Chapter 93
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
The Detonator
"There you are!" Zara announced immediately, already smiling. "Okay, first of all, you took long enough and second of all, if you hated it you have to tell me gently because I emotionally invested in your opinion like an idiot."
From the couch, Roy watched the interaction unfold with growing unease. Not because of the women themselves. The opposite, really.
Zara looked radiant. That was the first thing that struck him. Standing in the doorway in those tiny yellow shorts and spaghetti-strapped top, glasses slightly crooked, she practically glowed with excitement. Every gesture carried energy behind it. Every expression arrived at full volume. Whatever nervousness she'd carried the night before had evaporated somewhere between breakfast and book discussions.
And the blonde woman standing in the hallway matched her easily. Beautiful. Polished. Older than Zara by at least a decade. Athletic build. Perfect makeup. The kind of effortless suburban attractiveness that probably took forty-five minutes and expensive products to achieve. Even from across the room Roy could tell she took care of herself.
"I didn't hate it," the blonde replied dryly. "I came here voluntarily, didn't I?"
"Oh my God, you liked it."
"Slow down, nerd."
"I knew it!"
Zara grabbed her arm and bounced once in place like she'd just won concert tickets. Roy smiled despite himself. Then the feeling hit.
Sharp.
Sudden.
Wrong.
Every tiny hair along his arms stood up at once. A prickling awareness slid across the back of his neck, electric and cold, like static building before lightning struck nearby. The sensation lasted barely longer than a heartbeat. But it was enough.
No.
God no.
Not again.
The smile vanished from Roy's face as the implications landed all at once. His stomach sank hard enough to feel physical. Somewhere deep inside his chest, disappointment folded into guilt with brutal efficiency.
Too late. Another woman caught. Another innocent bystander dragged into this mess because Roy Robinson had once drunkenly wished to be loved.
A heavy ache settled behind his ribs as he climbed off the couch. The movement felt automatic, almost ritualistic now. Like his body already knew the steps:
- Approach.
- Meet them.
- Watch reality rearrange itself.
Across the apartment, Zara and her friend were still talking about books, oblivious to the cosmic disaster unfolding around them. Roy barely heard the words anymore. Instead, his thoughts snagged helplessly on Zara. Had it been enough?
That question chased him with every step toward the doorway. He genuinely liked her. More than liked her, honestly. Spending the morning together had felt absurdly easy. Comfortable. Fun. Zara made ordinary moments feel brighter somehow.
But love? Roy didn't know. Not the way he loved Elaine. Not the way Michelle had somehow carved herself permanently into his heart.
Could he get there eventually? Absolutely. Without question. Zara was warm and funny and endlessly enthusiastic about everything she cared about. The world felt more interesting beside her. But eventually might not matter anymore.
The blonde woman finally looked up from Zara. And smiled. Not polite. Not curious. Warm. Familiar. Immediate. Directly at him.
"Roy!" she said brightly, eyes lighting up. "Good morning, honey-cakes!"
Oh, Jesus Christ.
She moved before Roy could even think of a response, brushing past Zara without hesitation. The scent of expensive perfume drifted ahead of her, something floral layered over vanilla. Confident footsteps crossed the apartment quickly.
Then she kissed him.
Not tentative.
Not uncertain.
Experienced.
One hand slipped behind Roy's neck while her mouth settled against his with the kind of effortless familiarity that made his brain briefly stop functioning. Soft lips. Perfect pressure. A slow lingering confidence that communicated one undeniable truth:
This woman knew exactly what she was doing.

And God help him, she was incredible at it.
Roy had almost no real basis for comparison before the wish. Childhood kisses behind playground equipment didn't exactly qualify as expertise. But over the last weeks, he'd learned quickly.
Elaine kissed like comfort wrapped in heat.
Michelle kissed with enthusiasm that bordered on worship.
Zara kissed like discovery itself.
This woman?
This woman kissed like she'd spent years weaponizing charm.
The thought arrived somewhere far away beneath the immediate flood of warmth and surprise and feminine perfume. Roy found himself kissing her back before common sense managed to re-enter the building.
Then—
"AHEM."
The sound cracked through the apartment like a referee whistle.
Roy jerked backward slightly.
Zara stood near the door with her arms crossed tightly beneath her chest, staring at them with open irritation.
"Okay, you lovebirds, knock it off," she said. "At least not in my apartment. You know I don't approve."
The blonde snorted softly.
"Then it's a good thing I don't need your approval, nerd."
And then she kissed Roy again.
Lord almighty.
Roy's brain briefly turned to pudding.
"I mean it," Zara said sharply, stepping forward and smacking Roy lightly on the arm hard enough to snap him out of the moment. "Not here. If you want to do that, go out. Go on a date. Do something. Just not here where I can see you two... you know..."
The blonde finally pulled away, grinning unapologetically.
"Fine. I can be patient." Her fingers squeezed Roy's wrist lightly before releasing him. "It's not like my boyfriend comes with an expiry date or anything."
