Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by TheBoojum

Does she agree or propose an alternative?

Patsy brings her A game

"Oh hell!" Patsy declares. "I'm not going to let you just have this,Peggy! You've always taken the things I wanted and I'm not going to let you have this!"

"It doesn't matter WHAT you want, Patsy-Pie!" Peggy retaliates, thrusting her naked chest forward defiantly. "I've got this all sewn up! You're still so old, you don't remember how scrappy I was when we were young the first time!"

"Oh, I remember!" Patsy snarls. "I remember you were a dirty, cheating little witch! And it's about time I taught you a lesson!"

"Now girls!" you exclaim, stepping between them and pushing them back from each other, taking the opportunity to feel them up. "Let's do this the right way: in a tub full of jello! I'm the referee. You go to your corners. When I ring this bell, you come in and wrestle. When I ring it again, you go back to your corners and I'll declared who scored and who takes a shot. Oh, and one more thing. If you fall out of the tub, you have 5 seconds to get back in or it's a two-shot penalty. Any questions?"

The sisters shake their heads, glaring daggers at each other.

"All right, then, get to your corners!"

You ring the bell and the naked sisters advance, shivering briefly as the cold jello oozes between their toes and up their legs to just above Patsy's knees and a third the way up Peggy's thighs. But the reaction to the cold is short lived, other than the protrusion of their nipples, as Peggy screams out in rage and advances on her older sister with her clawed hands above her head. She obviously has no idea what she's doing, but her determination is fun to watch.

"All righty, Peggy-poopsie!" the redhead says defiantly, squatting and spreading her arms wide. "I'm taking you down to spanking town!"

The sisters collide. Despite Patsy's better stance, Peggy's momentum and the slipperiness of the jello causes the redhead to loose her footing and land with a jello-spattered squelch on her well-rounded ass. She recovers quickly, though, and grabs the side of Peggy's face and tries to push her over sideways. Down goes the younger sister and she comes up gasping, much more of a strawberry blonde now, with red jello dripping from her locks. You ring your referee's bell and announce: "Point for Patsy, Peggy takes a shot!"

Peggy sputters out jello, then obediently goes to her corner and downs a shot. Then you ring the bell and Peggy advances again with twice as much determination as before. Unfortunately, determination seems to be all the blonde has going for her and once Patsy realizes the jello is preventing any serious injury when her sister falls, she lets loose with her clearly superior skills. Within 3 minutes, Peggy has taken her fourth shot.

"I'm jus' gettin' warmed up!" Peggy declares, wiping a gob of jello from between her perky tits. "This time I'ma gonna show you!"

"Peggy, yer drunk, you tramp!" Patsy declares.

"Yer damn right I'm drunk, Patsy-poo! Drunk enough to kick yer ass!"

"That makes no sense, stupid!"

"ARgh!" says Peggy and charges.

The jello-spattered blonde misses her sister entirely and lands on her hands and knees. It becomes apparent to you that this will be a short competition...unless, of course, Peggy gets a little help from a time master.

You slow time to a crawl as Patsy advances on her sister. You push the busty red-head hard from behind and are out of the tub with your shoes back on and in front of her before she even begins to trip over the sprawling Peggy. You let time come back to speed and Pasty face plants into the jello, her head becoming completely immersed. She comes up gasping and sputtering and you ring the bell and announce: "Point for Peggy, Patsy takes a shot!"

"Somebody pushed me!" Patsy protests, looking around in bewilderment.

"That's absurd, Patsy," you tell her. "There's no one here but us three."

"But...but...Somebody pushed me, darn it! I know somebody pushed me!"

You ring the bell again.

"Arguing with the reg! Take two shots!"

"Ha-ha!" Peggy laughs from where she sprawls.

"Unsportsmanlike taunting," you rule, ringing again. "Peggy takes a shot!"

Patsy sniggered quietly.

"That's not fair!" the strawberry blonde protests.

"Is that an argument?" you ask.

Peggy pouts and says no, retreating to her corner. Patsy looks awfully smug. You decide to increase her handicap, freezing time and making the older sister's shots doubles by adding extra jello shots from the fridge to her cups. She doesn't notice and downs her two shots, which are essentially 4, as her sister takes her single penalty. Patsy blinks, stares at her empty cups, then shakes her head and glares at her sister.

"Let's finish this!" she exclaims.

Even with you tipping the scales, Patsy just might win this.

Do you let Patsy win?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)