Round Two: Fuck

Dinah and I panted heavily as I rested on top of her. Our naked bodies were slick with perspiration and the undeniable musk of sex.

My semi-hard cock rested within Dinah's welcoming hot cunt.

I'd never felt more satisfied in my life.

"That... that was incredible," I croaked.

The older woman glared at me, but the intensity of it was far diminished by the look of utter satisfaction on her face. My heart skipped a beat.

"Hmph. It'd have been even better if you hadn't played games with me earlier and took your punishment like a man," she said.

I chuckled at her. I couldn’t help it. It was so funny having this super hot metahuman babe think the only way to correct my bad behavior was to let me fuck her and cum inside her.

Dinah narrowed her piercing blue eyes at me and wrapped her thick, muscular thighs around my waist.

“Well it looks like you clearly haven’t been taught a proper lesson,” Dinah said.

I merely raised my eyebrows.

“How am I supposed to be taught a lesson if you’re just using me to get yourself off?” I told her. “It’s not my fault your fiancé can’t fuck you properly.”

Dinah blushed.

“No, I suppose it isn’t,” she said. “But you are at fault for ruining my relationship."

At my questioning look she continued, "How am I supposed to go back to Oliver after I’ve had such mind-blowing sex with you? You deserve every depraved sexual punishment I dole out to you and more.”

My cock twitched.

I smirked and said, “Did you like how my big fat criminal cock felt inside you? Would you even notice Oliver’s if he fucked you again? What would he say if he knew that you preferred having sex with someone you ought to be arresting than your own fiancé?”

The blonde nodded at me. Her freshly fucked pussy clamped down around my dick again. Her velvety walls massaged me, encouraging me to get hard again.

“I imagine he wouldn’t be too happy about that,” she bit her lip. God, she was so sexy. “You might be a worthless criminal, but you fucked me far more thoroughly than Oliver ever has. But that’s only part of it. You’re… you’re better than him. Your eyes, your skin, the way you smell… God, even your voice sounds nicer than Oliver’s. Oh! God, just saying that is such a fucking turn-on.”

She paused for a moment, a thoughtful expression on her face. After a few seconds, she smirked at me like a police officer who had a notorious fugitive at her complete mercy.

“I still have another hole you haven't... explored,” Dinah squeezed me with her cunt again. My cock twitched and was well on its way to reaching full hardness. She craned her neck upward so she could nibble on my earlobe.

“I was going to give Oliver my ass for his wedding present, but I'm willing to give it to you instead. No one’s ever been there before,” she whispered. Dinah licked my earlobe. “I want you to use my asshole until you’re satisfied. I want to feel you spurt your disgusting, thick, beautiful cum into my tight virgin ass.”

I stared at the couch beneath me with wide eyes, not fully believing what I was hearing.

“You’d like that, wouldn’t you?” she placed her face in front of mine again. She smiled devilishly. “To take what I was going to give to the man I love most in the world? You can have it. Any way you want. I’ve been preparing myself since he proposed.”

I blinked at her.

“Preparing yourself?” My throat suddenly felt incredibly dry.

Dinah nodded. “My friend Helena said I should start getting into anal to spice up my sex life with Oliver. Prevent him from getting bored with married life. I couldn’t believe that a man would want to have sex with me that way, but Helena explained to me that the taboo nature of the act made it appealing to a lot of men. So, I bought a few… toys, and started practicing.”

"Do you have any with you now? Butt toys, I mean," I asked, a shiver of anticipation running down my spine. I hadn't actually expected to be able to fuck Black Canary's ass so soon, so I was rather excited.

Dinah glanced meaningfully at her large purse, which had be unceremoniously deposited near my door.

"Mhm," she hummed. "I'm really glad Helena put that idea into my head. I doubt I'd be able to take your monster cock back there otherwise."

"Hm," I hummed. Maybe it'd be wise of me to make a few changes to make things a little easier going forward.

