Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by Luke_Powers Luke_Powers

Saturday Arrives

Room 214

Saturday arrived with the weight of a dentist appointment Hazel had been dreading for months. She dressed deliberately—plain cotton thong, a bra without lace, nothing that might suggest enthusiasm. Ethan text Dan at three: Room 214. Knock twice. Ethan had paced their living room all morning, adjusting his erection through his sweatpants every five minutes like a teenager.

The hotel smelled like Febreze. Hazel perched on the edge of the bed, ankles crossed, scrolling X while Ethan checked the nightstand for condoms for the fourth time. "He’ll bring his own," she said without looking up.

Ethan's fingers hovered over the drawer. "Right. Yeah." His throat worked. "Just—"

The knock came—two sharp raps. Hazel didn't move. Ethan practically tripped rushing to the door, his erection tenting his pants. Dan stood in the doorway. He'd dressed deliberately: black Henley rolled at the sleeves, jeans that clung to his thighs—no belt. Hazel catalogued it with detached interest. Efficient. Practical. No wasted motion.

Ethan’s breath hitched. "Hey—come in—"

Dan stepped inside, eyes scanning the room—king bed with its stiff floral comforter, Ethan vibrating by the door, Hazel still scrolling on her phone like she was waiting for a delayed Uber. His mouth twitched. "Nice place." The door clicked shut behind him.

Hazel didn't look up. "There's lube in the drawer." Her thumb kept flicking across her screen. "Condoms too, apparently. Ethan stocked enough for a porn shoot."

Dan chuckled. He didn't move toward the bed. Just leaned against the armoire arms crossed, watching Ethan pant by the door like an overeager puppy. "You gonna stand there the whole time?" Dan asked him. "Or you planning to breathe at some point?"

Ethan then scurried to the ugly chair in the corner, gripping the armrests like it was a rollercoaster. His knees bounced. His pupils were blown wide, lips parted. Dan just kept watching Hazel, who still hadn't looked up from her phone.

Finally, she sighed and locked the screen. "Alright. Let's get this over with."

Dan was moving toward the bed, unhurried. Hazel tilted her head up to meet his gaze. Behind them, Ethan inhaled sharply.

She expected Dan to touch her immediately—kiss her, grab her tits—but he didn’t. Instead, he knelt between her spread legs, hands braced on either side of her hips, studying her face. Hazel willed her expression into careful indifference, but her pulse betrayed.

"I can hear you thinking," Dan murmured. His voice was low enough that Ethan wouldn’t catch it over the rustle of his own frantic breathing. "Still hate this?"

Hazel exhaled through her nose. "Yes."

Dan's thumb traced her inner thigh—slow, deliberate—just beneath the hem of her dress. Her gaze met his eyes. "Liar."

Ethan was already stroking himself through his jeans, oblivious to the words being exchanged. His breath came in shallow gasps, fingers fumbling with his zipper as he watched Dan kneel between Hazel's legs. The rhythmic sound of fabric against skin filled the room—pathetic, ****, unbearably loud. Hazel rolled her eyes.

Dan’s fingers hooked into the waistband of her cotton thong—plain, practical, bought specifically for this moment—and peeled it down with a single practiced motion. Hazel let him. She could’ve lifted her hips to help, could’ve shifted to make it easier, but she didn’t. Let him work for it. The elastic snapped against her thigh before he tossed it aside, forgotten. His hands returned immediately, palms skimming the sensitive skin of her inner thighs, in a way that made her muscles tense. Not recoiling—reacting. Fuck.

He didn’t rush. That was the worst part. Dan exhaled, slow and warm, against her before his tongue dragged a wet, deliberate stripe up her center. Hazel’s fingers twisted in the cheap hotel bedding, her body betraying her with a shudder she couldn’t suppress. Behind them, Ethan’s breath hitched—loud, obnoxious—followed by the unmistakable sound of his zipper yanking down.

