Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by The-Drunken-Bandit The-Drunken-Bandit

Where do you look?

Undertale

As you bring up the files concerning this world, you are immediately lost in the bittersweet memories that you have of this world recall your time in it.

When you first arrived, you did so at the bottom of a giant hole with a strange 18-year-old girl who was named Frisk of all things and had to go through a series of wacky adventures to not only escape this world but also to free it from its never-ending time loop. However, as you get lost in your memories of your adventures in this world, your mind immediately comes up with three possible choices in Henchs who would be more than willing to help you, if you were to give them back their memories of when you went through their world.

1.Toriel: Motherly and kind, Toriel was the first kind monster you and Frisk met in the underground and did her best to help the two of you settle into this odd world. However, you knew that no one would be this kind to a stranger without a reason. So once Frisk had went to bed for the night you confronted Toriel in the living room of her home and questioned her about her motives and the answer you got from the goat woman did not disappoint. Toriel was at first hesitant to answer your inquiries, but after pressing a little harder, she folded and began the tale of the horrible course of events that eventually led up to this point.

Apparently, the Humans of this world went to war with the monsters that co-existed in this world with them out of the fear of having their immortal souls absorbed by the Monsters as when a monster absorbs a humans soul they gain a massive power up, so naturally fearing the worst humanity started a long and bloody war that ultimately lead to the monsters defeat and subsequent imprisonment in Mount Ebott. An ever since then Monsters have lived there in the underground peacefully for an untold number of years, However this all changed when a young human Girl by the name of Chara _(who also by the way looked exactly like frisk, so much so that you could say that they were twins even.) _fell down into the underground and was found by Toriel's young Daughter Asriel, who immediately went to her parents to help the injured young girl. What followed was Chara essentially being adopted by Toriel and her Husband at the time, Asgore the King of the Underground.

Yeah... finding out that Toriel was a queen was quite the shocker but that wasn't as nearly as shocking as what happened next. You see as the years went by, and the two daughters of the monster royal family grew into young women, a terrible accident happened that unfortunately killed Chara. Though surprising it wasn't as shocking as what followed afterward’s as Asriel being young and foolish wanted to return Chara back to the human world in order for her to be properly buried. In order to do this, Asriel had to temporarily absorb Chara's soul in order to get through the magical barrier that the ancient humans constructed eons ago to seal the monsters in. Though when she did this and brought Chara to the nearest human settlement to be buried, she was immediately attacked by the locals who thought she was the one to kill her adopted sister!

Asriel being completely innocent and inexperienced in both combat and in the running away from an angry mob’s was, unfortunately, lynched to ****. This naturally sent shock waves through the underground and caused Asgore to dive into a deep rage and later depression from what you learn later on.

Anyway, while Asgore was lost in his rage, he came up with a solution to destroy the barrier and free the monster kind but in order to do that he would require the souls of 6 humans. At the very mention of this plan and the fact that both their children had died horrifically, Toriel couldn't take it anymore and left Asgore to hopefully protect any of the humans that fell down into the underground, Which she tried to do for the last 5 humans, (all of whom were all small children and you and frisk were the first adults to fall into the underground) only to fail 5 times.

By the time Toriel had finished her tale, she was slightly sobbing, and just a single look into her eyes told you everything you needed to know about the former queen.

Toriel... had bottled up all her emotions to their very breaking point and then thanks to you, they finally bubbled to the top and overflowed as She let her guilt, loneliness, tiredness, and overwhelming regret out in a river of despair.

You couldn't stand seeing Toriel like that, so you did the only thing you could at that time and brought her close in a tight hug as she started to bawl her eyes out. As she did so all you could do was tell her to let it all out, to which she did for a good long while as she began to recount the sad tales of her trying to dissuade the other humans that came before, only for her to fail in stopping them from going deeper into the underground, to only then promptly perish at the end of her ex-husbands trident.

As she began to explain her story she began to sob and break down at her failures at saving those unfortunate children, she also began to recount her overall feelings of depression, guilt, and loneliness that she **** herself to experience here in her home in the ruins. As she did this, she began to hold on to you tightly as she let all of her built up and repressed emotions out to run their course.

However, as Toriel let out all of her pent-up emotions, another really strange thing came out as Toriel began to bawl her eyes out.

