Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by MeowJustMe

What's next?

Storyline 5 - Standalone Chapter

The Instagram photo loads on my screen, and Jordan Miller is sitting cross-legged on her bed, surrounded by fairy lights and half-finished design prints, looking at the camera like she doesn't care whether anyone's watching.

She has choppy pink hair and a silver chain at her throat, and there's a tattoo on her forearm—a geometric fox, minimalist, clean lines. She's wearing a charcoal silk camisole and high-waisted culottes, and her feet are bare. The industrial windows behind her show a grey January sky. The caption says "deadline szn" with a skull emoji.

I've been staring at this photo for twenty minutes. My sister Lena's work shoes are by the door, and her uniform is gone from the hook—she's on the night shift again, which means the apartment is mine until morning. The refrigerator hums. My knuckles catch on the fabric of my jeans when I shift my weight. I've been meaning to buy lotion.

Jordan Miller. Twenty-five. Graphic designer. Girlfriend of Madison Brooks—I've seen Madison's photos too, the polished blonde with the sharp smile. They look good together. They look like the kind of couple that makes other people feel like they're missing something.

The ache is there again. That hollow, pulling thing under my ribs. I don't want to be with Jordan. I want to be her. I want to know what it feels like to have pink hair and a silver chain and a girlfriend who looks at you like you're the only thing in the room that matters. I want to wear that silk camisole. I want to hear that low, unhurried voice come out of my own mouth.

I let the longing sharpen. I let it become everything I am.

The photo blurs at the edges. The colors bleed outward—charcoal and blush and the warm gold of fairy lights—and my dark room dissolves into white. For a heartbeat I am nowhere, a consciousness suspended in brightness.

Then the flood.

The incense hits me first. Sandalwood and something darker—coffee, maybe, or old paper. The air fills my lungs—her lungs—and the chest that rises is smaller than mine, the breath sitting higher, tighter. I taste coffee and the faint, clean trace of bergamot. The fairy lights are gold in my peripheral vision, and the mattress beneath me is soft, covered in a grey duvet that's bunched up under my crossed legs.

I look down. My legs. Slender, clad in high-waisted culottes the color of charcoal. My feet are bare, the nails unpainted, a small silver ring on one toe. My hands are resting on my knees—slender hands, pale, with a geometric fox tattooed on the left forearm and silver rings on three fingers. The silk camisole is cool against my skin, and under it, my chest is different. Small. Round. Perky breasts that move when I breathe. I can feel the straps of the camisole on my shoulders, thin and delicate, and the air is cool on my bare arms in a way I've never experienced before.

I lift one hand and press it to my throat. Smooth. No Adam's apple. A silver chain rests in the hollow of my collarbone, and when I swallow, I feel the movement under my palm—narrower, softer.

"Holy shit," I say.

The voice is low. Unhurried. A slight rasp at the edge of it. It resonates in a throat that's shaped differently, a mouth that's smaller, and the words come out in short, direct syllables. Jordan's voice. My voice.

"That's valid," I say, just to hear it again. "I'm here."

The phrases sit on my tongue like they've always been there. I know them. I know everything—her name, her address, her passcode, her girlfriend's coffee order, the freelance client who's been emailing her at midnight with impossible revisions. Her mother's voice on the phone last Sunday. The way Madison's hand feels in hers. The first time they kissed, at a gallery opening, Madison's lips tasting like champagne.

I'm in Jordan's studio apartment. The exposed brick wall, the drafting table covered in design prints, the closet that blends combat boots with ballet flats. The smell of incense and coffee and the faint, sweet trace of the bergamot perfume on her wrists. The fairy lights strung across the ceiling. Everything is exactly where her memories say it should be.

I stand up. The world is at the wrong height—I'm 5'6" now, and the drafting table is slightly taller than I expect, the doorframe higher. My center of gravity has shifted. The breasts on my chest pull forward, just slightly, and my hips sway when I take a step in a way I didn't tell them to.

"Jordan," I say, walking toward the mirror on the closet door. "Jordan Miller."

The girl in the mirror is Jordan Miller. Choppy pink bob, soft waves. Grey-blue eyes, large and expressive, winged eyeliner sharp at the corners. Fair skin, a few freckles across the bridge of her nose. The silver chain glints at her throat. The charcoal camisole drapes over small, round breasts, and the high-waisted culottes cinch at a defined waist.