I made eye contact with Dinah and watched with no small amount of satisfaction as her face slackened and her mind opened to me.

"Can you hear me, Dinah?"

"Yes," she answered flatly. Her cerulean eyes had a distant look about them that I was really beginning to like.

"You've been curious about anal sex since your friend Helena suggested it to you, right?"

Dinah nodded her head.

"You're even more curious about anal now that you've promised to take my big cock up your ass. The curiosity goes beyond you simply punishing me for stealing. Oh, you'll still use it as an excuse to get me to fuck you, but secretly you'll love every second that my cock is inside your asshole. It'll feel better than sex you've had with anyone besides me. Every time I thrust inside you, you'll become more and more aware of the fact that I'm better than Oliver in every way. You'll want to spend more time with me so I'll fuck you again, but you won't know how to justify it until I cum inside your asshole. When that happens, you'll come to realize that I need more than punishment from you; I need a mentor. A superheroine mentor to guide me through life and teach me right from wrong. And there's no better way for you to set me on the right path than to take my cock in every one of your holes and let me cum inside you whenever I want. You'll feel the need to dedicate a significant portion of your life to mentoring me, but you know other people won't understand how amazing your mentorship techniques are so you'll keep them a secret between the two of us," I said. I coughed. Fuck, I really have to find a way make my language more concise or I'll lose my voice.

Dinah just stared blankly at me.

"Uh, did you get all that?" I asked.

"Yes," Dinah said.

I broke eye contact with her. She blinked a few times before raising her eyebrows.

"You'll have to get off me if you're going to get anywhere near my ass," she said.

Reluctantly, I slid my now-hard cock out of Dinah's pussy with an audible 'plort'. Rivulets of thick white semen spilled from the confines of her folds. Dinah sighed and reached a finger down to her cunt, smearing it with my white juices. She brought her finger to her mouth and wrapped her plump lips around it. She gulped audibly and withdrew her finger from her mouth.

She smiled at me.

"Hm. You even taste better than Oliver," she said. She stood up from the couch and walked over to where her purse sat on the floor. Her big tits wobbled and swayed as she walked. My eyes fell to her delectable bubble butt as she passed me. Her soft, fat white cheeks jiggled as she put an extra sway in her hips.

She bent over instead of crouching down, sticking her prodigious ass in the air.

Fuck. It seemed like she'd discovered my weakness.

I bit my lip and walked up behind Dinah as she rifled through her purse. I put my hands on her big, juicy globes and squeezed.

The blonde looked back at me, the ghost of a smirk on her face. She pushed her ass into my hands.

“What is with you criminals and being obsessed with my ass?” Dinah asked. She didn’t wait for my answer, instead holding out a bottle of a clear liquid for me to take. She then braced herself against the wall and stuck her ass out at me. “Here, make yourself useful and start applying that to my asshole. Don’t overdo it, stud.”

I didn’t miss the way she bit her lip when she said that last word. Holy fuck.

I stared at the clear plastic container in my hands. So this was lube, huh. I looked back at Dinah. I could see her sphincter. The tight little hole twitched when I squirted some of the lubricant into my hand.

I spread her asscheeks apart with my hand, delighting at the sight of her sphincter stretching slightly. I licked my lips.

My right index finger crested the edge of Dinah's sphincter. The older woman moaned and shivered.

"You okay?" I asked.

"It's a little cold," she muttered, glancing back at me with an uncharacteristically apprehensive look on her face.

I guessed she was feeling the nerves from having her anal virginity taken, even if she tried to hide it.

I navigated my finger into the center of her asshole and pushed.

Dinah tensed. Her backdoor clamped down on my lubricated finger like a vice grip. I pushed onwards, pinching and kneading her left asscheek with my other hand as I did so.

When my finger disappeared all the way up to the knuckle, I inserted another one.

"Oh shit," she muttered.

