Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 7
by
cphi
Was Matt fooled?
Nope.
"Nice try, girls." Matt smiles, rubbing the tent in his pants openly. "Did you work that little act out between you?"
Miranda's smile goes crooked. "What are you talking about?"
"It was a nice try, like I said, but the first girl... tried a little too hard. That was definitely Nicole." Matt gives her an apologetic look. "You definitely tried to make me think you were Sarah. Sloppy and slutty."
"Hey!" Sarah is trying to sound indignant, but Matt just shakes a finger at her.
"Don't deny it! It's not an insult, it's a compliment and you know it's true. You love it. Anyway, second girl did the same thing, but she was better at it, so that was Miranda, and then obviously the third was Sarah, trying to act all lovey dovey and inexperienced. Probably trying to make me think you were Nicole."
"Hey!" Nicole definitely sounds indignant.
"No offense, Nicole. Just what I've heard..."
"From whom?!" she turns to stare at you, and you put up your hands.
"Don't look at me! I never told him anything about you." That is not strictly true: you've definitely told Matt that Nicole isn't the most experienced girl. But never any specifics!
"Well, John? How did I do?"
"100% correct!" you answer.
"Great." Tom breaks in. "Now can he pick his partner for seven minutes in hell or whatever so we can keep going? I'm getting old over here." Nobody pays him any mind, but Sarah does step in front of Matt, seemingly fully confident in his selection.
"Well.... shall we then?"
Does Matt choose Sarah, or does he subvert her expectations?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Afterparty
Six friends continue the party with a naughty game.
A group of friends gets closer than ever.
Updated on Jan 16, 2026
by Cheesers123
Created on Aug 28, 2014
by Cloontang1
You can customize this story. Simply enter the following details about the main characters.
- 51,522 Likes
- 19,237,018 Views
- 4,165 Favorites
- 9,754 Bookmarks
- 3,243 Chapters
- 106 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Comments