Ponder your options.

In a split second I weighed out the pros and cons of both girls. On a purely physical level, because they both had great personalities.
They were both virgins, I knew that. Not because they couldn't get any, but they were waiting for the right guy. Having had a lot of experience kissing guys though, Holly definitely had the advantage there. Holly was incredibly pretty. She usually wore tight tops and her tits were small. I would have loved to get those in my hands. Sophia's boobs were also pretty nice and were cute and firm.
Me myself though, am an ass man, and that was a deciding factor for me. Sophia did squats to improve her ass shape and I knew it was Big and round.

Not to rule out Holly's ass- it was firm and smooth and a definite catch since she always wore leggings.

Sophia liked to wear skirts, which I found irresistible.... this would be tough.