I wriggled my fingers around in there, eliciting sharp gasps and moans from the older woman.

My cock was rock hard at the sight of this powerful woman just letting me have my way with her ass. The fact that she could absolutely tear me apart made me feel even more powerful and dominant.

"Has Oliver ever played with you ass?"

"Ugh..." she moaned when I inserted a third finger. "N-no."

I slapped her ass, causing her assflesh to jiggle and ripple.

"Oh!" Dinah whimpered. Her quivering asshole clenched around my fingers.

"Did that turn you on?" I said.

The superherione narrowed her eyes at me.

"Oh you'd like that, wouldn't you, you per-"

I smacked her ass again. She bit lip and whimpered. Her tight hole twitched around my fingers. Huh, turned out being a badass superherione hadn't translated to dominance in the bedroom.

"Hm, what was that?"

She kept glaring at me, but her eyes had lost their piercing edge.

"Just... just keep doing what you're doing, you bastard!" she said.

I slapped her again. She whimpered and reached a hand between her legs to rub her pussy.

"Damn. Does Oliver know you like getting spanked? By a criminal, no less?

"N-" I inserted a fourth finger into her asshole. "Ohh... mmmm.... no, Ollie has no idea!"

I felt a shiver of pleasure at the admission.

"No?" I withdrew my fingers from Dinah's ass and grabbed the bottle of lube again. I squirted the cool liquid over my cock and rubbed it in. My dick bobbed.

“Lie face-down on my bed and spread your asscheeks for me,” I commanded.

“Of course, Jason,” Dinah replied without hesitation, a neutral look on her face. That must have been the obedience command working its magic.

Dinah stood up and walked past me towards my bed. She bent over my bed and rested her head and chest over my sheets, grabbing her ass with her hands and spreading her cheeks.

I drew a shuddering breath as I approached her, lubricated dick in hand. I nudged my member between her wide-open buttcheeks and found her tight rosebud. I pushed the head of my cock against her tightest hole, relishing in the feeling of it yielding to me.

Dinah whimpered.

I pushed further, inserting another inch of my cock into her.

“D-does it hurt?” I asked.

"Uhm," she moaned into my bed. "Just a little. Go slow."

I nodded and slowed my push into her rectum down to a crawl. Her ass was a lot tighter than her pussy, but I wasn't sure which I preferred since Dinah was far more adept at milking my cock with her pussy.

I sighed as another inch of my cock disappeared up her ass, leaving roughly half my cock outside. Jolts of pleasure coursed through my body like electricity.

"Okay, I'm ready," Dinah said, her voice far more firm this time. "Fuck my ass, you thieving degenerate."

I smirked and obliged her, the remainder of my cock sliding forward until I bottomed out inside her.

"Oh fuck!" Dinah screamed.

I stopped, worried that I'd really hurt her. My concern was assuaged when the blonde began pushing her ass against my pelvis, causing her thick buttcheeks to squish outward.

"Why the hell are you stopping?" She growled. "You're not allowed to stop fucking my ass until you've filled it with your fucking cum!"

I slapped her ass, causing her tightest hole to clench even tighter around my cock. Fuck.

I pulled my cock partially out of her ass. Her sphincter clung to my manhood, as if it were unwilling to let the invader go.

"Oh god," Dinah moaned.

I shoved forward suddenly, sheathing myself within her again. We both cried out at the dizzying sensations that assailed us. Lewd smacking sounds filled the room as I pounded her. Her asscheeks rippled and wobbled in tandem with our thrusts.

"That's it, you fucking stud. Fuck me, Jason. Oh god, you're gonna make me forget all about Oliver's cooooccck!"

Dinah quivered as she orgasmed. Her tight asshole clenched and milked my cock desperately. It didn't take long before I came as well, flooding Dinah's ass with a deluge of my cum.

Spent, I collapsed onto my bed. My head had barely hit the pillow before Dinah curled up beside me and rested her head in the crook of my neck.