A plus one

As the minutes dragged along, I wonder if Shar would ever show? Part of me can’t help but wonder if something has happened to her. Right as my doubts start to sink in, I hear a knock on my door. Upon hearing Shar knock, I shot up onto my feet and rushed to answer it. Once I opened my door, I find myself in front of Alyssa, who's wearing figure-hugging workout clothes.

"Oh... Alyssa." I say, giving her a puzzled look.

"Expecting someone else?" I hear Shar say from the side. Suddenly, she appears next to Alyssa, wearing a set of casual jeans and a black-and-white striped top that are both equally form-fitting.

My face sinks into further befuddlement upon seeing my girlfriend. "Oh, hey Shar."

"Can we come in?" She asked.

"Uh, sure."

I let both girls in, despite my confusion. Just what the hell is Shar playing at? This is supposed to be our time together as a couple.

"Can I get you girls anything?" I asked.

"No, I'm fine." Shar says.

"I'm good too." {partner_ first} adds.

"So, what's the occasion?”

Shar unleashes a devious smile that raised more questions than it gave answers. "Not exactly."

"Well, then what?"

Alyssa puts her arm around my shoulder and gives me a similar smile. It’s like two sharks are swimming around a confused fish, waiting for the right moment to strike.

"I had something in mind. See, I remember you telling me about what happened at Alyssa’s dorm when you walked in on her." Shar says.

"Okay..."

"And well, I think it’s a shame that she missed out on your full service.”

I continue to stammer as Alyssa rubs my thigh, even in front of my girlfriend.

"So, I was thinking, I could watch you two."

"Uh, I mean..."

"C'mon Andrew. Your girlfriend's giving you full permission." Alyssa coos.

"You sure you're okay with this?” I ask as Alyssa kisses your neck.

Without blinking, Shar nods. "Absolutely. You know I like to watch you."

With a shrug, I turn to Alyssa. "Uh, I mean, I guess if that's okay."

Alyssa bites her lip. "So where do you wanna start?”