She mixes them up

It sounds like these are all tailor-made to do something to us. This has got to be a trick!

Khala casually slips her tea cup off the tray and pours it into a nearby potted plant.

I have to think of some way to warn Ariane and the others! Maybe if I...

"Finally!" Ariane says as she scoops up one of the cups. "Mmmmm! This smells so good!"

"Ariane, I... d-don't!" Khala stammers, but the elf is drinking her tea before the thief can stop her.

"W-why did you do that!? And why aren't you in the parlor?" Khala says in frustration.

"I needed to use the little girls' room," the elf wizard says. "And this tea... IS AMAZING." Ariane struts back into the parlor, cup in hand as she sips more of the mysterious beverage. "You girls gotta try this!"

Khala just stands there, trying to figure out what to do next, but before she can dump the rest of this strange beverage, Ainzie comes up behind her.

"Come on, Khala what are you waiting for?" The witch says.

I don't have time!

"S-sure," the thief says as she heads back to the parlor.

But if this IS a trap, maybe I can still help the others. Ainzie said Bluebelle had to get this specific cup. That must be because fairies are different from people... so if I switch the cups...

Khala puts the straw in the tea intended for Bluebelle, and sets it down in front of the still bound Mira. She then hands the other one, the one meant for Mira, to Bluebelle.

The two women eagerly drink their tea, cooing in pleasure.

"This is so good, isn't it?" Ariane says.

"Ainzie makes the best tea," Bluebelle agrees. "Mmmm it's been sooo long since I had a cup."

Mira just moans in approval as she sucks it down through her straw.

Khala sits down, and pretends to sip from her empty cup.

I guess I'll just have to save everyone from this trap myself...

She sits there, nervously waiting for the other shoe to drop. Luckily, she doesn't have to wait long...