Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by pornsleuth6 pornsleuth6

Who will come through that door this time?

The Weird Sisters Pt. 2

Hours had passed since Ambrose’s desecration and still no one. Sabrina must have fallen asleep at some point because she was rudely awakened by a soft slap on her cheek. She opened her eyes to the sight of Prudence looming over her.

“Hmm. What’s this I feel on your face?” She brought her own hand up to examine it. “Looks like somebody beat us to our prize. I wonder…” She dropped her face to Sabrina’s and gave a long slow lick to the side of her face.

“Oh my Brina. I’d recognize that taste anywhere. It looks like somebody got a little one man bukkake from their own cousin. Not quite so innocent anymore.”

“Tell me did he just cover your face or has he been as prolific as he was with me. Oh that’s right no talking for you”

“Agatha, be a dear and see if there’s any evidence of intrusion on your end, I’ll check this side.”

Sabrina was somehow still surprised by the perversion of the Weird sisters as Agatha’s tongue poked her butthole and Prudence started a one-sided tongue battle. The sisters allowed themselves to continue for a couple minutes before pulling away.

“Well, Sabrina I believe our beloved Ambrose has taken your mouth. I bet he was rough too. He always liked it rough. What about you Agatha? Anything to report?”

“I remain the only one to have been in her little butthole. Isn’t that marvelous?”

“Sister, your anal fixation is getting out of control. Give her pussy a quick lick, like you know I wanted you to in the first place.”

Sabrina trembled as she faced her first cunninlingus. Thankfully, Agatha was quick and unenthusiastic back there.

“Nope. Nothing on this end.”

“Good, good. Now that that’s all settled let’s get a move on. You see, Sabrina it’s time to transfer you to a more secluded location. We don’t want Ambrose to ruin our fun again now do we?”


The Weird Sisters finally had Sabrina to themselves. They had taken her into the middle of the woods at the dead of night. Nothing was going to stop them from slamming that shit now.

For the second time in 12 hours, Sabrina watched as they strapped on their magical dildos to take advantage of her. She had less hope for rescue this time but still felt less scared. Honesty after getting blasted by your own cousin as he degrades you, getting fucked by 2 hot witches didn’t seem so bad. That feeling of acceptance didn’t last long though. As soon as she felt Agatha spit on her ass, she remembered the crazy witches anal fixation and realized what was about to happen. She could handle getting fucked but being butt fucked; that just sounded painful.

“Here comes the airplane” teased Prudence as she swerved her magic dick in front of Sabrina’s face making sure to poke her face several times.

Agatha, lacking all subtlety and wanted to get to the main course, yelled “Choo Choo” before plunging her tip into Sabrina’s ass.

Sabrina was right; this was not pleasant at all. Things were only made worse when Prudence tired of teasing her and finally stuffed Sabrina’s face.

“Oh this is nice. I’ve been waiting for this for years.” Pump Pump Pump.

“We could have been having fun that whole time, but noooo perfect little hell princess is too pure. She won’t suck and fuck like a normal witch.” Pump Pump Pump

“Well, look at you now. Stuffed like a turkey and getting nothing out of it. Nothing but pain in the ass for our little pain in the ass.” Pump Pump Pumpedy

She wasn’t wrong. Agatha was all the way in by this point and it was still unpleasant for Sabrina. And a dick shoved in your throat wasn’t particularly fun either.

“Little ice princess gets in the butt. Turn her into an anal slut.” That was Agatha of course. Fully in now she began to pump in earnest from the back end. Still slower than the rapid thrusts from Prudence but at this pace that wouldn’t be true for long.

“I can’t lie, Sabrina; you really do have quite an effect on me. But, there is one more thing I want to do this time around.”

“Agatha, let’s move her over to that stump over there and lay her on her back.”

Sabrina was expecting a short respite but it didn’t come. The 2 sisters thrust as deep as possible before waddling over to the stump. This was somehow more humiliating than getting dickslapped or cum on. The sisters paused over the stump.

“On the count of three.” Sabrina has no idea what was going on. Also, how often do they do this to not need more communication for this?

“One...Two...Three” On three, they both twisted Sabrina. The girl turned like a pig on a spit before feeling the wood and her back and seeing the stars in the sky. She didn’t get to enjoy that view for long.

“I feel like I’m hogging you Brina. I think it’s time you see my sister do her work.” She positioned Sabrina so that she was staring at Agatha as she resumed mining her depths. Agatha looked even crazier than normal. Her tongue dangled from her mouth and her eyes rolled back in her head as she basked in the ecstasy of victory and booty.

“Don’t worry tho, princess. I’m not done with you. I must admit I’ve always been jealous of your hair. I thought this might be a nice way to overcome that resentment and end our first romp.” With that, Prudence grabbed a handful of Sabrina’s pretty locks and wrapped it around her cock. She wasted no time in going to town. For Sabrina, it was physically just a bit of hair pulling and emotionally just another dose of humiliation. For Prudence, it great, as silky soft as can be.

“I’d ask for your hair routine, but I’m not sure it would transfer over. Oh this is nice. You keep this soft. I might have to tell Ambrose to give this a try next time.”

Agatha had reached her end. She bottomed and leaned forward to make out with Sabrina as she made her deposit. Unfortunately for her, This sight pushed Prudence over the edge and she let loose. Cum was everywhere. A lot was in Sabrina’s ass but her hair, face, and neck got covered as well. Agatha was a victim of friendly fire and stared up to her sister in dismay with a face just plastered by her cum. The sisters didn’t have to process anything when suddenly

*BANG* A gunshot. They heard a thunk in the wood behind them and immediately turned tail to disappear into the night once again abandoning Sabrina to an uncertain fate.

Is Sabrina saved? Or is it just next batter up?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)