More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 44 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

One Condition

Peg pulls her dick from your mouth to allow you and your sister to give yourselves to each other during this incredible moment.

The feeling of Elsie's massive cock throbbing inside of you as she dumped her load deep inside your ass is the stuff of the hottest wet dreams. Your anal orgasm seems to contract in perfect time with hers and the pair of you ride out your shared release moaning in a pitch perfect erotic duet. Your rhythmically gripping tunnel milks Elsie right to the last blessed drop.

And when it is all over...you look at each other...smile...and burst out into the biggest round of giggles you'd shared in probably ten years. "HA HA HA HA HA HA!"

"Oh my GOD!" Elsie says with glee. "We did it! We actually did it."

"You were soooo good Elsie!"

"YOU were so good Jesse!"

"I loved how you feel inside of me!"

"I love how you feel!"

"You can fuck me anytime you want!"

"You can fuck ME any time YOU want!"

"You're the best!"

"No, you're the best!"

"I love you Sister!"

"I love you Brother!"

"HA HA HA HA HA!" The pair of you laugh as one.

Even Peg can't help but chuckle along with your infectious giggles. "Would you two stop! You are way too cute." Your aunt is absolutely beaming looking at the pair of you laugh and joke around. "You two just...make me happy."

"He he he he!" In one adorable voice the pair of you say. "We love you Auntie Peg!"

Peg wipes a tear of joy from her eye. "Auntie loves you too."

El was still nice and snugly inside of you and you could feel her slowly begin to soften inside your slick and creamy hole. Ohhhhh what bliss. The pair of you just sit like this for bit. Chatting and giggling and letting your warm wonderful afterglow spread through your bodies. Your laughter causes your backdoor to tighten and that feels great too. Everything just feels great. Your soulmate and the love of your life had been right under your nose all this time, now that you knew you wouldn't waste another moment. You would treasure this girl with all of your heart for the rest of your days.

You look over at your aunt, your eyes scanning up from her rock hard cock up her toned body to her beautiful face. She looked so happy for the pair of you. "Madam?"

"Yes my boy."

You smile wider and bat your big brown eyes. "You can fuck me now...if you want to."

"OOOO! Yes!" Elsie chirps. "You have to feel him Peg. He's...he's...ohhh wow, you'll see."

"Please fuck me." You mewl.

"You're still up for it?" Peg asks. The way she was slowly stroking herself only made you want her more.

You nod. "Mmm hmm."

"Hard or gentle?"

"Hard please." You shudder as a delightful aftershock rolls through you.

"I'm pretty strong."

"I can take it! Use me Madam, I swear I can take it. Hard as you want." You say with naive bravery. You had no idea if you could take it but you were certainly willing to try! "It's okay if you hurt me."

"No one's going to hurt you baby." She says.

"But it's okay if you do." You grin. "I won't complain. I'm a good boy."

"It's okay? Sweet child..." Peg's storm cloud grey eyes stare into yours. "Hmmmm."

"Go ahead Peg." Elsie urges. "Make love to him."

"Please. Please Auntie Peg." You beg.

"Shhh." She places a finger over your lips. She looks back and forth between you and El. "My god, you two are so precious. You make my heart...feel so good." You and your sister are glowing with good feelings at that. You could see Peg is struggling with something though, she looks from you to Elsie and back again hesitant to say what is on her mind. Eventually she does. "I'll fuck you Jesse, on one condition."

"Anything! ANYTHING!"

She then shakes her head. "No, keep it fun. Right? I shouldn't have said that. Okay sweetie, I'll fuck you."

"Wait!" You say. "I want to hear. I want to hear the condition. I'll do anything."

Elsie settles down in a comfortable position, her shrinking dick still inside of you as her soft hands lightly rubs your tummy and legs adoringly. "Tell us Peg, what is it?"

"I love you two so very much." She says more to herself than to you.

"Tell me, please." You beg. "I'm your boy. I'm your Cutie Pie. You can tell me."

She chuckles but with a touch of melancholy. "You are right, if I can't talk to my boy who can I talk to? Hmm?"

You nod.

She glides up next to Elsie and kisses her left cheek as her fingers gently strokes down the other. Her arm wraps around your sister's shoulder. "Jesse, you are our boy and we love you very much." Your heart swells. "But I want my boy...to be a man. I need you to be man Jesse. I can't just let you live in a fantasy." Your glowing heart drops and you give her a hurt look. El too looks at Peg with annoyance for spoiling the mood. Your aunt ignores your glares and continues to stroke and pet your little sister. She kisses El again and says. "And I need my girl to be a strong woman."

"Peggy?" Elsie whispers.

Peg smiles and hugs her tight then looks down at you with nothing but love in her eyes. "My boy, it's not okay to hurt you. It is never okay to hurt you baby. A little pain between lovers can be fun, but not hurt. Never hurt."

"Peg?" You say.

She then hits you with both barrels. "Your big sister is abusive and manipulative and mean. She is a bully and worse. Much worse." Her arm around El tightens the hug. "And I am sick of watching her tear you two down."

This out of the blue statement leaves both you and El confused.

"She makes you two feel small, alone, divided. Especially you Jesse." Peg continues. "She plays on your budding masculinity. She plays on your beautiful sexuality. She makes you feel bad for her own insecurities. She keeps you small so she can be big."

You lie there stunned. "What?"

Peg's shoulder's slump. "Helen failed you two...and so did I. For that I am sorry."

"You didn't fail us." Elsie says as she turns her body to embrace her aunt. She lays her head on Peg's shoulder as her aunt holds her close.

"Yes, I did. Always busy. Always too busy. Always another project, always another deadline. The time just got away from me and now look at you two. All grown up already. I barely had enough time for Chloe. I'm so sorry." Peg sighs. "Too late I talked to Fiona, and oh how we talked, but it was far too late. And Helen..." Peg shakes her head sadly, clearly deeply disappointed in her younger sister. "...I thought your mother would...well...she doesn't help the situation."

You couldn't help feeling a bit defensive, even though every word she is saying is true. "Fiona loves me." You say.

"Yes she does baby. She loves you both. With all of her heart. But she also hurts you. She hurts you because she hurts. That's not a healthy love my boy." She implores you. "What you two don't realize is that she only has power because YOU give it to her." She takes in a breath. "My condition is this. The next time she says something that makes you feel small or weak or less than her...just imagine she said it about Elsie." She turns to look at your sister. "And Elsie, same to you. The next time Fiona is negging you I want to you imagine she is saying it to Jesse instead of you."

"I don't want Fiona to hurt Jesse." Elsie says sadly.

"I don't like her talking bad about El." You say.

"Exactly." She turns El's head up to look her in the eyes. "I want you to treat yourself with as much care and respect as you do him." She looks to you and smiles warmly. "And you, I want you to love yourself as you do her." She leans her head on Elsie's. "I promise you I will have your backs no matter what happens. With Fiona or even...with your mother. No matter what Aunt Peg is here for you now. I will always make time for you." She smooches Elsie's head and pats your bare hip. "So, do you accept my condition?" She then lowers her head with a guilty look. "Or did I just completely ruin the night?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)