"What?"

"What?" I babbled, tucking my limp cock back into my pants.

"I want to get pregnant as well," Talia repeated.

Everyone stared at her with our mouths agape, dumbstruck by her revelation.

"I want to Ian to give me a baby," she told Elizabeth and started to sob.

My wife got up from the table and went over to hug Talia and lead her to sit on the couch in the living room. "Honey, what's wrong?"

"Remember I had told you guys at the reunion that Rachel and I broke up because we had drifted apart?" Talia sniffed.

Everyone nodded.

"Well, I didn't tell you the entire truth," she continued, wiping her tears with the box of Kleenex I had handed her. "I wanted to have children and she didn't. But what upset her the most was that I wanted Ian to be the father. She never liked the fact that I was bisexual, enjoying cock as much as I loved pussy, and not one hundred percent lesbian like her. She never got over the fact that I loved being fucked by Ian and that in the heat of lust she gave into pressure to be fucked by him."

Everyone looked at me and I gave a look of surprise at the ten-year-old secret fling with Rachel. No-one was shocked nor upset at me over the news considering that I was their lover with each of them at one point or another during our senior year. Hell, we even had an orgy on prom night!

"Why Ian?" Elizabeth asked curiously.

"Because Ian was the only man I had been with since I came out during in our last year in high school," Talia explained. "Rachel got upset that all I would talk about was Ian being the perfect man to father our... my children."

I looked at my wife and she smiled back reassuringly. I knew that she understood Talia's feelings for me — she did after all married her perfect man.

"I'm still in love with Rachel but I really want a baby," Talia sniffed. "Can you believe that 'basket case' Talia being a mother?"

"Yes, I can," Elizabeth replied, giving her friend another much needed hug.

The other girls voiced their agreement and gave Talia a hugs and kisses. They were all crying at this point.

"I'm honored that you hold me in such high regard, Talia. Thank you," I told her when it was my turn to hug her. "You're very special in my life too." Each of the five girls were special to me in their own unique way.

"When things got heated at my apartment after the reunion," Talia confessed, holding my hands in hers while looking me in the eyes, "I had hoped you would cum in me and I would get pregnant."

I stared at Talia for a moment before looking at Elizabeth. Considering I had fucked all five girls that night I was surprised none of them didn't get knocked up, especially my wife. "You weren't on the pill?"

"No, I wasn't," Talia replied. "Remember, I was in a monogamous lesbian relationship and the last man to fuck me was you back in high school!"

"Okay," Elizabeth blurted.

"Okay what?" I asked her.

"Okay, you can get her pregnant," she replied.

"Seriously?" I stared at my wife, surprised by her decision.

She nodded and smiled at Talia. All of the girls squealed and hugged Elizabeth tightly for granting Talia permission to try to fulfil her dream of motherhood with me. Eventually the girls turned their attention back to me and I suddenly felt like a lamb surrounded by hungry lionesses.

"Anyone else wants to get pregnant?" I joked but the girls weren't laughing.

"Honey, let's go upstairs," Elizabeth said in a tone that was more of an order than a suggestion. I had seen the look of passion on the girls many times before, so I wasn't going to say no.