She’s willing to consider it

Mrs. Cooper seemed to actually be considering Rachael’s proposal. Jess averted her eyes and tried to appear completely servile hoping to avoid losing any chance for a slightly better existence.

“You two, please let go of her butt cheeks and let’s see if Rachael has a point.”

Jess let out a heavy sigh of relief as her sore, bruised, and beaten ass was released by the two students. She swallowed afraid to have any hope but she felt some developing. Rachael took her hand off Jess’ pussy and reached around her to grab Jess’ left breast while still fingering her ass. Rachael tried to massage Jess around the clip to provide what comfort she could. Jess bit her lip not wanting a moan to ruin any chance she had.

Kevin seemed caught off guard. He thought his puppets couldn’t act in any way he didn’t approve but he supposed that given their diverse personalities that some might remain nice even if they participated in degrading Jess. He considered making a wish to reign Rachael in but then decided to try something else as he saw Jess’ toes curl in pleasure.

“I wish anytime you felt hope you peed yourself.”

Jess arched her back and pushed back against Rachael’s fingers and felt their full length in her butt, massaging the inside of her rectum, as fresh juices thickly coated her thighs and she moaned with her eyes rolling back. She tried to disappear into the pleasure of the wish but knew it’s consequences would likely ruin what little enjoyment she was having.

“She’s pissing!” Screamed a girl.

Jess sobbed as she felt a warm stream of piss drip out of her pooling between her knees. She would be humiliated to admit the feelings of Rachael’s fingers in her ass while pissing was getting her even hotter on top of the arousal from the various wishes but it only made her feel like more of a slut; even if some of her arousal could be explained away with magic, not all of it could.

Jess moaned loudly as she fell back to the ground mashing the clips on her tits into the hard floor, causing them even more pain as she anxiously waited for Rachael to turn on her for pissing herself but her fingers just continued to play with her ass as Rachael’s other hand moved from her breast to gently rubbing her lower back. Rachael didn’t seem to mind Jess’ juices that seemed to cover her entire naked body from head to toe.

Jess frowned again as she opened her eyes and saw that everyone was laughing at her and another moan escaped her lips causing them to laugh even more heavily. She cowered backwards but that only serves to push her harder onto Rachael’s fingers and more into the puddle of her own making.

“Ms. Edwards, you disgust me. can you not do anything appropriate? Not only can you not control your obsession with sexual humiliation you can’t even hold your bladder? Or did you do that on purpose too, to debase yourself even further?” Asked Mrs. Cooper who expected Rachael to finally turn on Jess.

Mrs. Cooper’s words cut through her; she knew even if everyone hadn’t been bent to Kevin’s will they would still probably find her disgusting. She felt lower than ever and waited for a new even worse punishment.

“No she literally can’t. That’s my point. Just give me some tissues and I’ll clean her up.” Said Rachael almost angrily.

Jess looked back again and Rachael gave her an understanding smile. Mrs. Cooper was taken aback as she handed Rachael a box of tissues. Rachael let go of Jess’ breast and took the tissues. She didn’t look to Mrs. Cooper for permission as she removed the clip from Jess’ clit. Jess grit her teeth and let out a low mewl as she felt blood flowing towards her sensitive love button. Rachael then took a few and gently wiped the length of Jess’ slit up and down a few times as Jess just focused on the pleasure of the fingers in her bum and her vulva being rubbed and let out a few humiliating moans.

“What about my floor?” Asked Mrs. Cooper feeling like she was losing control of Jess to Rachael.

The girl took more tissues and wiped the floor and as she stretched her hand around under Jess her fingers shifted inside Jess’ asshole and she pushed herself back harder against them. Rachael smiled knowingly as she challenged herself to bring Jess to new sexual peaks exceeding what she’d already been through in class.

“She’s like an animal. You wouldn’t expect an animal to control themselves.”

Mrs. Cooper listened and Kevin was blown away that his wish didn’t have the desired effect. Jess finally understood that even in her sympathy Rachael thought of her as animal just like everyone else.

“Then what do you suggest?”

Rachael rubbed Jess’s wet and bruised bottom with her free hand.

“The leash and cuffs should stay because she can’t control herself. I think it would also be to her benefit to use the plug so she has something to keep her happy. Positive reinforcement will keep her content just as much if not more than your negative reinforcement will keep her controlled. The clips are just cruel. She‘s always in heat and to expect her to not act like it is an exercise in futility. They should go.”

Rachael reached around and pulled each clip off one at a time with her free hand while still fingering Jess deep in her ass. She then gently rubbed Jess’ nipples one at a time trying to comfort her.

“Rachael, you may have a point. Please insert the plug and then we’ll figure out how best to proceed.”

Jess wasn’t sure what was happening or how someone fingering her ass without her permission was somehow the nicest person she’d met so far who was still effected by Kevin’s wish. Rachael slowly and gently slid her her fingers out and Jess, much to her embarrassment, clenched her anus trying to hold them in. It didn’t work as Rachael removed them and then pat her bottom lightly to show affection and acknowledge that she knew Jess missed her fingers.

Rachael took the medium sized plug out of its package and held it in front of Jess’ mouth. Jess opened her mouth Rachael inserted and spun it allowing Jess to coat it in saliva. Jess blushed as everyone watched. She looked at everyone circled around her who seemed disappointed that Jess was getting some mercy but also amused at her debasing herself.

