Return to Tyler

You walk back over to Tyler, now fully erect and with a face covered in cum. Tyler is still talking to a few of his goonish friends. You notice Caoimhe's sitting on his lap now.

"Hey, Tyler. I helped out Katie and Beth," you say.

"Oh, hey, cuck!" Tyler smiles. "Notice anything about your girlfriend?"

You look down, noticing that she's not just sitting on his lap. She's sitting on his dick, with Tyler's cock literally plunged deep inside her pussy, where it rests. Caoimhe gently rocks back and forth, biting her lips to suppress her moans for fear of interrupting Tyler's conversation. Tyler laughs harshly as he sees you notice, before pointing to the guys around him.

"Do you know who these four lads are? We all scored a touchdown in that winning match!"

"Good job," you mumble.

"Speak up!" Tyler commands, pulling hard on Caoimhe's nipple and causing her to gasp as he does so.

"Good job," you repeat, more clearly as your eyes stare at the ground.

"Look at me when you're talking to me," Tyler growls, now glaring at you. "And fucking address me by name, you fucking cockroach, or I swear to god, I'll have the shit beaten out of you."

"Stop joking, Tyler," Caoimhe says amidst moans. "He's just roleplaying, he wouldn't do that."

You look up, noticing Tyler has now wrapped his arm around Caoimhe's side, his fingers now tugging gently on her clit.

"Good job, Tyler," you say, looking him in the eye.

"Thanks, buddy!" Tyler grins, eliciting laughter from the other jocks. "I think I should reward them. What do you think would be a good reward?"

Tyler's eyes drill into yours, and you know what answer he wants you to give. What answer he expects you to give.

"They deserve to fuck Caoimhe," you say. "She's really good at sex. Her pussy is so tight."

"Thanks," Caoimhe blushes, clearly aroused at the thoughts.

"That's a great idea!" Tyler smiles.

"But wait," Caoimhe says, stopping him. "I was planning to hang out with Jack tonight. Since the play got cancelled, we were going to watch some of my favorite plays instead!"

"You think that's more important than the winning game?" Tyler growls.

"No, of course not," Caoimhe says, looking down. "Maybe you could all fuck me at the same time to save time?"

Tyler notices your embarrassment at the prospect, and nods.

"Sure. Sure, we can do that, and then we have to give Jack some time with his pure little girlfriend, right?"

You nod in response.