Find the priest

As to leave you summon a little gift for Wendy.

"Wendy this is for your help."

You draw on the powers of darkness and summon a creature that looks a bit like a thin shiny black earthworm.

Wendy smiles. "What is it mistress?"

"A demonic parasite, Wendy. It will reward you for evil thoughts. It will help you become a creature of darkness, if you desire it. Now hold still!"

You bring the creature up to her ear and smile at the hint of fear in her eyes. You bring the parasite up to her ear and it slithers in. There is a moment of pain on Wendy's face. The she smiles.

"It...it feels...wonderful."

"I'm glad. Take this." You hand her a riding crop. Her face contorts with pleasure.

As you walk out you hear the snap of the riding crop. "Liz, get over here and lick my pussy you little bitch!"

So much for mousy Wendy, soon enough she'll be a useful tool.

You make your way across town to the church where Alana's old boyfriend preaches. As you step onto hallowed ground your power weakens. You can enter the church, but you will be nearly powerless.

Instead you stealthily peek into windows. The first two yield nothing. You look into the third and see Alana in the priests quarters. Her body is partly changed. She looks like a ripe juicy fruit eager to be tasted. If it wasn't for the church she might already have been reborn.

You could break in, hopefully her resistance has worn away. Of course you could wait for nightfall and pursue other ways of seducing her.