Dan’s hands pressed her thighs wider. “Still hate this?” he murmured, lips brushing her clit on the last word. Hazel kicked his shoulder—not hard, just enough to make him smirk—but Ethan didn’t even register the movement. He was too busy palming himself through his briefs, eyes glazed, mouth slack. His hips jerked into his own touch, jeans pooled around his ankles.

Dan’s fingers circled her entrance—slow, teasing—before pushing in with deliberate ease. Hazel clenched her jaw, determined to keep her breath steady, but her hips rolled forward before she could stop them. Dan hummed against her, tongue flicking her clit in time with the curl of his fingers. Every stroke was methodical, relentless. She could already feel herself softening around him, slick and hot, the familiar ache building in her.

On the outside, she was marble: arms crossed, face tilted toward the ceiling with exaggerated boredom. She tapped her fingers against her bicep, as if counting the minutes until this inconvenience would be over. Ethan groaned behind them—his hand finally wrapped around his cock—but Hazel refused to glance his way.

Inside, fire. Dan’s tongue dragged slow circles around her clit while his fingers crooked just so, and Hazel’s vision blurred at the edges. Her thighs trembled—betrayal—and she bit her tongue hard enough to hurt. Don’t. Don’t. But Dan knew her body better than she did, exactly how to press the heel of his palm against her while his tongue flicked mercilessly. The orgasm ripped through her like a bullet. Her back arched involuntarily, her hands flying to Dan’s hair—not to push him away, to hold on—before she caught herself.

Ethan didn’t even register it. He was too busy fisting his cock, his breath stuttering as he watched Hazel’s face contort into what he thought was discomfort. "You okay?" he panted, hips jerking into his own grip. Hazel squeezed her eyes shut—not in pain, in furious pleasure—and Dan licked against her thigh. Seven years. Seven fucking years of Ethan dutifully going down on her for birthdays, anniversaries, that one disastrous Valentine’s Day where he’d whined about his jaw cramping after twenty minutes. Not once had he managed this—not the way Dan was doing it now, relentless and filthy, like he could taste her unraveling and wanted more.

Hazel nodded stiffly—answering Ethan’s question—and held her breath. If she opened her mouth, she’d scream. If she screamed, Ethan would hear it. If he heard it, he’d know. Dan’s fingers twisted inside her, curling just right, and her thighs shook. The orgasm ripped through her in waves, violent and silent, her nails digging into Dan’s scalp. He didn’t stop. Of course he didn’t stop. His tongue worked her through it, lapping up every shudder, every clench, until she had to bite her own wrist to keep from moaning Dan’s name.

Ethan groaned behind them—his hand a blur between his legs—and Hazel **** her eyes open. She watched him over Dan’s shoulder: flushed, trembling, his cock slick and red in his grip. His gaze was locked on Dan’s mouth between her thighs, mesmerized, his lips forming silent words—fuck, fuck, yes—as he jerked himself closer to the edge.

Hazel exhaled sharply—half disgust, half arousal—and kicked Dan’s shoulder again, harder this time.

Ethan was too far gone to notice the kick, or the way Hazel’s thighs trembled around Dan’s tongue. His hips stuttered, his breath coming in ragged, his cock pulsed in his own grip. Then—Ethan grunted and came all over himself, cum splattering across his stomach, his fingers, the ugly hotel chair beneath him. His mouth fell open, eyes rolling back before he slumped forward, panting. His cock twitched against his thigh, dripping onto the carpet.

Hazel watched him with detached amusement. Pathetic. Predictable. Exactly what she’d expected—Ethan barely lasted five minutes before blowing his load. Meanwhile, Dan had stopped.

She picked herself off the bed and approached Ethan, who was still slumped in the chair, breath ragged and skin flushed pink. His cum pooled in his lap, sticky and already cooling. Hazel leaned down, close enough to smell the sour tang of sweat and cheap whiskey on his skin. His eyes fluttered open—glassy, dazed—and she smiled.

