THE PLAN!!

OH SHIT. The plan!!!
You can't fuck this up, Jenna will never forgive you. With all your willpower, you pull from Zoe's quivering snatch and violently roll her sideways, gripping the base of your cock.
"Come here, wife!" Jenna slides into Zoe's place, still hot and soaked with her girlcum.
"Give it to me James!" You pound your way in, and Jenna yelps with pain, but you hilt yourself, and start pounding. You can feel the crest. It's coming. You did it.
"I fucking love you baby...." you pant in Jenna's ear. "Oh fuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu..............." You pound mercilessly as you unleash a torrent of cum.
"YES! THANK YOU BABY! Give me your load..." Jenna's eyes are actually leaking tears. She really is so happy right now to be taking your creampie.
You collapse on top of your wife, and she sobs with joy and rubs your head.
"thankyou...thankyou....oh I knew it wasn't me....thankyou..." You look up and stroke her tears away with a finger.
"Of course not baby. And Zoe says if we do this more often, It'll retrain my dick."
"Oh we're going to be doing more of this, baby. No matter what." She reaches out to pull Zoe's head onto hers, kissing her passionately.
After about 20 minutes of just kissing each other and giggling together, you stand up on wobbly legs. Jenna's phone is blinking on the bureau top.

12:13 (25 minutes ago)
Karen: wwtf are you 3 doin n thurr??>? Killn a cat?
Karen: its fuckonh hot
Karen: Ive cum twice jus6t listening

uh oh. You guess, you really weren't being very discreet. You hope that the girls downstairs didn't hear anything. You can hear the thump of music from Riley's room, so maybe not.
You toss Jenna her phone, and she curses.
"FUCK. Well...looks like we might have to include Karen next time." she shows the phone to Zoe, who starts laughing hysterically.
You take turns sneaking down to the first floor bathroom to shower, with some overlap between you and Zoe, and then you and Jenna.
You head back to the bedroom with Jenna, and you both collapse onto the bed, exhausted and sated. You spoon your sexy wife, and feel true contentment.