Sarah

John sat down, not bothering to get back dressed. His throbbing cock bouncing up and down in front of him, begging for attention after Miranda was done distracting him from his dare. His ass was feeling weird, home to a butt plug for the first time, or anything for the first time really. He pulled Sarah's name and decided he was done, no one seemed to care when Tom used a dare to get off so why shouldn't he?

"Sarah, since you seem fascinated with things in asses tonight I dare you to let me fuck your ass!" You belt out, too horny and fed up to care about what Matt feels. This is Sarah we're talking about, if he can get over everyone else that she's fucked he can deal with you fucking her once.

"About time one of you manned up, was getting so horny I was worried I'd have to dare one of you myself to do it." As she says this she gets on her knees on the couch, pointing her pussy and tight winking ass hole towards you. It was obvious she had already been playing with it and that she was more then ready for you. Not sparing a second glance back at Matt you get on the couch behind her and taking your hard cock in hand begin to work it into Sarah's ass. You're sure she laid this way on the couch on purpose, with both of you facing Tom and Nicole with him still fucking away at her, though she seemed to have regained her energy and was being more active in it.

Even with her prepping for it it was still a tight fit for you. Sarah was grunting as she pushed back working more of you into her until finally you get your whole length in and feel your balls resting against her hot pussy. "Fuck John, really making me work for this huh." She sounded out of breath, but very pleased with herself. After what seemed like long enough for her to get used to it you decide to give her what she really wants and you really need.

Not bothering to start slow you just begin pounding her tight ass as hard as you can, you slap her ass hard enough to leave a hand print, you grab a handful of her red hair and pull making sure to get your cock as deep into her as you can. She's fucking loving it letting out moans and incoherent dirty talk, at some point she even stops calling you John and begins just calling you Daddy. Watching your hard fucking of Sarah just seemed to spur Tom on more and Nicole seemed fully lost in her pleasure. Then suddenly he just slams Nicole down hard on his cock and her eyes and mouth shoot open and you could tell Tom was filling her with his cum. After the initial shock wears off Nicole just gives you a happy dirty smile followed by a wink before leaning back into Tom.

You can feel yourself getting close to cumming, but you're trying to hold off as you can tell Sarah is on the verge of a really big one herself. She's chanting the word "Daddy" getting louder and louder and slamming her ass harder and harder back into you before suddenly screaming "FUCK!" and suddenly you feel something spray between and all over your legs. Feeling Sarah squirt all over you and the couch seemed to trigger something primal in your brain as you fill her tight asshole with your built up cum from tonight, you swear it felt like you were shooting rope after rope for about a minute.You promptly collapse back into the now wet couch before Sarah practically pounces back on you.

"Holy fuck John, that was fucking amazing! Why have we never fucked before?" She asked and without giving you a chance to answer gives you a deep kiss. You kiss back questioning yourself why you never tried to fuck her. After breaking off the kiss she begins stroking your slick semi hard cock. "Well that's going to change, I'm going to be on your cock every chance I get." She then got close to your ear and whispered "Daddy" Before biting your earlobe.