"You done?" she asked, voice low. Ethan blinked, still riding the aftershocks of his orgasm. He nodded no, his mouth slack.

Hazel rolled her eyes and turned back to Dan—who had moved to sit on the bed. His chin glistened with her, lips parted slightly. The sight sent another pulse of heat through her.

Ethan’s voice cracked from the chair. “Five more minutes,” he pleaded, fingers twitching toward his softening cock. “Please—just—let me watch—” His words dissolved into a whimper. The desperation in his voice.

Hazel’s lip curled. “You already came,” she said flatly, glancing at the mess on his stomach. “Like a teenager with porn.”

Ethan swallowed hard, still breathing like he’d run a mile. His cock twitched pathetically against his thigh, half-hard again, **** for more. His voice cracked. “Please—just—watch—you fuck him—”

Hazel sighed—long-suffering, exaggerated—and leaned in to press a kiss to Ethan’s sticky lips. “I love you, Ethan,” she whispered, like it pained her. Then she straightened, rolling her eyes for Dan’s benefit, and let her dress drop to the floor.

Dan exhaled through his nose. Hazel was taller than any other woman he'd fucked—5'7", same height as him—and she knew it. She arched her back now, just slightly, enough to make her tits look even fuller in the cheap hotel lighting. Brown hair, hazel eyes, 34D tits—he knew because he'd bought her lingerie seven years ago, back when she'd bite her lip and blush at the sight of black lace. Now she stood there like it was nothing.

She reached into the drawer—slow, deliberate—and pulled out the condom Ethan had stocked. The wrapper tore between her teeth. Dan watched her, unmoving, as she rolled it onto him with no efficiency. Her nails scraped his shaft—accidentally—and he inhaled sharply. Hazel smirked. Then she climbed onto him, knees straddling his hips, settling into place like a mechanic installing a part.

Ethan whimpered. His cock twitched again, still wet from his own release. Hazel glanced back. She kept her eyes on Ethan.

Her expression was the same one she'd worn two Sundays ago—the ninth inning, Mariners down by three, Ethan refusing to change the channel even as she'd sighed and tapped her nails against her wineglass. That particular blend of exasperation and boredom, like she was waiting out a toddler's tantrum. Except now, instead of baseball, Ethan was watching Dan's hands grip her hips, his cock sliding into her with slow, deliberate ease. His mouth fell open. His fingers twitched against his thighs, **** to touch himself again.

Inside—fire. Dan's cock filled her exactly the way she remembered, thick enough to make her breath catch, relentless in a way Ethan never was. Hazel clenched her teeth against the moan threatening to spill out, her hips rolling forward instinctively, chasing the friction. Fuck. Fuck. Seven years hadn't dulled how perfect his cock was.

She moved deliberately—slow, steady, grinding down onto him with the same mechanical efficiency she used when Ethan was taking too long to finish. Her hands braced against Dan's shoulders, fingers digging into the worn fabric of his Henley as she rocked against him. No frantic bouncing, no **** gasps—just the measured, almost clinical rhythm of someone determined to endure rather than enjoy. Except Dan's fingers tightened on her hips, his thumbs pressing into the soft flesh above her hipbones, and she knew he could feel the way her pussy fluttered around him. Traitorously..

Ethan was already hard again, Hazel noted with detached amusement. His cock stood stiff against his stomach, flushed and leaking precum onto the drying streaks of. His breath coming in shallow pants as he watched her ride Dan. Pathetic. Predictable. She'd give Ethan five minutes—tops—before he'd be cumming again, whimpering her name like a prayer.

She adjusted her grip on Dan's shoulders, her thighs burning slightly from the deliberate, slow grind she'd been maintaining. Her nails scraped against his collarbone, and Dan inhaled sharply—his fingers tightening on her hips—before she felt it. The way his cock twitched inside her, impossibly deep, impossibly thick. Fuck. She'd forgotten. Seven years had dulled the memory of how long he was—how she'd needed both hands to stroke him, her mouth still able to lick at the flushed tip while her palms worked the shaft. Ethan was manageable, comfortable—she could lazily stroke him with one hand while scrolling on her phone. Dan was work.