Apparently the goat mom hasn’t been in contact with anyone from outside of the ruins for ages, and as a result, she built up a good deal of sexual frustration, frustration that she immediately began to cry about as she went on and on about her unfulfilled needs. Needs that she’s been trying to satisfy using her rather large collection of toys for years, but it wasn’t enough for her she needed the real thing, and no man has ever visited her until… You.

It would take too long to fully explain what happened after Toriel came to that full realization but safe to say that entire night you had to keep an area of silence spell in order to make sure frisk didn’t wake up in the middle of the night hearing Toriel’s loud Moaning and to also ensure that she didn’t hear the sound of Toriel’s bed breaking.

Safe to say you didn’t get any sleep that night as you spent the entirety of that night satisfying a sexually frustrated Goat Milf, who you had to utilize her large collection of toys on, all of which varied in size and shape and were mind boggling but what was most surprising was Toriel’s breeding fetish.

That threw you for a quite the loop as when you were with Toriel that night, you kept hearing her moan and scream loudly about how she wanted you to “Use that big fat stud cock to Knock me up like the breeding bitch I am!” or how she wanted you to “ Fill me to the brim so I’ll never be lonely ever again!”, the list of her lusty moans goes on and on but you’ll spare the details for now.

Anyway, that following morning Toriel looked and sounded like a new woman and was so grateful that she let you and frisk out of the ruins without conflict on the promise that the two of you would come back to visit and that you would do your best to protect frisk. Of course, with that promise safe to say this wasn’t the last time you talked or saw Toriel as after giving the two of you phones, which you immediately upgraded to touch phones for convenience and even gave torn on one of them. She would constantly send you naughty pictures of her dressed up in all different types of lingerie and of her playing with her rather large collection of toys.

Needless to say, Toriel pretty much latched on to you after that one night, which got even worse after you defeated Flowey in her monstrous form and not only saved Toriel every other monster that you and frisk encountered and became friends with during your stay in the underground.

Following this and Asgore’s self-exile, you were appointed to the new Queens guard in order to help Toriel manage the kingdom. Which you did most of the time but whenever the matters of the underground didn't come in to play, the two of you were shamelessly and wholeheartedly making love throughout the entire castle. However, it wasn’t all fun and games as you shared a lot of your different adventures throughout the multi-verse with Toriel and she, in turn, told you of the magic and mythology that existed within monster kind. As a result, Toriel sort of became your Girlfriend more or less as you often went out on several dates with the Goat Milf and built up a great relationship with her.

However this all came to a rather bitter end as after a couple of months, Flowey somehow came back and when she did, she did so in a rather spectacular way as she absorbed the six human souls and became a God! When she became a God, she revealed her true identity, flowery was in actuality Asriel, Toriel and Asgore’s long departed daughter who somehow clung to life in the messed up form of Flowey.

Anyway, after this big shocking reveal, Asriel tried to waste both you and Frisk but was stopped short by the entirety of the monsters living in the underground banding together to protect the two of you.

However, this was a mistake as Asriel simply absorbed them and added their power to her already unimaginable power, which ended up giving her control over time, space, and creation. It was with this godly power that Asriel immediately tried to completely wipe both you and frisk off the face of the earth and while you did your best to fight back and even managed to damage Asriel bad enough for frisk to dive deep into the one God to pull your friends back out. You were still no match for the being that Asriel had became, as you were far too weak back then to actually do any real damage to a Godlike entity.

Regardless, thanks to frisk, the two of you were able to reawaken the humanity that was buried deep within the spiteful girl and as such was able to bring back her true form short period of time. It was during the short period of time that Asriel apologized greatly for her actions and told the two of you that she only wanted this to stop, she wanted this endless cycle to end so that she and everybody else could be free from it as she explained this she broke down into tears. Frisk seeing this did the only thing she could at the time and gave comfort to a lonely, scared child who just simply wanted the pain and suffering to end.

After regaining control of her emotions, Asriel broke down the barrier and freed everyone, including the six human souls that were trapped in the underground and in doing so transform back into flowey. However, as the two of you were about to argue about trying to change Asriel back into a real form permanently, she could only shake her head and say no, she deserved this. She deserved to be alone for what she had done and that the two of you should go while you still had hope.

An with that Asriel disappeared back into the underground never to be seen again. This event has always been a great regret of yours as you could not free or save Asriel from she was trapped in and save her from her own self-imposed misery…

Following this event, you and Frisk went outside of the mountain to see the sun finally rise over the new day. However, this is where the bitter end finally comes full circle.

