Sarah comes home from the game

Tom dozed off with Abby in his arms. He awoke sometime later that night to noise from the hall. He blearily opened his eyes and could see light from under the door. Abby had rolled off him while they slept and was now curled up against him. Figuring that Natalie/Sarah must be home, he slid out of bed being careful not to wake Abby. He pulled on his robe and slipped quietly out the door.

Sarah was stepping into her room so he quickly walked down the hall after her. He just caught her door as she was closing it. "Daddy!" she gasped, just managing to keep it to a loud whisper. "You surprised me! Sorry I'm so late but the girls wanted to celebrate with the team, so we went over to Jay's house after the game.

Tom glanced at his watch. It was almost 3am! "That must have been some celebration," he smirked. "The game was over at what, 9? 10 at the latest?" Sarah stammered out an excuse while he examined her appearance. She looked very disheveled and had the smell of recent sex all over her. He decided to cut 'Natalie' short. "Sarah, wake up," he said, interrupting her.

Her eyes widened as the 'Sarah' personality took over once again and processed the night's events. She smiled at Tom. "My god Tom, you wouldn't believe the night I had! I fucked 7 guys ... well, I had sex with them in one way or another - pussy, ass, mouth... I used everything," she said almost proudly. "I'm REALLY good!" she beamed.

Tom stared at her for a moment, unsure whether he was upset, jealous, or aroused by Sarah's explanation. She gave a small laugh at his expression and pulled him into her room. "Don't worry Daddy, I still have enough energy left for you," she teased.

She loosened his robe and let it fall open. "Oh my!" she said as she took in his naked body and his growing erection. "I see you came ready for your baby girl." She let her uniform drop to the floor. He saw that she wasn't wearing any underwear underneath! "I've been very bad tonight, Daddy. I let lots of dirty boys touch me." She ran her fingers down his chest. "They kissed me. Put their penises in my - in my mouth, my ass ..." She took his hand and pressed it against her crotch. "... and in here too. I've been so very, very naughty. A dirty, slutty girl. But I'll always be your baby girl first."

It was obvious that Sarah hadn't really cleaned up from her night of sex, but Tom found he didn't care. He was so incredibly turned on by her appearance and behavior that he couldn't wait. He pushed her back onto her bed. She giggled with excitement and spread her legs open wide. "You don't want to play, Daddy? You just want to fuck your slutty daughter?"

Without a word he plunged into her, holding her down on the bed while he forcefully fucked her, harder than he had ever been with Sarah before. Her giggles turned into little mewing sounds, then moans of pleasure. "That's right, fuck me Daddy!" she cried out, wrapping her legs around him. He grunted as he came into her. "Oh GOD!!!!" she screamed out before biting her lip to keep quiet. Tom collapsed beside her on the bed. "That was something else. I didn't think you had that in you. To talk so dirty...so perverted," Tom told her.

Sarah took a few seconds to catch her breath, so she just smiled at him. Finally she answered "I don't know how much is a part of me we've just never explored and how much is because of all this, but I fuckin' love it." She leaned over and gave him a deep, long kiss that was interrupted by a knock on the door.

Abby's voice came through the door. "Natalie, are you alright? I thought I heard you cry out..."