I lift my hand. She lifts hers. I touch my cheek—her cheek—and the skin is smooth and cool. I trace the line of my jaw, the curve of my lips, the slight bump of a cartilage piercing in my left ear. I tilt my head. She tilts hers. I smile. It's a small, unhurried smile, the kind I've never made before.

My lips. My eyes. My face.

The memory surfaces without warning—triggered by the denim jacket hanging on the back of the closet door, by the painted mural on its back panel, by the faint smell of acrylic and old perfume.

I'm sitting on the floor of this same apartment, wearing this same camisole, and Madison is behind me with a paintbrush. It's our first anniversary. She's painting a mural on the back of my denim jacket—a geometric fox, like the one on my arm, but bigger, bolder, surrounded by flowers. "Hold still," she says, and her voice is bright and focused, and I can feel the brush moving across the denim in slow, careful strokes. "This is going to be your best piece." She's wrong—it's going to be hers. She just doesn't know it yet.

The memory fades, and I'm standing in the mirror, my hand resting on the cool glass. The denim jacket is behind me, the fox mural facing the room. I've worn it a hundred times. I know this. I was there.

The wardrobe is waiting. I've been aching to do this for years.

The closet is a blend of contradictions. Combat boots next to ballet flats. A pleated leather miniskirt hanging beside a tulle midi in blush. Silk camisoles in charcoal, cream, olive. A velvet wrap dress in deep green. High-waisted culottes in three colors. The oversized blush denim jacket with Madison's mural. I run my fingers along the garments—the silk, the velvet, the soft worn denim—and the textures are a language I'm only just learning to read.

I pull out the velvet wrap dress. Deep green, soft as water. The tie wraps around the waist, and when I hold it up against my body, the color is striking against my fair skin, my pink hair.

I undress. The camisole slides off my shoulders and pools on the floor. The culottes unzip and drop. My underwear—a simple black bralette and matching boyshorts, soft cotton with a thin elastic band—stays on. The room is warm, the fairy lights casting gold across my skin. My breasts in the black bralette, small and round. My waist, defined. My hips, gentle and curved. My legs, long and slender, the geometric fox standing out against my pale forearm.

The velvet dress wraps around me. I tie it at the side, and the fabric settles against my body like it was made for me—because it was. The skirt ends mid-thigh, and when I turn, the velvet moves with a weight that silk doesn't have. A drape. A presence.

"Oh my god," I whisper. The voice is Jordan's, low and unhurried, and it fills the quiet studio. "Oh my god."

I pull the denim jacket off the door and slide it on over the dress. The sleeves are slightly too long, the way Jordan likes them, and the weight of the denim settles on my shoulders. The fox mural is on my back now, hidden from the mirror, but I know it's there. I can feel Madison's brushstrokes in the way the fabric sits.

I look in the mirror. The girl looking back at me is Jordan Miller, dressed in a green velvet dress and an oversized denim jacket painted with foxes and flowers. Her pink hair is soft and choppy. Her winged eyeliner is still sharp. Her silver chain catches the fairy lights. Behind her eyes—behind my eyes—is me. The boy with the rough knuckles and the shoulders he hates and the sister who works nights. The boy who wanted this for years.

I don't wink. I don't grin. I just stand there, breathing, being her. The body is starting to feel less like a costume and more like mine.

The afternoon light shifts, and my phone buzzes on the nightstand. Jordan's phone. My phone. The lockscreen is a photo of her and Madison at the beach, both of them laughing, Madison's blonde hair whipping across her face.

A text from Madison: hey you. dinner tonight? that thai place?

My heart—Jordan's heart—does a small, warm flip. The emotional impression is there, immediate and deep: Madison is her home. The steady, grounding presence in a life that can feel chaotic. The love is real, and I feel it in my chest like it's mine.

I type back with Jordan's fingers: i'm here. what time?

7? i'll come get you.

that's valid.

I set down the phone. My hands are steady, but my mind is racing. Dinner. With Madison. I'm going to have to be Jordan—fully, completely, in front of the person who knows her best.

The thrill of it unspools in my chest like a dark ribbon. And underneath it, something else. The quiet, steady affection that Jordan feels for Madison, now layered with my own awareness of the deception. I'm going to sit across from her and order Thai food and listen to her talk about her day, and she's going to look at me with love, and she'll have no idea that behind these grey-blue eyes is someone else entirely.

Madison arrives at seven exactly. She's wearing a black jumpsuit and pointed-toe heels, and her blonde hair is in a high ponytail. When she sees me—sees Jordan—her whole face changes. A slow, warm smile. The kind of smile that reaches her eyes.

"Hey, you," she says. Her voice is bright and confident, the voice of someone who's used to being in charge. "You look amazing. Is that the velvet dress?"

"Yeah," I say. My voice comes out in Jordan's low, unhurried register, and the word is short, direct, exactly the way Jordan would say it. "The one from the gallery opening."

"You wore that on our first date." Madison steps closer, and her hand finds mine—her fingers lacing through my fingers, her palm warm against my palm. The contact sends a shiver up my arm. She's touched Jordan a thousand times. She's never touched me. "You okay? You seem a little quiet."

"I'm here," I say. "Just thinking."

"About the deadline?"

"Among other things."

Madison squeezes my hand and leans in to kiss my cheek. Her lips are soft, and she smells like expensive perfume—Jo Malone, something floral. The gesture is casual, automatic, the kind of affection that comes from years of intimacy. And I feel it in Jordan's body like a warmth spreading through my chest.

The restaurant is a small Thai place with fairy lights and mismatched chairs. Madison orders for both of us—she always does, and Jordan always lets her, and tonight I let her too. The food is spicy and good, and Madison talks about her product launch and her mother and the luxury listing that's been giving her nightmares. I listen the way Jordan listens: with my whole attention, with small sounds of agreement, with the occasional "that's valid" that makes Madison's shoulders relax.

Halfway through the meal, she reaches across the table and takes my hand again. Her thumb traces circles on my knuckles—Jordan's knuckles, my knuckles—and she looks at me with an expression I've only ever seen directed at other people. Unguarded. Full of love.

"What?" I say.

"Nothing. I just—" She pauses, and her voice goes a little softer. "I'm glad you're here. That's all."

I squeeze her hand back. "I'm here," I say. And I mean it. In this moment, in this body, in this life—I'm here.

After dinner, Madison drops me at my apartment—Jordan's apartment—and kisses me on the cheek before she drives away. I stand at the door and watch her taillights disappear, and the cold January air nips at my bare legs under the velvet dress.

Inside, the studio is quiet. The fairy lights are still on. The incense has burned out. I stand in the center of the room, breathing, being her, and the weight of the evening settles over me. I did it. I sat across from Madison Brooks and ate Thai food and held her hand, and she looked at me with love, and she never suspected a thing.

The thrill of it is still there. But underneath it, something quieter. The body is starting to feel less like a costume. The voice is simply my voice. When I think I, I mean myself—not Jordan, not the boy I was this morning, but whoever I am now.

I undress for bed. The denim jacket goes back on its hanger. The velvet dress is folded on the chair. The bralette and boyshorts—I leave them on. I pull on an oversized t-shirt from the laundry basket—a faded thing from a design conference—and climb into her bed. The duvet is soft and grey, and the pillows smell like sandalwood and bergamot.

The body is warm and real and mine. The fairy lights glow gold above me. Somewhere in the city, Madison is driving home, thinking about the dinner, thinking about me.

I don't want to leave. But I know I have to. First time. Test run. I need to know I can come back.

I close my eyes and will myself to return.

The world snaps back. I'm in my room, on my bed, my phone in my hand. The Instagram photo is still on the screen. Jordan is still looking at me with that same expression. No time has passed.

But everything is wrong. My shoulders are too broad—I can feel them pressing into the mattress, wide and heavy. My hand is rough, the knuckles catching on the denim of my jeans. The air has no taste. Just oxygen. Just nothing. Through the wall, the refrigerator hums. Lena's work shoes are still by the door. The world is gray. Not metaphorically—like someone turned a dial and drained the color out.

I close my eyes. For a second—less than a second—I smell sandalwood and bergamot. Jordan's perfume. It's gone before I can hold onto it.

I lie back on my bed. The ceiling is white and blank. My chest is flat under my t-shirt, and the weight that was there an hour ago—a lifetime ago—is gone. The fairy lights are gone. The velvet dress is gone. Madison's hand in mine is gone.

But I was her. For one perfect, impossible evening, I was her. And I know how to go back.

My phone is still in my hand. The photo app is right there. I look at it for a long moment. Then I set it down on the nightstand. Not tonight. Tomorrow. I'll go back tomorrow.

For now, I just breathe. And I remember what it felt like to be her.

What's next?

  • No further chapters

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)