Making a decision

"You're not making it easy on me" you told them.

"Well, as long as you don't have an answer I'm going to keep on sucking" Tamsin said, putting her money where her mouth was. Or her mouth where her mouth was? You moaned softly as the plump lips wrapped around your cock again with renewed vigour. Likewise, Willow came back in to play with your nuts, dragging a velvety-soft tongue across the soft skin of your scrotum.

"Well, who's it going to be?" Esther pressed.

"I don't know" you said honestly. "You're all so fucking gorgeous."

"Aw, thanks" Isobel said. "But come on, you have to decide. One of us needs that dick."

"We all do" Willow said.

"I know I do" Esther said, smiling at you. She took another hit from a new joint and kissed you, exhaling into your mouth. The buzz was starting to get to you, making you even hornier. Your eyes met Noelle's and on a whim you pulled her closer.

"I think I want you first" you whispered in her ear. The blonde's cheeks grew red and you smirked. "I'm sure."

"Please don't tell me you choose her to go first" Willow said, looking surprised. "She's the one who's shown the least interest in you."

"Maybe that's why" you told her, smirking. "Unless you want me to fuck you first."

"Yes!" Willow exclaimed, making the others laugh.

"Fine. Get yourself a condom and we'll play" you told her.

"I've got you covered" Tamsin said, grabbing a condom from her pocket. She tore open the packet before using her hands then her mouth to put the condom on your length. At the same time Willow had gotten up and started getting rid of her remaining clothes.

"Oh, he likes the view" Isobel said, watching your cock throb and twitch as the blonde exposed herself.

"I don't blame him" Noelle said. "She is very, very hot."

"What about the man in the room?" Esther asked, obviously hoping to get Noelle interested in you.

"Look, he's hot, okay? He's got a nice big dick and he looks like he knows how to use it. It's just that...I've never been with a guy before" the short-haired blonde said. Esther gasped and Willow grinned. Tamsin smirked at you.

"Looks like she doesn't want a freakishly huge cock to be her first, John" she said. "Maybe you should start with someone willing, instead."

"Didn't we agree that it was going to be me?" Willow said. "I mean, he's got his raincoat on and I'm wet as fuck. That cock's going to slip right inside of me."

"Stop talking and do it" Tamsin told her friend. Willow looked at you then sat in your lap, her legs on either side of you, then smiled.

"You ready?" she asked.

"Are you?" you replied. "Go on, sit down." Ever helpful, Esther reached out to hold your cock in place so that Willow could lower herself onto it. The small blonde moaned as she took your inside of her, taking it slow. She went back up again a few times, getting you deeper inside of her every time she tried again. With all the other young women looking on with eyes wide, you were extremely horny. It was all you could do not to cum yet. Lucky for you, as soon as Willow had taken you all the way inside of her tight little pussy she needed a breather, giving you time to come down from your near orgasm.

"Oh my God" Tamsin said, staring.

"I know" Isobel agreed. She stared at Willow then told her friend to point at where your cock was. When she felt her stomach and ended up where your cockhead was, the girls gasped.

"And that's why I didn't want you to be my first" Noelle said, though there was something in her eyes that told you she wasn't being entirely truthful.

"Oh, please" Esther said. "It just looks even bigger than it actually is, which is plenty big mind you, because you're so tiny."

"I want to see how he fits inside of me" Tamsin said, by far the most slightly build, even if she was taller than Willow. "I bet you can see his dick making my stomach bulge."

"I want to try" you said. At this Esther laughed.

"I bet you do, you horny fucker" she said, leaning in to kiss you. "But Willow's gone first. So you better give it to her."

"Yes ma'am" you said, standing up, carrying Willow and putting her down on her back on the couch, right between Noelle and Esther.

"See, this is more my speed" the former said. "That sexy little blonde is so fucking cute. I can't stop touching her." She reached out and gripped one of Willow's modest breasts, squeezing it. While Noelle toyed with Willow, Tamsin had gotten in Esther's lap, making out with her. You were so entranced by the sight of these two gorgeous women that you almost forget to start thrusting into Willow. Lucky for her, and you, Isobel was on hand to assist. She pushed into you from behind, her heavy, warm breasts resting against your back.

"Go on, fuck her" she whispered. "Fuck my sexy little friend."

"Ah...fuck" you said, shivers running down your spine as you got a great ASMR treatment from a sexy latina.

"Yeah, you like that, don't you?" she asked in a soft voice. "A husky voice with big tits pushing into you while you're inside of a tight little pussy." With a soft laugh she licked at your earlobe, making you shiver again. Encouraged by Isobel, you began to thrust into Willow, who moaned loudly.

"Oh, Jesus" Noelle breathed. "I can see her stomach bulge!" Sure enough, when you looked down, your cock was making Willow's flat stomach distend with every thrust, even if it was only a little.

"Wow" Tamsin said with a grin as she kneaded Esther's breasts. "I can't wait to see what it'll do to me."

"Probably even more" Esther said, kissing her friend on the lips.

"I want to see John fuck Willow some more, first" Isobel said. She licked your earlobe again and exhaled into your ear. "Go on, do it" she whispered, giving you all the tingles. "Shove that fat dick inside of my tiny friend. Show her who's boss." She remained quiet for a while, letting you build up your pace. "And show Noelle what she's missing" she added after a while. "That's what you want, isn't it? You want to fuck the hot lesbian, see if you can turn her bi?"

"I know I can" you told her. "I can turn her bi yet." Your eyes met Noelle's, who was biting her lip. She was obviously considering it, judging by her stiff nipples and her expression.

"Come on, No" Esther said. "You'll love it, I swear. John is hung like a horse, sure, but he can also be so very gentle."

"I thought you were fuckbuddies, not lovebuddies" Tamsin teased.

"Shut up" Esther replied, laughing, She tweaked one of the skinny brunette's nipples, who moaned in response. "Yeah, he's my fuckbuddy. Any one of you can become his girlfriend."

"Even Noelle?" Isobel asked, kissing your neck.

"Yeah" you said. The blonde turned away, her cheeks a scarlet red. God, at the very least you wanted to fuck her. But someone as gorgeous as Noelle, you wouldn't say no to. Then again, you could see yourself with any of these women, at the very least sexually.

"Oohh, he wants the gay girl" Tamsin said with a giggle.

"Stop distracting him!" Willow exclaimed. "I can't have this horsecock inside of me without it making me cum!"

"Yes, ma'am" you said, leaning in to kiss her then starting to pound her like you meant it. Behind you, Isobel laughed, her fat tits slapping against your back as you fucked her friend. You then decided that you wanted her next.