She should keep her normal genitalia...for now.

As tempted as Tom was to mess with his wife with another wish, he ended up deciding, for then at least, to keep her as she was. For the next several days, things continued as they had been before. Sarah alternated between showing him how much she loved him and how she was grateful for his support with all of this, and giving him the dominating bad girl attitude. It leaned more towards the latter than the former, that was certainly for sure.

And no matter how nice she was to him, as long as Tom had that butt plug in him, he couldn’t keep the idea of what was to come from it out of his mind. At first he hadn’t liked it, feeling like having something stuffed up his ass all day wasn’t comfortable in the slightest. But the longer he kept it there, and imagined how this would lead to Sarah pegging him up that same asshole, the more pleasurable just wearing it was becoming for him.

Finally, after getting home and being a bit warmer than usual to him, Sarah gave her husband a saucy look. “Have you been a good boy? You kept the plug in like I told you to?”

Realizing what was about to happen, Tom started getting very aroused, his cock getting hard and his asshole clamping around the buttplug. “Y-yes I have.”

“Show me.” They went into the bedroom, where Sarah had abstained from sex for a few days, to make Tom a little more eager to be pegged, and without having to be asked Tom stripped naked and presented his butt to her. Sure enough, the buttplug she’d given him was still there. Clearly aroused herself, Sarah went into the closet and dug around, until she found the bag she was looking for. Pulling out the strap-on, Sarah affixed it properly to her crotch, applied lube to it, and was ready to fuck her husband. The only question was: would she make his first time slower and smoother, or go all out on him?