Sex or Permanent Erotic Statue?

The next morning Chloe awoke and giggled at the miniature naked statue that she had turned James into, picked him up and spoke to him softly.

"I hope the view you had last night you had makes up for the inconvenience of your situation" she told him "I have a plan to convince the others to let you stay. It won't sound good to you, but you have to trust me. It will stop you from spending eternity as an erotic statue and will allow us to have more fun together while I figure a way out of this for you, okay?"

James was hardly in a position to question this as he was carried downstairs by cute blonde witch and placed on the dining room table where the whole house had gathered to decide his fate. James was restored to human size but remained in statue form, unable to participate in the discussion about him.

"You are up late today Chloe?" Dorothy raised an eyebrow accusingly "Anyway, no matter. We have already decided that Toad will be sold as a life sized statue. I have a buyer lined up and we stand to make a significant sum of money. He will be put on display for any number of wealthy, shall we say, art enthusiasts to enjoy, so everyone is happy, no?"

"Well, we could do that I guess" Chloe began "But I think I have a better idea"

"She wants to keep him" Abigail sneered "She has I thing for Toad!"

"Yes, we all heard the noises you were making last night" another witch who James hadn't been introduced to yet added.

"Well, it's true that I fucked Toad last night" Chloe admitted to everyone's' surprise "And it was good. For me. But he didn't enjoy it. Look at him, he is just a terrified statue"

"So, you are saying we keep him like that and use him as an oversized dildo?" Dorothy folded her arms in dissaproval.

"I'm saying we make him our sex ****!" Chloe enthused "We enchant him to remain totally obedient to us and to never age. We make him mute. He exists only for us to act out our most degrading, humiliating, kinky and downright disgusting sexual fantasies on. He can neither object or tell anyone. Whatever any of you do to Toad or make him do to you will remain your hot, dirty little secret."

Chloe scanned the room, she had definitely captured her sister interest.

"So, shall we vote on it?"