Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 25 by Cheesers123
What's next?
Sarahs name is drawn
Nicoles mouth hangs slightly open as stated in her dare as she pulls out a piece of paper. As she reads the slip she looks increasingly nervous. For a second you think the worst has happened and she's drawn Tom. "Sarah." She announces, assuaging your concerns somewhat, although Sarah could still be pretty naughty in her dares. The second the red haired girls name is announced she bounces from Toms lap and sets to work opening the large black box brought downstairs earlier. Nicole watches with trepidation before she speaks again. "Tom, do I get to dare Sarah?" She asks. He thinks for a second before answering, "Only after she's put something in your mouth." Nicole nods and goes back to awaiting her fate like a prisoner on death row.
"Actually Nicole." Sarah says while sorting through all sorts of rubber and leather implements. "You might have a problem with daring me after this." When she says that she produces with a flourish a black leather ball gag, with a shiny red ball. There's a chorus of giggles and guffaws from most of you while Matt frowns and Nicole groans loudly. "You've gotta be kidding me." She says, slumping her shoulders in frustration. "Oh don't be like that Nicole." Sarah chides her, twirling the gag around on one finger. "You might discover you like it." She advances menacingly on your kneeling friend until Nicole throws her hands up and shouts "Wait" Wait!" Sarah halts her wicked approach, raising an eyebrow. "Before you put it on me can I ask two questions?"
"Fine." Sarah sighs, clearly eager to get on with things.
"First, how long does it stay on for?" She asks, looking from Tom to Sarah.
Tom looks a little puzzled, clearly he hadn't planned for this to be a dare that would last more than a round. "Until someone draws your name I guess." He replies, scratching his chin.
"Okay, second of all, how am I gonna give dares with that thing in my mouth?"
Sarah doesn't wait for Toms answer, instead she just sighs irritably, reaches for the same notebook the slips had been torn from and tosses it on the ground in front of Nicole. "There." She says, putting her hands on her hips. "Now can we get on with this?" Nicole doesn't say another word, instead she just opens her mouth wide and tilts her head back a little. Sarah quickly sets to work, slipping the ball between Nicoles widespread teeth before fitting on the straps. "You know, all these rules made this a lot less fun than I hoped it would be." She says, as she pulls and tightens a strap behind Nicoles head. "Sometimes it's more enjoyable to just go with the flow, you know." As she says this she runs her tongue over the ball, brushing against Nicoles open lips.
While Sarah makes her finishing touches you lean forward and whisper into Mirandas ear. "Poor Nicole. That can't be comfortable." Your voice half joking and half pitying.
"You never know. Some girls love being treated like that." Miranda responds, shrugging. "Some girls?" You echo, flirtatiously putting a hand on her throat. "Yes some girls." She giggles, playfully stopping your hands. "And some guys like getting their balls stomped on." She warns, barely hiding the laughter in her voice. "Noted." You say simply, letting go of her neck , making Miranda laugh that cute, pure laugh of hers that you can never hear enough of.
Back in the middle of the room Sarah is satisfied with Nicoles new accessory and she stands up to admire her work. "You know Nicole." She says, putting her hand on Nicoles blonde head. "This is a good look for you." Nicole merely glares at her as she stands up, unable to reply. "I really love how you can't talk back." Sarah laughs as Nicole picks up the notebook and stalks back to Matt. While she sulks back into Matts lap he speaks. "You know Sarah, since Nicole drew you, you have to go back to John now." He says it somewhat smugly, as if eking out some measure of revenge on Nicoles behalf.
You and Sarah both share a moment of cold eye contact before Sarah speaks. "Fine." She huffs, moving to get up, but Tom grabs her. "Nope." He announces, pulling Sarah back against him by her wrists. She falls giggling into his lap as he continues. "The dare was that she had to stay here, no matter what, until her name was called. Now she's back to normal girls rules which means she stays where she is." You consider arguing with him (You're sure he's wrong) but, truth be told, now you have Miranda sat on your lap instead you really don't care. "Fine." You shrug your shoulders, a sentiment shared by everyone else. Sarah squeals in delight at staying with her former captor. " I'm sure glad I get to spend more time with you!" She exclaims happily. "And with this." She continues, dropping her voice as she rubs the noticeably large bulge in Toms pants. "I'm telling you Miranda, you're really missing out." She teases, her hand slowly sliding back and forth over Toms jeans.
"I'm sure I am." Miranda replies sarcastically, rolling her eyes. But you could have sworn you saw her blush and felt her squirm a little. "Anyway, Nicole." Sarah says, turning the attention back to your gagged friend. "Have you written something yet?" With a few elegant strokes Nicole finishes scratching a dare on the page and nods her head, fire in her eyes as she looks at Sarah.
What does the note say?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Afterparty
Six friends continue the party with a naughty game.
A group of friends gets closer than ever.
Updated on Jan 16, 2026
by Cheesers123
Created on Aug 28, 2014
by Cloontang1
You can customize this story. Simply enter the following details about the main characters.
- 51,522 Likes
- 19,238,854 Views
- 4,165 Favorites
- 9,754 Bookmarks
- 3,243 Chapters
- 106 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Comments