"I just wanted to calm her down."

"I... I just wanted to calm her down," you try to explain.

"By fucking her?" Samantha snaps.

"No, not initially," you reply. "I ate her out and fingered her..."

"That doesn't help," Samantha grumbles, glancing over at the pool of cum between Erin's thighs.

"I wanted to punish her for hitting you," you admit.

Samantha touches her redden cheek where she was slapped and looks down at her ex-girlfriend. "If I take out the gag, will you promise not the scream?"

Erin nods.

Samantha pulls out the saliva-soaked panties from her mouth.

After taking a gasp of air, Erin eyes at both of you but without the anger she had before. "Don't worry he can't get me pregnant. I'm on birth control."

"What?" Samantha gasps. "I thought you're a lesbian!"

"I take birth control to help me with my PMS," Erin explains. "It balances out my hormones and periods -- that's why I've been so moody before..."

Samantha looks away and sighs.

"I'm sorry, babe," Erin sobs. "I didn't mean to hurt you!"

Samantha looks at her ex-lover for a moment before reaching over to untie the socks used to bind Erin's wrists to the headboard.

"So should I leave to give you girls some space to talk privately?" you ask, breaking the awkward silence between the three of you.