Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 18 by BartyTrinky
Do you care?
No
“Just fuck me, Kelly!” you beg as you feel the tip of her cock enter your virgin asshole.
“Oh, fuck you’re so tight Matt!” Kelly screams as she slowly works herself all the way in. She grabs the sides of your ass as she slowly moves in and out, and you can hear her moaning loudly with each thrust.
As she hits your prostate, you feel your massive hard cock drop precum underneath you as you get fucked for the first time.
Do you stop?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Truth or Dare with the Guys
How much can the twinks make their straight friend do?
While celebrating with your friends, you play games that make you question how straight you are.
Public, Femboy, slut, twink, humiliation, alleyway, gayslut, spitroasted, Cumshot, facial, tag team, MTM, Cumslut, whore, cockslut, precum, drop, straight, turning, Assplay, ass fingering, Video, camera, dirty talk, public blowjob, shemale, alley, swallow, Gay sex, Anal, Bicurious, Tranny, dickgirl, Bisexual, party, Cum on face, cum on her face, shemale on male, Gay slut, under the table, gangbang, Creampie, On your body
Updated on Mar 1, 2026
by BartyTrinky
Created on Sep 28, 2016
by BartyTrinky
- 10,029 Likes
- 5,946,958 Views
- 1,034 Favorites
- 590 Bookmarks
- 369 Chapters
- 40 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Jump to comments
Comments