Which time?

“Which time?” Buffy asked him simply.

Xander paused, he had to take a few deep breaths to ensure he remained conscious. “You mean ...” Xander began slowly “You have used a spell on me on more than one occasion to have sex with me.”

“Yeah,” Buffy said. “It was only suppose to be once of course. But after the first time it was just too tempting and I had too use the spell again after that.”

Xander leaned forward not believing what Buffy was saying “How many times?”

Buffy shrugged simply, “I lost count.”

Xander stared at her “Have you been the only one?”

“Not always,” she replied with a satisfied smirk thinking of some pleasant memories.

Xander thought about the situation “Buffy has used a spell to have sex with me, and she has not always been alone when doing so.”

“Well at least this eliminates any guilt I may have had about using magic to have sex with her,” he thought before continuing with his questions “Well why don't you tell me what you think where the best times?”

Buffy paused as she thought it over. “Well, the first time with you was very enjoyable, it was not long after you cast that love spell and I guess I still had some desires swirling around that got it all started. The first time I shared you with Willow to get her more comfortable with sex was also very good, though the times we shared after she figured out she was a lesbian were also wonderful. Hmmmm, oh, shared you with Faith once before she turned evil which was very hot. The bachelor/bachelorette that Will, I, and a few others had for you and Anya was quite enjoyable. I think my favorite though was when Cordy, Will, and I had a special graduation party with you.”

“Cordelia, Anya, and Willow have all been involved,” Xander thought even more stunned. “Buffy ... have you used magic to have anyone else join?”

Buffy once again shrugged. “Some, but mostly not sure. In fact I sometimes suspect that what I am doing is magic induced. For awhile Will certainly didn't have a problem using magic to get what she desired.”

Xander thought about what he was going to do next, he certainly needed some time to just think over what Buffy had told him, though his cock certainly had other ideas. “Buffy ... describe more in detail what you have done with me under magic.”

“Which time Xan? There have been a lot more than just what you asked about.” Buffy asked. She was sitting fairly calmly though Xander could tell her thinking about these past events had gotten her quite aroused.

“Good question,” Xander thought. He wouldn't mind pursuing any of those stories. Of course he also wouldn't mind just stripping Buffy naked and fucking her either at the moment.