As the sun rose over the new day time seem to freeze for you for a second and before you knew what you were back at the bottom of the hole that you found frisk in and saw flowey reappear and say the same damn words from before when she originally met the two of you…

You were confused and had no idea what just happened, you thought by letting the monsters go free you assumed the cycle would have ended, but it appears you were wrong. It wasn’t until after you left this world that you feel the realized the true systematic problem with it and after realizing the full problem you realize it would be impossible to fully free these worlds from the cycle that they were trapped in.

This was your greatest regret about this world, but just because the world can’t be free from it's temporal cycle doesn’t mean you can’t free Toriel from the cycle permanently.

Freeing Toriel and bringing her here to be your second comes with many benefits as Toriel is a master Pyromancer with a long history with administrative duties, not to mention she makes great pies!

So do you want to recruit Toriel to your cause?

2.Undyne: the captain of the Royal guard and the closet Otaku, who secretly wishes that she could be a magical girl. Undyne was perhaps the craziest monster that you met during your time the underground, So its not a surprise that when you first met the fish girl that she instantly tried to attack you.

As when you first met Undyne, she tried to kill both you and frisk in order to harvest your souls to free monster kind from the cavernous prison that they had long since trapped in. Thankfully thanks to the agility enhancements to your armor and Undyne’s insane training practices of loading her armor up with weights, that you and frisk were able to outrun her and wear her down until she finally collapsed when she chased the two of you into Hotland, the magma center of mount Ebott.

When Undyne finally collapsed from dehydration and overheating, you easily see that her plate armor essentially was cooking her alive like a sauna suit. However not taking any chances you told frisk to go on ahead while you checked on the downed fish girl. As the young mute girl ran on ahead to the next room, you slowly walked over to check on the blue fish girl and found that the walking sushi was completely Knocked out and looked seconds away from a heat stroke.

So, you did the most logical thing at the time and started peeling the crazy fish girl out of her armor, but as you did so, you found out that undyne likes to go commando from time to time. As for when you peeled her out of her ridiculously heavy armor, you found out that the fish girl was completely naked underneath! However, the topic of Undyne’s dressing habits is something that can be discussed later as you had far more pressing matters to deal with at that time, such as ensuring that Undyne didn’t suffer a heat stroke.

Luckily there was a water cooler nearby filled to the brim with cool water, unluckily though you dropped the damn thing and had its entire contents evaporate in seconds due to the heat that Hotland was so well known for. Even more unfortunate was that you had no bottled water in your inventory to give to the Knocked out fish girl who was getting closer and closer to a damn heatstroke.

You had to get Undyne something to hydrate her, and you had nothing on hand that could help her except… Well… It’s embarrassing as hell but in order to ensure that Undyne didn’t die you were **** to whip out your Mini-me and… cover Undyne in your batter.

Which of course immediately woke the exhausted fish girl right up and for a second there you thought she was going to try and skewer you for what you had to do to save her life. Especially since she was completely red in the face with a pissed off expression but just as you thought you should run for the hills, Undyne hesitantly licked at a rope of the pure alabaster white seed that you covered her with and quickly turned about face and walked out left you alone and as she did this you could hear the fish girl mutter something about “delicious” before running off with a look of great indecision and self-hatred.

After that little incident, you and frisk didn’t come back into contact with Undyne until Papyrus introduced you to his best friend. Who Surprise, surprise was Undyne, and it was safe to say that you wished that you had jumped out the window with Papyrus after being stuck with the crazy fish girl. Awkward and tense could not even begin to describe the situation that you found yourself in with Undyne, thankfully frisk was there to mend the bridges between the two of you.

Though did she did so at the cost of setting Undyne's house on fire, not that she minded as she was just going to go and crash at papyrus’s house until she could get a new one. Apparently, this happened more often than you expected, but just as you and frisk were about to leave Undyne pulled you off to the side and demanded an actual fight for the humiliation you inflicted upon her, not wanting to waste frisk’s attempts to make friends with those that lived in the underground you agreed to this rematch.

However, this fight that Undyne wanted would be in a place of her choosing, which she surprisingly chose to be the hotel in Snowden of all places.

