Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 4
by
Fotzenglotz
What's next?
Raven-pie
Raven’s eyes flickered toward me, then back to the ancient pages, a wicked glint dancing in their dark depths. "You want to see if these words have weight?" she asked, her voice dropping an octave. "To see if they can change the very shape of reality?"
She began to chant—a low, rhythmic sequence of sounds that didn't sound like any language we knew. It was guttural yet melodic, vibrating through the floorboards and right into my marrow. As she spoke, the air in the living room began to swirl. The temperature seemed to spike, and the shadows cast by her velvet dress lengthened, dancing wildly against the walls.
"Watch closely," Raven whispered, her eyes locking onto mine as if challenging me to witness the impossible.
She traced a complex sigil in the air with a finger, and suddenly, there was a flash of violet light—a silent, blinding pop that made us both blink. Where the petite, bustling goth woman had been sitting, there was now only an empty space on the rug.
In her place sat a large, deep-dish apple pie. It was perfect: golden-brown crust with intricate lattice work, steam rising in fragrant wisps from its center, and a dusting of cinnamon that smelled heavenly.
"What the—" Cheri gasped, leaning forward, her eyes wide.
Suddenly, the pie's crust shifted. A mouth seemed to form within the lattice, and as if by some impossible magic, the pie began to move, sliding toward us on the rug like a living thing.
"Don't look so shocked," the pie said. It was Raven’s voice—husky, sultry, and teasing, echoing out from the baked crust. "It’s just a little bit of flavor."
The pie let out a muffled, cheeky giggle as it glided toward my knees.
"Is she... is she a dessert now?" Cheri asked, half-laughing in disbelief, her hand reaching out to touch the golden crust.
"Not exactly," the Raven-pie purred, its voice vibrating through the air. "I'm just a little sweet and easy to swallow. Though, I might be a bit too much for one man to handle at once." The pie's 'body' buckled slightly in a mock-shrug. "Unless you're looking for something thick and juicy to sink your teeth into?"
She paused, the lattice top shifting as if she were winking.
"I thought about turning into something even more delicious," the pie teased, her voice dropping into a dirty, suggestive lilt. "But then I realized... after seeing how much you like heavy things, a big, thick slice of me might be exactly what you need to satisfy that hunger."
The joke was so absurdly lewd that Cheri let out a peal of delighted laughter, her face flushed red. Even as my brain tried to process the logic, the sheer absurdity of the "witch-pie" making dirty jokes at my expense sent a fresh wave of arousal through me.
Raven’s voice drifted from the pastry again, sounding playful yet hungry. "What do you think, big guy? Do you want to start slicing, or are you going to let me sit here and get cold?"
"She's definitely got jokes," I managed to grunt, a slow, predatory grin spreading across my face as my cock throbbed painfully against my shorts. "But how do we eat an apple pie that talks back?"
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
My Witchy Neighbor
How the hot young emo goth chick next door changed our lives
This story is about me and my wife and our sexual discovery of our witchy neighbor.
Updated on May 26, 2026
by ManRayMansker
Created on May 11, 2026
by ManRayMansker
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments