Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by The Smutsketeer The Smutsketeer

What's next?

Moving out

It was another four months until the two of you had finished all the paperwork and you could move into your apartment. You'd already brought over your own essentials and were now helping Willow pack up her own things. When she was out of the room Holly came up to you.

"Hi" you told her.

"Hey John" she replied softly. "I wanted to talk to you."

"About what?" you asked.

"About that one night you and Will made me...you know..." she said, her pale cheeks turning a firey red.

"The time we caught you spying again and we taught you a lesson?" you finished the sentence for her.

"Yes...I've ...I can't stop thinking about it" Holly told you.

"About what, Holly?" you repeated yourself.

"About Willow bouncing on your...on your..." she said, trailing off.

"On my cock?" you offered. "Do you want to see it again?"

No" Holly said, too fast to mean it.

"I'm sure Willow won't mind" you said, making sure the door was closed before taking your dick out. "Look, but not touch and all that stuff."

"Oh my God" Holly said, staring at your member. "It's so fucking big."

"Yeah, it is. And it's not even hard yet. Although.." you said, smirking as your cock twitched. In full view of an attractive young woman it wasn't long in starting to harden.

"Oh my God.." the 18-year old repeated. She blushed and stared as you grew to full strength. "It's so big...and thick..and looks so..."

"Hey, John? Do you have my phone?" Willow asked as she walked into her room. She saw you and her sister and laughed. "Sorry, am I interrupting something?" She knew that you were utterly loyal to her and wouldn't dare touch her sister unless you got her permission.

"Holly was just curious" you said. Holly looked like she was ready to run, but Willow stopped her.

"Is that so, sweetie? Then why don't you touch it?" Willow asked.

"Are you..But he's your boyfriend" Holly whispered.

"That's okay. You've already seen us fuck multiple times. What's a little touching copared to that?" Willow said. Then she looked at you. "Right baby?"

"You got it" you said, taking Holly's hand and putting it on your erection. The teen gasped and blushed an even deeper red before curling her long, slender fingers around your cock.

"There you go" Willow said with a smile. "Now squeeze a little and begin moving your hand back and forth" she instructed her sister. Holly started to do this and immediately you started feeling good. Her hands were silky smooth and soft, maybe even softer than Willow's, but unlike her big sister, Holly probably had no experience. You let out a soft moan and smiled at the teen.

"You're not doing too badly" you said. "Are you sure this is your first time touching a cock?"

"It is" Holly said. She continued exploring you until she suddenly let go and ran out of her sister's room.

"Aw, I was just having fun" you told Willow. "Do you mind?" you asked.

"Not in the least" Willow said, going to her knees in front of you and treated you to you oral until you climaxed in her mouth.

"So, have you got everything? Hamish asked.

"Yeah, I think so" Willow told her dad. Looking at her you couldn't tell she'd just swallowed her lover's cum, but that might have been because she'd just brushed her teeth and washed her face.

"If she doesn't, it's not like we live that far away" you told Hamish.

"That's true" Lori said, watching you put the last of Willow's stuff in your car.

"Don't worry mom, we'll be on the phone every day" Willow said before hugging her mom then her dad.

"Take care of yourself, okay honey?" Hamish said.

"I will" Willow said. "Plus John is here to pick up any slack."

"Don't worry, I'll look after your daughter" you said, coming to stand behind her and closing your arms around her. She looked up at you and smiled.

"You better" she said.

"You better" Hamish echoed. You couldn't help but laugh.

"Hey, it's in my best interest to do so anyway, so of course I will" you said.

"So where's Holly?" Willow asked.

"She's gone to see Rachel" Lori said.

"I would have liked to say bye to her too. Oh well" your girlfriend said with a shrug.

"We can always invite her another time" you suggested.

"Great idea, John" Lori said. "I'll let her know when she gets back."

"Thanks mom" Willow said. "You ready to go?"

"Yeah, let's" you said, smiling, kissing the top of her head.

"So here we are" you said, smiling. "Our own place."

"I love it" Willow said, "and I love you. Even if you flashed your dick to my baby sister."

You smirked. "I seem to recall you were the one telling her how to do jerk a cock."

"Only after you flashed her your pussyslayer" she said. "Now how about you come here and celebrate getting our own place, huh?"

"What did you have in mind?" you asked.

"Give me five minutes" Willow said, walking off. "Come in in five minutes."

So you waited patiently, checking your phone, trying not to get distracted by your curiosity. Before long, though, Willow called: "come on in" You put your phone away and went into the living room where your girlfriend was waiting for you and you were faced with a most welcome sight.

Please log in to view the image

"Welcome home, baby" she said, smiling broadly. "Come and say hello to your girl." You responded to her smile with one of your own and took your shirt off.

"Hello, my girl" you said as you kissed her tenderly. As you made out, the beautiful blonde unbuckled your belt and pulled it clear of your jeans. She then yanked them down and began fondling your groin.

"I want you so bad, baby" Willow said. "Fuck me hard. I'm going to be thinking about how Holly touched your cock before, so it's like she'll be fingering me."

"Oh...Willow, that's so perverse" you said with a look at her. Her eyes met yours and she grinned.

"That's who I am. A little pervert" WIllow told you. "A pervert with a hunky boyfriend with a freakishly large dick who's going to fuck me crazy. He's going to shoot his thick, fat load inside of my pussy and make me a mommy."

"Are you serious?" you asked, wondering if this was sexytime talk, or if she was being for real.

"I am" Willow said, "we've got a place of our own and I'm done with my study. You've got a job. Besides, don't you want to start our own little family?"

"I think I do" you told her, kissing her gently. "But are you sure?"

"Yes, John" your lover replied. "I am sure. I love you and I want to have a baby with you."

"Don't you think we should get engaged first?" you asked even as Willow pulled your pants off.

"Why would we? We can always get engaged, sure, but you're a little old fashioned" she said while starting to kiss your groin. "We don't need to be married, baby. Not yet, at least." Before long she peeled off your shorts and finally got you naked. "All marrying's going to do is give me your last name and our baby will have it anyway. Assuming you acknowledge it, anyway."

"Of course I will" you told her, smiling down at her. You began to stroke her hair as your girlfriend returned the favour by stroking your cock. "You didn't honestly think I'd leave you and our baby, did you?"

"Never did" Willow said, placing tender kisses on your cockhead. "I think you're going to continue to be a wonderful boyfriend like you've already been and be a wonderful dad."

"Thank you, Willow. You are amazing yourself and I think you're going to be a great mom" you replied. "So is tonight the night we're going to make our baby?"

"We're going to try" Willow said before putting her lips on your cockhead and tenderly suckling on it, her eyes on yours the entire time.

"That's not your pussy" you told her, grinning.

"Just because I want a baby doesn't mean I don't want to suck some cock" Willow replied, smiling broadly as she jerked you off.

"Well, dig in then" you said, answering her smile. "Suck all you want."

What's next?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)