She agrees to help

Cindy let's out a deep sigh. Once she finishes her exhale she stares at her feet and shuffles them nervously. She looks up when the screen door to the house creaks open. Both of you see Ashley poking her head out only far enough so her naked body is still hidden behind the door.

She looks you in the eyes. You think you see an angry fire burning behind her pupils. "Okay. But you promise to destroy those photos once we're done?"

Your grin tightens. "Of course." You suddenly feel powerful and your eyes roam freely over her body. "But you promise to not tell Ashley the truth and do everything you can to support her?"

She swallows hard. "Y-Yes...I think...what do you mean by everything?"

"Well, for starters you're going to march back in there and apologize to Ashley. After that, you'll strip and sit at the table to enjoy the pie. Of course, I'll protest but you'll tell me you're doing it in solidarity with Ashley. Then you'll call your parents and tell them you're staying here tonight. We'll all sit down together and watch a movie before going to bed." Your eagerness to be able to control when these two girls are naked gets the best of you and the words just flow out of your mouth.

Cindy looks back to the door where Ashley is no longer watching. Her lower lips trembles. "All right, Mr. Doe, but I need one condition, okay? I know I'm not in a position to bargain but to help me through this," she pauses and takes a deep breath, "you need to promise if I get naked you won't touch me tonight."

You can feel your cock start to stiffen in your pants. You hadn't thought about touching her until she mentioned it.