The sentence hit Roy strangely. An expiry date. God. If only she knew.
While Roy tried to mentally recover, the blonde retrieved the paperback she'd dropped onto the coffee table during her charge across the apartment.
"This book messed me up, by the way," she announced, handing it back to Zara. "Like genuinely. I was thinking about it in the shower this morning."
Zara gasped dramatically. "YES. Okay. Okay, thank God."
"I'm serious," the blonde continued. "That whole idea that humanity might just be... broadcasting itself into the dark without understanding what's listening? Horrifying."
"Right?!" Zara practically vibrated. "And the sophons! Oh my God, the sophons! The idea that science itself could be sabotaged before humanity even realizes it's at war?"
Roy hovered awkwardly nearby while the women launched fully into discussion mode.
"It's the scale that got me," the blonde said. "Everything felt so big and hopeless and inevitable."
"But also human," Zara countered immediately. "That's why it works. Everyone's still just people making emotional decisions even while civilization collapses around them."
"Some of those emotional decisions were terrible."
"Yes, but realistic terrible."
Roy listened quietly while making absolutely no contribution whatsoever.
Apparently this was happening now.
"And the Dark Forest stuff?" Zara continued excitedly. "The idea that everyone's hiding because the universe punishes anything that reveals itself? That's one of the coolest concepts ever written."
The blonde pointed accusingly at her. "See? That. That's exactly the kind of sentence that would've made me avoid this book if you'd led with it."
"You loved it though."
"I did."
"You LOVED it."
"I said I did."
Zara made a triumphant noise.
Watching them together stirred something unexpectedly unpleasant in Roy's stomach. The friendship between them was real. Established. Comfortable in ways he wasn't part of. Shared references. Shared history. Shared enthusiasm. Roy suddenly felt like an outsider sitting three feet away from his own life. And worse...
Zara still hadn't looked at him romantically again.
No flirting. No touching. No lingering glances. Just irritation every time he'd kissed the Iris.
Maybe that was it, then. Maybe whatever fragile emotional bridge he'd been trying to build with her hadn't been enough after all. The thought landed heavily. Because losing Zara hurt more than expected.
Eventually the blonde reached over and grabbed Roy's hand directly.
"Time for us to go," she announced cheerfully. "I only have a few more hours."
Roy blinked. "What?"
But she was already tugging him toward the door. Across the apartment, Zara scowled openly.
"I don't know why you have to be like this, Iris," she muttered. "George is a good man. Why are you treating him like this?"
Roy stopped walking.
George?
Iris paused near the doorway.
"George is a good man," she agreed easily. "Roy is a great man."
Something unpleasantly proud flickered in Roy's chest despite the growing confusion.
"More than that," Iris continued, glancing back toward him with startling sincerity, "he's everything I need. It's not like I don't love my husband. I do. But I can't imagine a world where I'm not with Roy."
Roy stared at her.
Husband?
"What?" escaped him weakly.
Neither woman acknowledged it.
"Can't you, of all people, understand that?" Iris asked Zara.
A moment passed. Then Zara sighed dramatically.
"Yeah," she admitted. "He is absolutely worth it. The best thing. The best one. I get it." Her expression tightened slightly. "But still... doesn't George deserve better? Like, to know? To make his own choices?"
Roy's thoughts screeched to a halt. Wait.
Wait wait wait.
Zara still...
The realization crashed into him so suddenly it almost felt dizzying.
She still loved him. Not past tense. Not discarded. Not erased. Hope exploded through him. Maybe it had worked. Maybe he'd actually done it. Maybe...
"I'll tell him when I tell him," Iris said with a shrug. "If I tell him. He's had me for years. Three kids I gave that man. Now it's finally time I have something for myself."
Three kids. Roy nearly tripped over his own feet. He pulled the apartment door open for his companion. Across the apartment, Zara locked eyes with him, the enthusiasm and energy she was known for began to spill out o fher.
"Call me tonight, Roy!" Zara shouted after them. "I miss you already!"
Then the door slammed shut behind them. And immediately Iris was kissing him again. Hard. Roy's back hit the hallway wall with a dull thump while her hands slid up into his hair. Passion rolled off her in waves, hot and immediate and absolutely overwhelming. But Roy's brain wasn't focused on the kiss anymore.
Married.
Three children.
George.
Holy shit.
It wasn't just his life getting tangled up anymore. This wish wasn't merely handing him girlfriends.
It was detonating marriages.
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Everyone's Boyfriend
Becoming the kind of guy that women want...
Roy Robinson's life isn't going great. A soft middle, a work rival out to get him, and no love life to speak of. Suddenly, thanks to an errant wish, his life takes a dramatic turn for the better.
Updated on Jun 10, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Dec 26, 2025
by Mr Nice Guy
- 7,631 Likes
- 449,420 Views
- 1,089 Favorites
- 698 Bookmarks
- 108 Chapters
- 105 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