It wasn’t until you arrived at the hotel room did you discover the true meaning of this “fight” that Undyne wanted. You see ever since tasting your seed, Undyne was completely haunted by its flavor and was not only sexually frustrated but also unbelievably angry at herself for allowing such a weakness to exist. So in her own whacked out logic she figured that the only way to get rid of this weakness would be to embrace it entirely so that it wouldn’t haunt her anymore but if she was going to do this, and she would be doing this on her terms and on her terms alone. Which is what led to this, Undyne wanted to “fight” you in a way that would satisfy her new cravings and satisfy her frustrations.

So, you ended up "fighting" Undyne in a battle for dominance in bed, a battle that was long fought over the course of the entire night but ended with you as the victor. However, you had a strong feeling that both you and Undyne came out as winner’s if that silly expression on her face was anything to go by. Of course, this wasn't the only time that Undyne decided to “fight” you as she kept coming back for more and even brought her new girlfriend, Alphys into the mix! It just wasn't Alphys and Undyne either as Toriel got involved as well and had no hang-ups on the idea of sharing you with others, just so long as you invited her to join in on the fun.

Shaking your head clear those fun memories you think on the advantages of recruiting Undyne to your cause. Undyne is a seasoned warrior and is an extremely skilled magic user and has led and even trained other soldiers, a skill that could be very useful to train up your mouse men. That said it Undyne comes with their own negatives as well she often jumps headfirst into a situation without thinking ahead and has a strong sense of right and wrong…

So, do you want to invite this crazy warrior on to your team?

3.Alphys: the nerdy otaku and Ex-mad scientist, Alphys was perhaps the most socially awkward monster you had ever encountered in the underground. Despite this social awkwardness, Alphys was extremely kind and friendly to both you and frisk, despite the fact she created a killer robot in the form of Mettaton. Who by the way actually did try to kill both you and frisk but thankfully ended up running out of power before he could actually do so.

Anyway, Alphys was one of the most friendly monsters you met during your time in the underground, but this friendliness hid a dark secret of Alphys’s that you ended up discovering later on. As apparently Alphys conducted a series of experiments to attempt to give monsters natural human souls which only ended up creating a series of abominations that you and frisk stumbled upon when you found her sub lab and when the two you found you had to protect frisk from these abominations and were about to put these things out of their misery Alphys showed up at the last minute and stopped you. After returning the… Test subjects back to their rooms Alphys brought you and Frisk back up to her normal lab to explain everything and essentially confessed her guilt about the horrific experiments that she conducted on those monsters that lived in the sub lab down below and told you and frisk that she would understand if the two of you never wanted to speak her again after learning about what she had done.

However, much to Alphys’s surprise you and frisk stayed the scientist’s friend despite learning of the horrible things she had done to those people down below. For the simple fact that she feels guilty for doing what she did and was trying to make amends and for this you and frisk saw that there was hope for redemption in Alphys. Though with that said she needed to get out a little more, which she did as you and frisk ended up setting her up on a date with the one person she had the biggest crush on, that person, of course, being none other than Undyne.

So, a plan was hatched, a plan that you personally named “Help The Neet short stack get a date.” This plan divided up into two parts; frisk would go and get Undyne, while you would help Alphys get ready for her date. So as frisk went off to get the fish stick, you did your best to help Alphys get ready for her date, but as Alphys got changed you decided to kill time by browsing Alphys’s computer to see what kind of anime she was able to get her hands on.

Alphys was a gigantic otaku thanks to the fact that a lot of human junk ends in the underground due to the waterfall being connected to a river that runs past a dump. So sometimes things trickle in, like a huge crate of anime memorabilia that Alphys found one day while scavaging at the falls and was instantly hooked on anime, but were sidetracking now.

So putting the focus back on your past with Alphys, you began to browse her computer and ended up finding a rather large file, being curious you decide to dig deeper and what you found surprised you to no end. As the file was apparently Aphlys porn file, which contained a variety of hentai, nude images, but most surprising of all were the rather large video files that were in it that had you having sex with the various women that lived in the underground. It appears that Alphys was quite the voyeur and just as you were about to open up one of the said files you were interrupted by none other than Alphys herself and she of course was absolutely freaked out at the sight of you in her porn file.

After calming the former mad scientist down, you and Alphys had a little discussion in which you learned that Alphys had been watching your every step with frisk outside of the ruins. Alphys was able to do this via a series of spy cams she had set up through the entire underground, Alphys went on to explain that her observation of you and frisk start out rather innocently and she just wanted to ensure that the two of you didn’t hurt any of the other monsters in the underground.

