She sucks the filling off your fingers

Ashley giggles through her tears and wraps her lips around your two fingers. She sucks the pie off. She's sloppy about it, definitely not trying to be seductive, but still seeing and feeling your daughter wrap her lips around your fingers makes your cock grow. You’re sure she can feel it pushing against her naked ass.

She licks her lips. “Not quite as good as Mom makes, but still my favorite.” She throws her arms around your neck and hugs you tight. “Thank you for standing by me. You’re the only one who isn’t treating me like I’m crazy.” She kisses you on the cheek next to your ear. Her small naked breasts press against your chest. You take in a deep breath feeling the urge to turn your face and kiss her building up inside you. She laughs and whispers in your ear, “You’re such a cool Dad that you aren’t going crazy about me sitting naked on your lap. Mom would freak if she walked in right now. I’m going to go take some alone time in my room. It’s been a rough day.”

She wipes her eyes on your shirt before standing up. Her shaved pussy is only inches in front of your face. She must notice your gaze as she puts a hand over it. “I’m so embarrassed. Sorry, Daddy...I mean...Sir.”

She scurries away and you watch her tight teen ass streaked with pie filling retreat up the stairs. When she’s out of view you rub your bulge. Using the two fingers she sucked the filling off of you scoop up some more that was under her. You lick them clean with your eyes closed imagining the crease between your fingers is her slit.

This is ****. And wrong. Yet, she hasn't fled and while she's shed many tears she continues to be obedient.

Just as you start to unzip your pants to rub one out in the kitchen your phone vibrates with a message alert. Sighing you stand up and read the new message from your blackmailer.

"That went better than planned. I wasn't sure if forcing her to be naked all the time while in the house would be pushing her too far, but she's turned out to be so very willing. Cindy's response was a bit concerning, but I'm not sure we need to worry about her. The more we isolate Ashley from other people the easier it'll be to get to my final goal. Now, I think your little girl's performance tonight is deserving of having two pieces of evidence destroyed, so I've gotten rid of a document and a photo. You're now down to nine. Here's your next task:"

Evidence Remaining

5 Documents
4 Photos