Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 71
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
The Weight of a Key
Roy had never moved so quickly through the lobby before.
The building's glass doors closed behind him with a soft hydraulic sigh, sealing him inside the familiar quiet. Late afternoon sunlight filtered through the tall front windows, casting long golden bands across the worn tile floor. The scent of industrial cleaner lingered faintly, sharp but clean.
Home.
The word felt different now. Not just a place to sleep. Not just a place to exist between workdays. Because someone was waiting for him.
The realization sent a quiet current of anticipation through his chest, subtle but persistent. For most of his adult life, returning home had meant unlocking a silent door, stepping into still air, confronting the quiet accumulation of his own solitary routines. Shoes off. Jacket hung. Television on for noise, not attention.
Tonight would be different.
Michelle was there.
His girlfriend.
His live-in girlfriend.
The words still felt fragile, like something that might dissolve if examined too closely.
At first he'd felt uncomfortable with the thought of hijacking Michelle's life, using the wish to change her destiny and line it up with his own. She deserved to be making her own choices, to live how she saw fit. She was young, only nineteen, and being chained to a forty-year-old man wasn't fair and wasn't right.
But now that they had been together for a couple days, Roy had a difficult time imagining a life without her. And just a difficult time imagining her life without him. They had become intertwined. She loved him.
And he, Roy had come to realize, loved her.
Despite feeling the urgency to get home to see Michelle, Roy had made two stops on his way home. Tonight was all about them, and he didn't want to show up empty-handed.
The flowers had come first.
The florist's shop had smelled like damp stems and fresh earth, the air thick with the perfume of a hundred blooming things. Roy hadn't known what he was looking for when he'd stepped inside. Flowers were unfamiliar territory. Something other men bought. Romantic men. Men who knew how to do these things properly.
A patient woman with silver hair and soft eyes had helped him choose. A modest bouquet. Nothing extravagant. Bright without being overwhelming. Warm colours. Welcoming colours. Something that said: You belong here.
And then the more important stop. The locksmith.
Right next door to the florist, walking in there had felt less playful and more serious. Not just because the man behind the counter looked at Roy as if he were more an annoyance than a customer, but because of what he was picking up. This gift wasn't romantic. It was a message. A symbol.
The shop had been narrow and cluttered, walls lined with blank keys hanging in neat rows, each one identical and full of possibility. The locksmith had worked efficiently, selecting the correct blank, feeding it into the cutting machine. Metal had shrieked softly as the blade carved grooves into the surface. Sparks had flickered briefly.
A key emerging from nothing.
Michelle's key.
Holding it for the first time had produced a strange tightness in Roy's chest. Not anxiety. Something deeper. Heavier.
Commitment.
Responsibility.
This was what people did when they built lives together. Quiet, practical gestures that transformed abstract relationships into physical reality.
He had wondered, briefly, if this was what buying an engagement ring felt like. The thought had startled him.
And then, impulsively, he'd asked for another.
Elaine's face had surfaced in his mind without warning. Elaine, with her calm confidence. Elaine, who had been first. It didn't feel right that Michelle should have a key and Elaine shouldn't. Not fair. Not balanced.
The second key now rested in his pocket alongside Michelle's, identical twins with very different futures.
He missed Elaine. Missed her voice. Missed her steadiness. He would call her tonight. Check in. Hear how her day had gone. The thought comforted him.
Back in the present, Roy stepped forward and pressed the call button on the elevator. The plastic surface flexed slightly beneath his finger. Above the doors, red numbers began their slow descent.
A sensation crept over him then. Subtle. Instinctive.
Not alone.
Movement in his peripheral vision drew his attention to the left. Agnes stood a few feet away, waiting.
She looked exactly as she had that morning, Golden hair falling perfectly over her shoulders. Makeup flawless. Clothes fitted precisely to a body engineered for admiration. She belonged in glossy advertisements, in curated social media feeds, in the imaginations of men who believed beauty implied virtue.
Getting to know her, though, had destroyed that illusion.
Coldness radiated from her without effort. Disdain lived in the set of her mouth, in the faint tightening around her eyes when she noticed him looking. Roy would never have noticed it before, so taken would he have been by her beauty. But now it was all he could see.
Her eyes darted up at him, then away. No recognition. No flicker of memory.
The wish had erased everything.
Relief flooded into him. The brief nightmare of their **** intimacy had vanished from her reality entirely. She saw him now as she always had: a neighbour. A man not worthy of her respect. Not as someone she had, just that morning, begged to show her "a woman's place" while he had her bend over her bed.
The elevator doors slid open.
Roy stepped inside and pressed the button for their floor. Agnes entered without speaking, positioning herself in the far corner. Distance, carefully maintained.
The doors closed.