And it was work she could pretend she hated.

Dan’s cock hit her cervix with every slow roll of her hips—deep, deliberate, the kind of penetration that would’ve made lesser women gasp. Hazel kept her expression bored, her lips slightly pursed like she was calculating grocery lists in her head, but inside, fire. The way her body clenched around him instinctively, greedy for more even as she maintained the illusion of indifference. She arched her back just enough to change the angle, letting him slide even deeper, and had to bite the inside of her cheek to keep from moaning.

Then—betrayal. A shudder tore through her without warning, her thighs clamping around Dan’s hips as an orgasm detonated in her. Hazel’s fingers scrabbled against his shoulders, her nails biting into fabric and skin alike, her breath escaping in a sharp, bitten-off gasp. The pleasure was violent, unexpected. Worse, Dan wasn’t even breathing hard beneath her, his expression infuriatingly calm as he watched her come apart on his cock. His fingers flexed once against her hips—acknowledgment, not celebration—and that smug, knowing look in his eyes made her want to throttle him.

Then Ethan’s weird grunt—the one he made when he was cumming—cut through the haze. Hazel’s head whipped toward him instinctively. Ethan’s entire body trembled like a plucked string.

Hazel let out a sharp quiet moan—Ethan was totally out of it now, completely oblivious to how her legs shook around Dan’s cock. Ethan's breathing rough, his dick twitching in his hand. His mouth hung open again, eyes rolling back before he collapsed forward from round two. Hazel watched him, numb. Hazel pushed herself off Dans cock and the bed, her own breathing uneven, skin hot, and stumbled over to Ethan. She leaned down. His eyes flickered open—hazy, unfocused, oblivious to her stumble—and she smirked. "You done?" she asked. Ethan blinked slowly. Nodded yes. Grinned like an idiot. Hazel rolled her eyes and turned back to Dan, who'd settled on the edge of the bed now. "Get out, Dan," she said, sharp and firm. No arguing.

Dan smirked, adjusting himself before standing. "Sure thing," he murmured, tossing the condom in the trash. He was dressing—grabbed his jeans from the floor and put them on, walking toward the door. Hazel didn't watch him go. Instead, she grabbed Ethan's chin, forcing his gaze up to hers. "You happy?" she asked. Ethan swallowed hard, still dazed, still grinning. "Yeah," he breathed. "Yeah, I—Are you?" Hazel exhaled through her nose. "No," she lied. Then she let go of his chin and turned away, grabbing her dress from the floor. "Clean yourself up."

Ethan scrambled for tissues, his hands shaking as he wiped himself down. Hazel tugged her dress back on—plain cotton thong long discarded—and smoothed her hair with deliberate indifference. Ethan opened his mouth—to apologize—but she cut him off. "Please," she said, voice low, serious. "Let's not do this again, Ethan."

She watched his face crumple—his fantasy fulfilled, his guilt immediate, eyes wet with remorse. "Yeah," he whispered. "Yeah, of course. Never again. I promise." His fingers twitched toward hers, **** for reassurance. Hazel let him take her hand—and fought the urge to smirk when he kissed her knuckles like Catholics do the Pope.

The shower ran. Hazel leaned against the bathroom doorframe, arms crossed, watching steam curl around Ethan’s hunched silhouette. He scrubbed himself—three passes with the loofah over his chest, his neck, his thighs—like he could erase the memory of Dan’s hands on her. Water sluiced when he bent forward, bracing against the tile. "Hazel?" His voice cracked. "You still love me, right?"

She didn’t hesitate. "Yes." Honest. Simple. She did love him—his dumb loyalty, the way he still brought her coffee in bed even when she snapped at him, the way he’d cried holding their cat after it died. Love wasn’t the problem.

The problem was Dan’s cock.

Three Days Later (Tuesday)

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)