Emily Lets it Happen Reluctantly

[This chapter was commissioned by brain66 as part of the Chapter Of Your Choice reward on Patreon. Thank you for your support!]

Nonono-NO! Not there! the light blonde panicked and clenched her virgin asshole tightly as Constance's fingertip pushed inside.

Emily arched her back and turned her ass left and right, desperately trying to escape the poking digit but it was no use. The goth girl could easily follow her every movement and was about to squeeze through her sphincter.

Now, the only way of preserving her anal virginity was to right herself up and break away from the passionate grasp around the back of her head.

Emily quickly realized that she would have to brace hard against Alice's soft tit and delicate inner thigh and expected that it would pain the teal-haired enough to make her arousal go south in an instant, making it impossible to win the race against the clock.

Then it was all for nothing and everyone and their mom will see me licking another girl..., the freckled girl thought before her eyes went wide, "My vag! They will see my vag and how... how I got fingered by another girl..."

I'd forever be known as the naked lesbian slut! Emily realized, visualizing her topless appearance in the yearbook and the raunchy text below the picture: Thank you all for that great senior year. I really enjoyed all the glances at my cute tits and constantly wet slit, all the fingers which explored my whole body, and all those sweet, delicious pussies I was allowed to eat out. Your Little Ms. Pussy Eater.

Damn! I can't risk that! the kneeling girl sighed inwardly and yielded up to her fate, keeping her behind still and hesitantly relaxing her tight asshole.

"MH-MMH!" Emily groaned into the teal-haired's crotch as Constance's sharp-nailed fingertip finally made their way past her sphincter.

You must make her cum! the light blonde thought and resumed licking Alice's wet pussy, desperately trying to ignore the strange, unfamiliar feeling in her butt.

The damp digit inched deeper and deeper into Emily's ass until the thin layer of her own pussy juice was used up.

Holy shit! Be careful! the light blonde cursed in her mind before the growing friction at her sphincter caused a sudden, piercing pain.

"MM!" the kneeling girl squealed and instinctively contracted her asshole around Constance's finger.

"What a tight, little hole!" the goth girl teased in an exaggerated voice, pretending to be impressed, "I guess we need some lube!"

Before Emily knew what was about to happen, Constance had pulled her digit out of the tight butthole, and slipped it into the kneeling girl's slick snatch, accompanied by another finger.

In a swift motion, the skinny goth thrust all the way into the dripping wet hole and turned her wrist left and right, her knuckles pushing and rubbing the sensitive pussy lips roughly against the rock-hard clit underneath.

"MMH!" the light blonde let out a deep, throaty groan, and rolled her eyes back as waves of pleasure rocked through her body.

"That's so... so hot...," Alice gasped, gently pulling the kneeling girl's head tighter against her crotch.

"That... should do it...," Constance murmured from behind, carefully pulling the pussy juice covered fingers out of Emily and positioning them a half-inch below her recently deflowered asshole.

"M!" the kneeling girl flinched slightly as the goth girl dropped a big load of saliva on her tight backdoor.

"Here we go again!" Constance giggled, rubbed the spit into the pink butthole and squeezed her lubed-up fingertips inside.

Must... make her... cum..., the light blonde tried to focus on pleasing the girl in front of her while the two fingers inched deeper and deeper into her ass.

"Much better, don't you think?" the skinny goth cooed from behind as her digits were completely buried in Emily's rear.

Shut up, graveyard bitch! the kneeling girl cursed in her mind but when Constance's thumb slipped between her pussy lips and touched her clit, she couldn't help but let out a deep, lustful moan and contract her sphincter around the intruder.

"I knew you would like it!" the pale-faced girl laughed and added in a joyful voice, "But guess what!"

"It gets even better!" she whispered and started to finger-fuck the kneeling girl as fast as the tight hole would allow.

Caught off guard by the sudden, quick thrusts, Emily involuntarily clenched her sphincter around the long, scrawny fingers, intensifying the unfamiliar, odd feeling in her rectum.

"MM-MM-MM...," the kneeling girl groaned into Alice's pussy, and desperately tried to relax her tight asshole but failed miserably.

"Oh yes... don't stop...," the teal-haired in front of her breathed, visibly enjoying the vibrating lips at her hard clit and sensitive pussy lips.

Just hang in there a little longer, Emily! the light blonde encouraged herself to endure the slight burning sensation in her ass, She's almost there!

"Damn! You love this, don't you?" Constance teased her, "You're so horny, you're leaking already!"

Shut up! the kneeling girl snapped in her mind but suddenly sensed the small drops of pussy juice which ran down over her clean-shaven pubic mound and her delicate inner thighs.

"How lucky you're not wearing clothes!" the skinny goth giggled, "They'd be all soaked by lunch break!"

"Oh, wait!" she cooed as if something dawned on her, "Is that the reason why you're naked all day long?"

Focus, Emily, focus! the kneeling girl tried to ignore the constant teasing, Don't listen to her! She just wants to distract you! She wants you to fail!

In the meantime, she had gotten somewhat used to the fingers in her tight asshole and had managed to adjust the rhythm of her tongue to the pace of Constance's thrusts.

"Mh-mh-mh...," Emily moaned, gently licking and sucking at Alice's delicate pussy lips.

"Please...," the teal-haired girl whispered sheepishly, "Please..., look at me."

Putting her head back and doing a hollow back, Emily looked up at eaten-out girl's relaxed but heavily breathing face.

"You're really getting into it, horny kitty!" Constance laughed and thrust her fingers hard into the now raised butt, pushing the kneeling girl's face into Alice's crotch.

"MMH!" the light blonde let out a throaty groan, unable to recover from the sexy pose while her cute, freckled face turned crimson.

"Oh, Em! That's so hot...," Alice moaned, gently stroking the blonde girl's head, "I could do that... mh... could do that... forever..."

FOREVER? the kneeling girl screamed in her mind, her blue eyes widening in panic, You have to... you must... I... I...

Her heart pounding heavily in her heaving chest, Emily desperately thought about a way of getting Alice off in time.