However, that all changed when her spy cameras started to see you have “relations” with some of the female monsters that existed there in the underground. At first, Alphys tried to ignore your sexy adventures with the female monsters that existed down in the underground but eventually she could no longer resist her urges and thus began to watch your many romps throughout the underground.

These urges especially came into full effect when Alphys began to compare your many romps throughout the underground with the hentai she was able to scavenge from the waterfall. The way she described the comparison was essentially seeing a real-life monster hentai situation play out, except the roles were reversed as instead of a human woman being shagged into oblivion by a monster. It was instead a human man fucking the very sanity out of a monster girl, something that she admittedly fantasized about happening to her as she watched your many escapades.

You personally had no idea how to feel about Alphys watching your many different sexual adventures like they were porno’s, but you couldn’t exactly blame Alphys for watching them. Especially when you began to put in to consideration Alphys’s situation, she’s a socially awkward monster that’s big into a type of fiction that most monsters don’t even know about, she rarely if ever leaves her laboratory, she has overwhelming self-esteem and guilt issues, and she is a complete and total virgin when it comes to romantic situations.

So yeah its not that really surprising why Alphys would start recording your many sexual adventures down here in the underground because for her this is probably the only sexual excitement she’s had in a very long time. Because of this you ultimately decided to let it go and let Alphys keep the recorded videos of you having your sexual adventures in the underground but told her to stop recording anymore them, especially since you are going out of your way to ensure that she got a girlfriend so she wouldn’t need to peep on your sexual adventures anymore.

Alphys was greatly relieved at this compromise that you offered her and readily agreed to stop recording your adventures down in the underground. However, this was not the last time you had to deal with the sexual frustrations of the yellow short stack Dino. Because a couple of weeks later after you and frisk got Alphys and Undyne together, you were approached by the two of them with a surprising offer.

This offer is what eventually led into you essentially becoming their fuck buddy, as apparently Alphys was really big into role-playing and wanted to explore some more adventurous situations with her girlfriend. These situations varied from time to time, but you remember that Alphys and Undyne’s favorite role-play was ironically having you play the twisted and evil king who kidnapped the Hero’s (Unydne) bride (Alphys) and turned her into your own personal Cock sleeve. After which the hero would arrive and try to defeat you in a game of sexual prowess in order to win her bride back.

The irony of the situation is now not lost on you as you have now effectively become an evil overlord bent on conquering the multi-verse and its women.

Shaking your head from your memories, you begin to consider the pros and cons of recruiting Alphys.

The main pros of recruiting Alphys is that she’s an experienced scientist who has created some pretty amazing and absolutely fascinating creations out of spare parts and junk. You could only begin to imagine what Alphys could do if she had the top-of-the-line technology at her disposal, the technology she could develop could help you sidestep many problems throughout your adventure.

Then you have to consider the cons of recruiting Alphys, those cons being that Alphys has an overwhelming sense of guilt and regret for the experiments she performed on those monsters that hang out in her sub laboratory. So she may not be willing to do certain experiments because of this, not to mention recruiting Alphys may be a package deal. Because if you recruit her, then more likely than not you’re going to have to recruit Mettaton and had to put up with his egotistical and his…

Well, you wouldn’t say flaming gay as you're pretty sure Mettaton doesn’t have a gender, but you will say he’s pretty damn flamboyant to the point that you’re pretty sure that he could light a house on fire if he wanted to.

Still, you can’t deny having Alphys on your side wouldn’t be beneficial. So you want to recruit the former mad scientist to your cause?

4. Combo of two of them or all three: this is an extremely risky and resource draining option. As the issue rises from the requirement of ground the three of them here in your pocket dimension in order to prevent the three of them from being dragged back into their home world via the temporal vortex it's trapped in with it's many, many alternates.

then comes the issue of reawakening their memories of the previous timeline, as that would require the aid of the life reactor in order to do. That would drain even more power away from the reactor, so much so that it would **** you to shut down the alien island's factory and as result you wouldn't be able to equip your minion's with the proper firearms and would be **** to give them simple weapons in the form of melee weapons.

This would **** you into a bottleneck that your not to sure your comfortable with, as you would be **** to conquer exceptionally weak worlds or worlds without hero's in them, till you are able to refill the reactor.

So the only question remains on that one is whether or not you’re willing to take the high risk for the high reward of having all three in your side.

#:look at the AUs version and other options...


Who do you pick?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)