You choose pussy.

"I'm waiting Da!" she says menacingly.

"I...I want your pussy." you say shamefacedly. This was wrong. But it had to be done.

"Good choice. Taking it like a real man! I don't know what's up with you and butt stuff but once I'm done with you, you'll want nothing but my pussy." saying that Arya removes her underwear and throws it on the floor. Her hard, almost 12 incher, comes in view. It was huge and thick, but not monstrously so like Riya. It was the perfect size for you.

*No goddamnit! What is wrong with you?! This is wrong!* you think to yourself. But no matter how you try to reason with yourself, your cock betrays you and stands at full mast, ready for the inevitable plunge.

Arya takes your hard 4-inch dick and slips it inside herself. It is very warm and wet inside her pussy.

"Oh. I mean I can feel it. But it's kinda small and thin. Eh...whatever. What matters is your pleasure. So Da....how do you like my pussy?"

You can't take this anymore. You don't want to do it with your sister. Not like this. "I HATE IT!! I ABSOLUTELY HATE IT!! YOU'RE DISGUSTING!! FUCK YOU!!"

Arya stares at you with a blank face. "I had hoped it wouldn't come to this. I wanted you to make the right choice. Looks like I was wrong. Fine, I'll **** your ass you stupid little dicked bitch" She gets up off of you and stuffs the gag back in your mouth. She gets between your legs and positions her dry cock directly on top of your hole.

"MMMMPPPPFF..." you try to protest.

"Here comes the pain train." Arya says dispassionately.