To everyone's surprise, Erica was NOT a virgin!

"What? But... I'm not a virgin..." Erica blushed as she revealed her indiscretion to everyone, and all of her friends were rightfully shocked.

"Okay, I have to ask, who was the lucky guy?" Alicia, racking her brain with thought, winced and fired the question.

"... It was Henry." Erica, still naked, seemed to be blushing harder with this revelation.

"Henry? After all he did? When?" If there was a boy who participated in stripping Erica the most, it was Henry, yet another of Lisa's little helpers who, time after time, Erica found herself faced with his smug face as she inevitably removed more of her clothing.

"After Lisa's party, he snuck into the room I was staying in and said he was sorry how this was turning out." Erica fidgeted shyly, and it would have been adorable if she wasn't standing there half-naked with her fingers still teasing her clit. "And I always thought he was cute, and I was still a little pent up, and... I don't know."

"You almost had sex with me too, you little slut." Carrie teased Erica, no malice behind her words, in fact, she almost seemed happy for her friend.

Lisa, however, was left with no other recourse, her gambit had failed now that Erica was no longer such a rare treat for her tormentors, and she was now (quite literally) staring down two large cocks that threatened to have their way with her, unless she comes up with something right. now!