Rachael then placed the tip of the plug at Jess’ backdoor and Jess tried to relax her anus. She then looked back at Rachael who was now rubbing her stomach still covered in juices. She felt the tip of the plug slightly inside her and wondered if Rachael, who only sympathized because she thought she was such a slut she couldn’t help herself, was as good as it would get for anyone aside from Sam or Tiffany caring for her.

Rachael then palmed Jess’ slit with her other hand rubbing gently to keep her content while the plug stretched her sensitive rear passage. Jess moaned deeply and tried to stop feeling so much shame at her public arousal but still couldn’t help but feel like some sort of sexual exhibit at some science museum, which given further thought she guessed she was to some extent.

“Relax your cute little butthole.” Said Rachael, almost giggling, as a warning as she didn’t want to cause Jess any discomfort as the plug stretched her more and more as it pushed deeper and deeper.

Jess was embarrassed at open discussion of her anus, though she almost smiled at it being called cute, but then grunted loudly as it was pushed further inside and she felt her anus stretch to accept the plug. Her fingers and toes curled in arousal and pain both as Rachael took her hand that had been rubbing her slit and started delicately fingering Jess to calm her. She avoided her clit as she knew it was likely very sensitive from the clip.

“It’s okay, it’s okay.” She said as Jess grunted and moaned.

As the plug made it further in Jess’ eyes became wide as it was difficult for her formerly virgin anus to take such width but she tried to calm herself with deep breaths. Between everything she’d been through and was going through, her body had so many sensations she didn’t know if she could really process anything.

“Just one more big push at it’ll be all the way in, sweet girl.”

Rachael’s words sounded kind and soothing and Jess, though she had completely lost any form of independence, didn’t feel so terrible submitting to Rachael. She somehow despite Kevin’s total modification of her life and mind was a deeply caring person. If Jess had to be someone’s subservient plaything she didn’t think she could do much better.

As a show of trust and respect Jess lowered herself further to the ground, though her nipples were still quite sensitive against the cold wet ground, trying to open her asshole as much as possible for Rachael. Rachael fingered her pussy deeper as if to recognize Jess’ submission and reward it and Jess moaned loudly and for the first time she didn’t care. She closed her eyes as she felt the full width of the plug stretching her asshole and Rachael paused as Jess’ took deeper and deeper breaths, toes curling, nipples and clit erect and the pleasure pushed through the pain, she closed her eyes and forgot everything but her own pleasure.

“What a fucking slut!” Yelled one of their classmates.

“Shut the fuck up and let her have this!” Screamed Rachael back in Jess’ defense.

Kevin felt like he’d lost complete control. Jess had somehow found, if not happiness, peace. He felt like using a wish right now would be cheating but as he watched Jess moan and moan he grinned and waited.

“It’s just you and me and you’re doing so good, baby.” Cooed Rachael into Jess’ ear, she even nibbled Jess’ earlobe a little and even that had a hint of Jess’ juices though Rachael didn’t seem to mind. Jess smiled and licked her lips.

Rachael’s fingers in Jess started moving quicker and quicker as her fingers on her other hand gripped the flange of the plug, and pushed the tips of her fingers against Jess’ butthole. Jess moaned deeply and rocked harder into Rachael’s fingers. Rachael held the thin piece of the plug tightly making Jess continue to feel it’s full width stretching her anus. She moaned deeper and deeper as she pushed herself back against Rachael and Jess had completely forgotten the danger she was putting herself in and Rachael, whether through indifference or having forgotten herself, fingered harder and harder. Jess’ voice cracked as she moaned her loudest yet and Rachael realized what was about to happen finally and knew it was too late to stop it.

She withdrew her fingers from Jess’ pussy and pushed the plug in all the way as hard as she could and Jess came with incredible **** as she felt her anus wrap tightly around the flange and the plug pushed to its deepest point. Her anus contracted over and over as her quim quivered and her back arched. She started spasming and lowered herself rubbing her rock hard nipples against the cold wet tile to build additional pleasure as she moaned loud enough to be heard in the halls.

Kevin knew that if anything was going to cause a rift between Jess and Rachael it was what would likely happen next. However, much to his disappointment Rachael smiled with pride and it didn’t change at all Jess squirted like a fire hose all over Rachael’s face and shirt. She just closed her eyes and let it happen.

Jess took a final moan and collapsed in a heap, cuffed, with her blue gemmed plug sparkling between her ass cheeks pointed up in the air and her overly stimulated drenched pussy between spread legs on display underneath it.

Kevin let her enjoy her moment as he thought bringing her down from her new high to a completely new low would be so much better to watch.

Rachael went to hold Jess but Mrs. Cooper circled between them cutting her off and by the time she moved out of the way the rest of the class circled closer.

As Jess started to come down and the pleasure faded she felt the tremendous pain in her ass cheeks, the sweat and pussy juices literally all over her and definitely not a complete absence of urine despite Rachael’s best effort. Her wrists ached from spasming in the cuffs. Her nipples ached from being clipped as did her clit and they were so hard she could barley bear it. Her pussy was sore from being played with so much, being spanked, and cumming three times in less than a single period and without sexual stimulation the plug felt much larger and even a bit uncomfortable. She finally heard everyone laughing and opened her eyes to everyone taking pictures and mocking her.

“I... I...” she tried to find words as everyone was crouched down around her way too close as she was completely restrained and unable to defend herself in any way.

Finally she remembered the leash around her throat just as Mrs. Cooper picked it up yanking Jess by the neck to meet her hateful gaze.

“Just when I was about to show you some mercy you stupid, lecherous, little slut...”