A Night With Little Sis

***Voting Outcome: Okay after what I'd say was a good voting period, thanks to everyone who participated, we have our decision. Seven votes for Rachel wins it, Melanie and Claire were tied with four and poor Taylor only came in with one measly vote. Anyway, thanks again for voting guys and enjoy! ***

You ran your fingers through your hair and thought things over, Melanie had been your bread and butter all day today and most of the day yesterday. You loved hanging out with her as she got you perfectly, she knew her place and didn't mind it in the slightest. So you figured that your night with her would be pretty standard in the end, you'd screw around, maybe fuck her face throughout the night and end up passing out with her. Not a bad night in the slightest, but not what you wanted tonight.

Then you thought back to Claire, your loving, whorish step-mother who basically begged you to got to her room tonight, and cum all over her face. It surprised you that somehow Claire had already beat Melanie in the whore factor, what kind of step-mother would swap cum with her step-daughter, cum that belonged to her step-son no less. Then to top it off, only thirty minutes later, she comes out here and starts to seduce you...the gall. You let out a soft chuckle and shook your head; Claire wasn't your choice either.

You gave a final glance at your phone, still seeing nothing from Taylor, you shrugged and went back to cooking. Minutes past as you strained the pasta and poured in the sauce, heating it up properly, "So...what's your answer?" Melanie asked as she walked back into the kitchen,

"Sorry, Mel, not tonight. I think I'm gonna spend it with Rachel, see where it goes." You replied with a little smirk to your older sister,

"Oh," Melanie replied a little forlorn,

"Hey, I just want to spread the love around," You chuckled, "Rachel's had the worst of me these last few days, I want to see if I can make it better." You explained before pausing and looking at Melanie with a smirk, "Speaking of which, I remember we had something of a deal. You promised to help me get Rachel to like sucking my cock,"

"Hmm? Oh! Oh yeah, David, that's right." Melaine smiled with a quick nod, "Um, well the first part of that would be getting her back on speaking terms,"

"Done," You replied while crossing her arms, "Next?"

"So, this is going to be the hard part; you need to make Rachel initiate the first move." Melanie explained in a hushed tone, "Rachel's new to all this, she's gonna be scared normally, but since you already fucked her throat against her will, she's gonna be even worse with you. So you need to make her comfortable, hint at things but don't pressure her into it. If you're lucky her curiosity will get the better of her, and she'll offer to help you out." Melanie said with a thoughtful smile,

You nodded your head; you hadn't thought of that, having your little sister offer to suck you off sounded pretty nice, if not even cute. "I like it, dinner with Rachel finished off with her sucking my cock, sounds fun."

"Ah-Ah, that's not the whole plan here David," Melanie said with a shake of her head, "Part one is making her want to do it, part two is denying her."

"What?" You blankly asked back,

"You tell her no, tell her you'll have me handle it or Taylor, honestly tell her whatever you want but just don't let Rachel suck you off." You dismissively looked at Melanie and frowned in confusion, "Just listen," Melanie said while putting her hands on your shoulders, "If you let Rachel blow you tonight she'll know you only want that from her, making her start to resent you. Sure she'll reluctantly blow you now, but she'll never like it." Melanie said causing you to let out a small sigh and nod, "But, if you deny her tonight, she'll start to wonder why. She'll ask herself, "Why doesn't David want me? What's wrong, I offered to suck his cock? Who denies that?" Then she'll start to get annoyed. Rachel won't be able to stop herself from thinking about sucking your cock, and the longer you wait, the more obsessed she'll get. Before you know it, Rachel with be crawling towards your cock, throat fucking you, loving every moment of it."

You felt your cock pulse as you imagine your beautiful blonde little sister crawling on all fours towards your cock. Sucking you down as best she could, learning how to swallow her brother's cock before taking your load. Then she'd thank you for it! You liked having the power to fuck any woman's throat in this world but why not have them lusting after you too? Plus, if you did wait and turn Rachel into this horny monster, then you wouldn't have to deal with **** glares every time she saw you. Instead, it'd be the gorgeous eyes of a horny woman, ready to suck your cock at a moments notice...all if you waited...that's the hard part.

"Right, wait...no head from Rachel tonight...just spending time with my baby sis, like usual." You sighed back as your cock continued to twitch,

Melanie let out a murmuring laugh and leaned forward, deeply kissing you as her hand grouped your stiff cock, "I know it sounds hard to resist, but it'd be worth it. Rachel would let you do anything to her if she wanted you bad enough, you could teach your little sister everything." Melanie whispered out causing you to groan,

"Doing this isn't gonna help my control..." You sighed as Melanie squeezed your shaft through your pants,

"It's part of your training; you need to get a little self-control so you can pull this off." Melanie replied as her hand continued to paw at your crotch, "Now, you do this right, and don't touch Rachel then I promise I'll get you off as many times as you want later. You can fuck my face...you know what, you can just fuck me David, whatever you want." She warmly smiled before tenderly kissing your lips, nibbling on your bottom lip, "Or you can go and fuck with Claire, call Taylor, go outside and find a jogger and face fuck her for an hour! You've got options; it doesn't have to be Rachel, remember that."

"But her mouth...it was built to suck cock, Mel," You groaned back causing her to laugh,

"I know, I know, it's gonna be okay little bro, you can do this." Melanie assured you while walking away, "I'll be in my room if you need me, mouth ready and willing...pussy and ass too," She added on with a wink,

"Jesus...I love her," You mumbled out while you watched Melanie leave the kitchen and head back to her room.

With a deep breath, you shook off your lustful thoughts and prepared two plates of food, then walked down to Rachels room. You lightly knocked on the door with your elbow and waited, "One second!" Rachel happily replied, "Just changing!" You shut your eyes, grumbling in your head at Rachel's accidental teasing. A moment later Rachel opened up her door, and her smile started to fade, "Oh...David...I thought you said you weren't doing anything to me anymore," She lowly said,

"I'm not!" You replied with a smile, "I just wanted to really bury the hatchet you know, here I brought you some food and I just thought...why not hang out with my little sis tonight. No shenanigans, promise." You sternly said while Rachel took her plate from your hand,

"Oh," Rachel said in some surprise, "Um, okay, I guess? I mean, if you really want to," Rachel said with a shrug as she turned around,

Your eyes locked on Rachel's perfect bubbly ass, bouncing all the way back to her bed before you tore your eyes away. "So, what do you want to do? Chill out, talk, movie? I'm up for anything, just want things to be cool between us again,"

Rachel blinked as you walked in and sat down at her computer desk, genuinely surprised that you seemed to be serious about your offer. "Let's...watch a movie," Rachel replied with a now warm smile, "I was just about to watch one anyway,"

"Sounds great, Rach, pop the sucker in," You sighed back while looking up at her flat screen, "I'm gonna get a kink in my neck for it, but it'll be worth it," You joked as you had to look all the way up from her lower computer chair just to see the screen,

"Well...I mean, you can sit on my bed. It has a better view on the TV anyway," Rachel nervously said causing you to flash her a thankful smile.

You got up and walked over to her bed, Rachel receded back for a moment but calmed as you sat down at the edge of the bed. "Thanks, that's better." You merely replied as Rachel cocked her head, once again surprised that you didn't do something like move right next to her and just pin her down. "Press play, Rach, dinner and a movie awaits!"

"Yeah, okay," Rachel said now flashing you a smile, "You know, I don't remember the last time we watched a movie together, actually,"

"Me either...you know, I'm glad I did this," You warmly replied while glancing over at the now calm and happy blonde, her smile almost intoxicating you immediately,

Rachel wet her lips and lightly rocked her head for a moment before lowering her head and saying, "Me too,"

You smirked to yourself and looked back to the television; Plan seems to be working rather well, she's a lot cuter when she's like this. Still...she's a lot hotter with my cock in her mouth. You thought as you took a bite of your dinner. Minutes passed as you both ate and just about a half an hour later, of only small talk, eating and watching the movie you were finished. Your cock was still hard, aching for a release and the more Rachel sweetly talked to you, every so slightly shifting closer to your body, the harder it was to resist her.

"D-David?" Rachel timidly asked as you reached over and put your plate down on her end table,

"What's up?" You asked while glancing over at her, seeing a coy nervous look,

"Look, I know why you're really here. Let's be honest; you just want me to blow you." You raised a brow and silently stared at her. Rachel broke into a nervous laugh, "I mean, it's nice that you are trying to butter me up, try and convince me to do this but it's kinda easy to tell what you're doing."

"Is it?" You asked back while turning your body to face her,

"Yeah, so look..." Rachel sighed while rubbing her arm, "I know you can **** me to do whatever you want, but if you really want me to blow you, can I just do it? Like, let me stay in control, don't face fuck me and all that hard shit like before? I can do that for you if you want...I mean, I know that's what you want." She said, unable to look you directly in the eye. You wet your lips and looked her over, an adorable nervous mess.

A) Rachel knows your plan, might as well go back to basics, Throat Fuck Her!

B) Agree to let Rachel keep control and enjoy her nervous, but accepting blowjob.

C) Things are going to plan, leave like Mel told you and have her handle your cock tonight.

D) Things are going to plan, leave and have Claire work out your pent up load onto her face!