The ascent began.
Michelle waited above them.
The thought reshaped everything. Agnes's presence became background noise. Irrelevant. Meaningless.
Michelle belonged here now. That fact was undeniable. And it came with implications. Practical ones. Legal ones. Protective ones.
The lease would need updating. The landlady would need to be informed. Michelle's presence would be formalized, documented, secured. No one, not Agnes, not anyone, would have grounds to challenge her right to exist in that space.
But there were other ways to make someone feel unwelcome in a building, ways that he suspected his neighbour would have no qualms in using.
Roy turned slightly.
"Agnes, right?" he said, keeping his tone polite. "I'm Roy. From down the hall."
A thin, exhausted smile appeared on her lips, the expression of someone enduring an inconvenience. Her phone emerged from her purse, screen lighting her face as she retreated into it.

Dismissal. Undeterred, Roy continued.
"Sorry to bother you. Just wanted to let you know my girlfriend moved in with me."
Her thumb paused. Interest, **** but unavoidable.
"You know... in case you see her around."
Silence. Roy pressed forward.
"Her name's Michelle. She's absolutely beautiful. Young Black woman. You can't miss her."
Agnes's eyes lifted.
The reaction was instantaneous. Shock. Displeasure. Calculation. All of it flickering across her face before discipline **** it back into neutrality.
Good.
"Just wanted you to know who she is in case you see each other in the hall. She's great. I'm sure you'll get along," Roy paused, then added, "Say hi if you get a chance. I want her to feel welcome."
The elevator chimed.
The doors opened.
Roy stepped out without waiting for a response, leaving Agnes behind with the weight of information she could neither ignore nor control. Perfect. He hoped he made her day just a little bit worse.
The hallway stretched before him. Home waited at the end.
His door.
His life.
His girlfriend.
The key slid smoothly into the lock. Metal turned. The mechanism yielded with a familiar click.
In his left hand, the flowers.
In his right, Michelle's key.
For a brief moment, Roy paused. Anticipation gathered in his chest, bright and electric. Then the handle turned, his hip nudging the door open as the words he'd been carrying all the way home finally escaped him.
"Honey, I'm home!"
She stood there.
Michelle.
Beautiful in a way that transcended simple physical description. The dress she wore traced her figure perfectly, dark floral fabric alive with colour. Hair framed her face in soft waves. Makeup subtle, deliberate. Her smile...
Her smile transformed the room.
Warmth flooded him instantly. Stress dissolved. The long day, Tom's hostility, the quiet unease of the wish, all of it fell away beneath the simple reality of her happiness at seeing him.
Something else caught his eye then.
The apartment.
Spotless.
Every surface gleamed. Everything aligned. Ordered. Perfect.
"You cleaned," Roy said, astonishment softening his voice.
Michelle stepped closer, her hand settling gently against his chest. Warm. Real.
"I was bored," she said, mischief dancing in her eyes. "Besides, I wanted everything perfect for my boyfriend."
Boyfriend.
He loved hearing her say it.
"Sounds like a lucky guy," Roy replied. "Let me know when he shows up so I can make myself scarce. I wouldn't want to cause any drama."
Her laugh came easily.
"Some of us like drama."
Then she kissed him.
The contact erased the last traces of distance between them. Michelle leaned into him fully, without hesitation, without reservation. Trust lived in that kiss. Need lived there too. Not desperation, but certainty. As though he were something fixed and reliable in a world that had never offered her stability before.
Roy responded in kind, his arms settling around her, holding her carefully. Affection came naturally. Love followed close behind it, startling in its intensity.
Days.
He'd known her only days. And yet the feeling was undeniable.
The wish had changed her. Had it changed him too? The question lingered, unanswered.
They separated slowly.
"Wow," Michelle breathed.
"Yeah," Roy agreed.
A sudden electronic chime shattered the quiet. Michelle's eyes widened.
"Dinner!" she gasped. "I cooked!"
She hurried away, heels clicking against hardwood, energy spilling from her in every movement.
Roy watched her go, something deep and quiet settling into place inside him. Gratitude. Whatever the wish had taken, whatever it had complicated, it had given him this moment.
And standing there in the doorway of a home that no longer felt empty, Roy allowed himself, just briefly, to be thankful.
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Everyone's Boyfriend
Becoming the kind of guy that women want...
Roy Robinson's life isn't going great. A soft middle, a work rival out to get him, and no love life to speak of. Suddenly, thanks to an errant wish, his life takes a dramatic turn for the better.
Updated on Jun 10, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Dec 26, 2025
by Mr Nice Guy
- 7,631 Likes
- 449,472 Views
- 1,089 Favorites
- 698 Bookmarks
- 108 Chapters
- 105 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments