Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 12 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

The Trail Ahead

Evan watched his mother slide into the driver's seat of the minivan and pull the door shut. The familiar thud landed heavier than it should have. The engine turned over, steady and reliable, the same sound he had grown up with. Early mornings. Long drives. Road trips that felt endless when he was a kid and impossibly short now.

Then Roy got in.

Front passenger seat. Like it was natural. Like it was where he belonged.

Evan tightened his grip on the urn resting in his lap. His father, Mark's, ashes. Thirty-two years old, Evan had rebuilt engines from the ground up, had handled wrecked cars and shattered metal without blinking. And still, this felt unreal. Like the universe had shrunk something enormous down to a size that fit between his knees just to mock him.

Roy buckled his seatbelt, fumbling slightly, and said something low to Elaine. She smiled at him.

Not a polite smile. Not a careful one.

The kind she used to give his dad.

Evan turned his face toward the window, jaw tight. He told himself, not for the first time, that he did not want to make this harder for her. That today was already heavy enough. That scattering his father's ashes was not the moment to pick a fight.

But it burned anyway.

This was supposed to be a family thing.

He had left his girlfriend at home without hesitation. Claire had not brought her fiancé. They had both understood, instinctively, that this was not a couples outing. It was private. It was sacred.

So why the hell was Roy here.

The van rolled away from the gas station, gravel crunching under the tires. Evan watched trees blur past, green layered on green, and tried to breathe evenly. He knew his feelings were tangled. Maybe Roy was an okay guy. Maybe. But every time Evan looked at him, all he could see was someone standing where his father used to stand.

And it felt like theft.

Roy was nothing like Mark. His dad had been tall, broad-shouldered, solid in a way that made you feel safer just being near him. An engineer who understood how things worked and why they failed. A man who fixed problems instead of circling them.

Roy was shorter. Heavier. Soft. Some office job Evan had never bothered to fully understand. Meetings and emails and spreadsheets. The kind of work that left nothing tangible behind.

It was unfair. Evan knew that. But grief was not interested in fairness.

His mother reached across the centre console and rested her hand on Roy's arm. Casual. Familiar. Her thumb brushed there absently, like muscle memory. She leaned toward him slightly and said something Evan could not hear.

Roy smiled.

Evan looked away.

Beside him, Claire shifted, sensing the tension without needing it explained. She always did. Even now, teaching drama to high school kids, she had that same awareness. Always reading people. Always trying to smooth things over.

The road narrowed as they turned toward the trailhead. The silence stretched too tight, and before Evan could stop himself, the words slipped out.

"So," he said, staring straight ahead. "Guess this is a group activity now."

Claire turned sharply. "Evan."

His mother's hand tightened on the steering wheel, but her voice stayed calm. "I know this is hard."

"That's not really the point," Evan said. He glanced toward Roy without quite looking at him. "This was supposed to be for us."

Roy shifted uncomfortably. "I, uh, don't mean to make things awkward," he said clumsily, turning around for the first time, his eyes drawn to the urn. Evan watched as Roy's eyes went wide, then he turned back to the front, as if it only now dawned on him how much of an intrusion his presence was.

Claire exhaled. "Can we please not do this right now?"

His mother nodded once. "Evan," she said gently but firmly, "I understand why you're upset. I really do. But Roy is part of my life. An important part of my life. I am not asking you to replace your father. I never would. I just need you to respect that I am allowed to love again."

There was no room to argue with that.

The rest of the drive passed quietly.

When his mother parked at the trailhead and shut off the engine, the sudden silence felt too loud. Evan opened the door and stepped out, the air cooler here, carrying the scent of pine and damp earth. He lifted the urn carefully, its weight grounding and unbearable all at once.

He looked at the trail ahead. Narrow. Winding. Disappearing into the trees.

There was no going back.

Evan turned back toward them. "Can I have a minute before we start?" he asked. His voice was steady, even if his chest was not. "I just... I need a minute."

His mother nodded immediately. "Of course."

He took the urn and walked a few steps away, stopping at the edge of the trail where the path narrowed. He stood there alone, the forest quiet around him, and looked down at the container in his hands.

"Hey, Dad," he said softly.

The words felt strange. Too small.

"I'm not okay with this," he admitted. "Not really. I don't like that she's moving on. I don't like that he's here. It feels wrong. It feels like she's letting go of you."

His throat tightened.

"But I know you," Evan continued. "I know what you'd say. You'd want her happy. You'd hate the idea of her being alone just because of you. You always put her first."

He swallowed hard.

"So I'm going to try. I don't promise I'll be good at it. I don't promise I won't be angry. But I'll try. For you."

Evan stood there a moment longer, breathing in the forest air, then nodded once.

Please log in to view the image

"Goodbye, Dad."

When he turned back toward the others, the trail waited.

And Evan stepped onto it.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)