Chapter 69
by
Mr Nice Guy
What's next?
Miracle Territory
Noon approached with surprising gentleness. Sunlight spilled across Roy's desk in clean, rectangular bands, illuminating dust motes that drifted lazily in the conditioned air. The office had settled into its midday rhythm, less frantic than the morning surge, not yet hollowed out by lunch. Familiar sounds provided a steady backdrop: keyboards clattering in uneven bursts, phones ringing with polite insistence, the distant churn of the copier down the hall.
Work, which had felt impossible to focus on when the day began, had become manageable again.
More than manageable.
Productive.
Three emails drafted and sent. A budget discrepancy resolved. Notes reorganized for the upcoming staff meetings. Each completed task had restored a small piece of internal order, like realigning bones after a fracture.
The real turning point, however, hadn't been the work. It had been the messages.
Roy reached for his phone again, not because it had buzzed, but because the memory of those words lingered like warmth beneath the skin. Michelle’s had come first.
MICHELLE: I miss you already and you literally just left like two hours ago
A second message, moments later.
MICHELLE: Your pillow still smells like you btw. I stole it. It's mine now. No takebacks.
And then:
MICHELLE: Also I may or may not be wearing your shirt and nothing else so you should probably hurry home before I get into trouble
A smile had broken across his face when he'd read that one, helpless and immediate. The image had formed without effort: Michelle curled on the couch, long legs tucked up in front of her, dark skin glowing against the pale fabric of his oversized shirt, hair in a loose ponytail. Calling in sick had been her decision, a chance to recover from the onslaught of toxicity heaped on her by her mother, a way to find healing in the nest of a home they shared together.

And he'd supported the decision. Primarily because he had been operating under the assumption that a few minutes after he left his apartment the wish would activate and she would forget that he ever existed. But now that he'd been given the gift of her love, the wish choosing to let them stay together, Roy couldn't help but feel excited that she was in his apartment waiting for him. Wearing his shirt.
Nineteen years old, and entirely unburdened by hesitation.
Energy radiated from her even in stillness. Michelle didn't ration affection. It poured out of her freely, generously, as though loving him were the most natural state in the world.
Elaine's messages had arrived next.
Less chaotic. More grounded.
ELAINE: Just finished first period. Thinking about you.
And then, a few minutes later:
ELAINE: Locker room's empty. Five minutes before the next class.
Another pause.
ELAINE: If you were here, I'd have you pressed up against the equipment cage. Maybe you can help me do inventory after work one of these days.
Heat had crept up Roy's neck at that one. Elaine never wasted words. Confidence infused everything she said, every thought delivered with the calm certainty of someone who understood herself completely. Fifty years old, and more self-possessed than anyone he'd ever known.
One more message had followed.
ELAINE: Have a great day, baby. Remember that you are loved.
No elaboration. None needed.
Support, desire, reassurance, all braided together in a way that made resistance impossible.
Tom's presence, despite the bully's best effort, had shrunk after that. Not vanished, but diminished. Reduced to something manageable.
Loved.
The word still felt foreign when applied to himself. All his life, Roy had assumed love would be something distant, conditional, fragile. Something glimpsed in others but never possessed. One woman loving him would have been enough to redefine his world. Two was beyond reason.
Two was miracle territory.
Awareness of the wish lingered beneath it all, of course. The mechanism behind it. The artificiality. None of this would exist without that impossible intervention. Michelle wouldn't be in his apartment, wearing his clothes. Elaine wouldn't be stealing moments between classes to imagine him against cold metal cages. Without magic, none of them would have chosen him.
Acceptance of what he had been given had come slowly, reluctantly. Roy thought of himself as a moral man, a man who did right by others. But the wish didn't care about his morals. And so resistance had proven futile. No matter what he did, reality would simply be rewritten, moving forward, straight through any moral boundaries he had held up.
Fighting it had accomplished nothing. He was thrown from situation to situation, relationship to relationship, no agency, no consent. Yes, the sex was amazing. Yes, the attention was intoxicating. But having his entire life dictated by a throw-away comment made in a bar after a few drinks was not his picture of paradise. There was nothing, it seemed, that he could do to take control of his life.
Celebrating parts of it, however... now that was a choice. That was something he could do. Something he could choose to do.
Love, even artificial love, still felt like love. Still warmed the same hollow places. Still mattered.
A spreadsheet filled the monitor, numbers aligned in obedient rows. Fingers moved across the keyboard automatically, muscle memory carrying him forward while his mind wandered elsewhere.
Agency.
The thought surfaced again, unwelcome but persistent.
