Exchange numbers then get dressed and head back to the party

You'd love to get together with Alison some other time, so the two of you exchange numbers, then take turns washing up in the bathroom, before getting changed and heading back down to the party. Not really caring anymore if the other girls see you, the two of you walk back outside and head over to where you see the rest of the group, Mandy included, standing around, drinking and laughing.

Zoe is the first to see you and quickly informs the rest of the group with a loud "Well, look who's finally rejoining the party! You look like you're having a little trouble walking David. Is something a little sore?" Then turning her attention to Alison, she asks "You look like you're walking a little funny too there Ali. What were you two doing while you were gone?"

It's quickly apparent that the girls have been drinking pretty heavily and have already swapped stories amongst each other, but Alison is clear-minded and, straight faced, responds with "Zoe, what's this on your chin? It looks like... cum?"

Not realizing that Alison's actually pulling her leg, Zoe reflexively wipes at her chin before the rest of the girls break out in laughter at how easily she's fooled, then flicks Alison off before laughing herself.

The girls trade a few more barbs with each other before Mandy excuses herself, but quickly returns with shot glasses for everyone and a bottle of vodka in her hand. The shots get poured and passed around then Mandy raises her glass in a toast. "I think we should acknowledge that a record has been broken tonight, girls!" she says, turning towards you. "Our boy David here, has managed to fuck five of us in one day! Breaking the previous record of four! To you David! Cheers!"

"Cheers!" the rest of the girls call out in unison, as the tale of your conquest is openly spoken about for the first time tonight.

As you finish knocking back your own shot, you feel the heat of another body against yours and turn to see Gabbie has appeared by your side. "So stud, did you save any of yourself for me?" she asks as she moves her hand down between your legs and fondles you. "Or are you going to throw in the towel for tonight?" she says with a hint of challenge against your manhood.

Even though you feel like you've been kicked in the dick multiple times right now, your ego won't let you back down, and you know this is more than likely a once in a lifetime opportunity. You move your mouth to her ear so the other girls can't hear and whisper. "I thought I would just save the best for last, Gabbie." you say, stroking her ego. "Let's enjoy the party for a little to give me just a bit more time to recover, then maybe you can come back to my place if you'd like. I'm just a short walk from here."

Gabbie's already listened to the other girl's stories about you tonight and her pussy starts to drip at the thought of having the relative privacy of your place versus potentially having to finish things quickly to give someone else the room. "Alright, but I'm holding you to that. Don't think you can sneak off with one of these other whores here. I was fine with you fucking one of my girls, but now that you've had them, I'm next." she says, giving your junk another squeeze.

Honestly, you've been hoping you'd have the chance to fuck Gabbie tonight and have no intention of sneaking off to find someone else. You tell her the same before excusing yourself to get another drink, but not before asking if anyone needs anything. The girls are all set with drinks, so you only have to worry about yourself. You grab yourself another beer before rejoining them and seeing what might be in store for the rest of the night.