Charlotte.
Tabitha.
Elaine.
Claire.
Michelle.
Agnes.
Zara.
Each name carried weight. Each name represented a life bent around him without consent. Women who had awakened into realities where Roy had been present, where he shouldn't be. Not just present. Central. Theirs. Choice had been taken away from them.
Agnes, especially, lingered in his mind like a bitter aftertaste.
Since he first saw her, months earlier, he'd thought she was beautiful. But admiration from afar had been easy. Distance had allowed imagination to fill in the blanks. Beauty had done the rest.
Reality had been different.
Cruelty, casual and unapologetic, had spilled out of her almost immediately. Bigotry worn like a badge. Contempt for anyone who didn't fit neatly into her narrow understanding of the world.
Disgust had replaced attraction within minutes. Under normal circumstances, Roy would have walked away and never looked back. Instead, the wish had **** intimacy. **** relationship. **** connection. Escape had required action he hadn't wanted to take, but had taken anyway, because the alternative, staying with her, integrating her poison into his life, had been worse.
Choice had been removed from him, too.
Not entirely. Not in the same way. Roy's awareness that he had significantly more control than the women remained intact. He, at least, knew what was happening. His mind wasn't being rewritten. No magical **** compelled his emotional devotion. No rewritten memories convinced him he'd always loved them.
And he, at least, had a viable exit to every relationship he didn't want.
The women had no such agency.
A vibration against the desk pulled him back.
Zara.
ZARA: So? Dinner tonight? We on?
Memory surfaced immediately: her voice filling the car that morning, words tumbling over each other in unstoppable waves. Groceries, recipes, ideas, possibilities. Energy without brakes. Enthusiasm without restraint.
Charming, in its way. Overwhelming, too.
The wish moved quickly, always pushing toward escalation. Toward intimacy. Toward entanglement.
Another memory surfaced. A gas station restroom. Tabitha on her knees, pulling open his pants and freeing his erection, eager to pleasure him despite everything she'd once believed about herself.
And another. Claire's startled laugh as he'd carried her across his apartment threshold like a new bride, despite her lying to her soon-to-be husband about where she was that night.
Were women in normal relationships always this eager, always this willing, or was the wish increasing the intensity of their encounters? Roy, having no romantic experience prior to the wish, could only guess. But his guess was that it was abnormal. That the magic was creating something for him that was beyond what a normal relationship would provide. It was taking what might occur naturally and making it hotter, more intense.
A glance toward the office door, still closed, still offering privacy. Tom wanted to take control of his job, forcing him to quit, forcing him to move on. The wish wanted to take control of his love life, placing new women in front of him, teasing him, enticing him. He could feel the forces, pushing him in one direction or another. Telling him that he had to comply, that he had to live the life that they were telling him.
But Roy had something that the women in his life didn't have: a choice.
A small one, perhaps. But his and his alone.
ROY: Not tonight - already have plans. Sorry. Tomorrow?
The message sent with a quiet whoosh.
Control, reclaimed in increments.
Just that morning he'd discovered that Michelle, the beautiful Michelle, would be staying with him. Not only a girlfriend, but a girlfriend who lived with him. It was exciting. She was exciting. And while, to Michelle, nothing had changed since the day before, Roy knew differently. He knew that the world had been rewritten to encompass them as a couple, to give space for their relationship to grow.
And that, it seemed to him, was something to celebrate.
So Michelle would have tonight.
Zara could wait.
Another vibration, almost immediate.
ZARA: Tomorrow night it is! Friday date night with my man! Love you XOXOXO
Before he could control it, he smiled. Zara was a stranger, but she was infectious. Even in her texts he could feel her enthusiasm leaking through.
Phone returned to the desk, he refocused. Even a man as loved as him still had to get his work done.
But now, as he clicked through spreadsheets, Roy felt the buzz of anticipation. Waiting for him at home was a woman who was his, and he hers. For the first time in his life, he would walk into his home and someone who loved him would be there to welcome him home.
And he couldn't wait to see her. That was his choice. And it had to mean something.
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Everyone's Boyfriend
Becoming the kind of guy that women want...
Roy Robinson's life isn't going great. A soft middle, a work rival out to get him, and no love life to speak of. Suddenly, thanks to an errant wish, his life takes a dramatic turn for the better.
Updated on Jun 10, 2026
by Mr Nice Guy
Created on Dec 26, 2025
by Mr Nice Guy
- 7,623 Likes
- 449,185 Views
- 1,089 Favorites
- 698 Bookmarks
- 108 Chapters
- 105 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments
