Let Peter take your virginity

You clench your terrified asshole around the tip of your brother's finger nervously, not really wanting to take a cock in that hole yet, especially for your first time. Vaginal sex is supposed to feel pretty good, right? It just hurts a bit the first time. You're already furious with yourself for what you're about to say.

"I guess it's okay if he fucks me, dad. Just please don't let him fuck me in the ass." You say, looking up at your father with a pleading look in your eye.

He wants to scold you over the foul language you used, but he quickly falls prey to your puppy dog eyes, especially since there isn't a very good way to say what you just did. He begins to think you're protecting your anal virginity, not realizing he's about to give away your actual virginity by agreeing. "Alright, sweetie. If that's what you want."

Peter pulls his finger out of your ass, finally. He seems a bit upset about not getting a chance to stick it in your rear, but excited to get a chance to fuck your pussy, since he hasn't yet anyway.

He'd likely be more excited if he knew it was your first time. You briefly consider mentioning it, but you don't want to make things even more awkward than they already are. He moves to lay down on the bed beside you, erection already standing tall in the air, then pats his lap while working his stiff cock. "Hop on!"

You sheepishly begin taking off your pants, wishing your father had let him warm you up more. Dad looks away respectfully, then begins stealing glances as your shaven pink pussy comes into view. He's not really sure he actually wants to watch something like this, but figuring he needs to get used to it now anyway. He gets on your bed and stands beside Pete, waiting for you to resume your blowjob when you're ready.

You look at the two cocks as they get slowly jerked by their owners to keep them hard while waiting for you and gulp nervously. Guess this is it.

You move over top of your brother, straddling him as you do, and try to line him up with your pussy so you can sit down on it. You immediately realize everything is too dry for this, so you spit into your hand and quickly rub it on his cock like you've seen other people do, then try again. Your brother throbs from the wet rub down and he moans as he begins to part the folds of your pussy with the head of his penis under your careful direction.

Your father begins to feel awkward about watching the two of you, so he pulls your head over to him, popping his cock into your mouth to make himself feel better about being here for this. You try to bob for a second, but mostly just hold him there as you begin carefully trying to lower yourself down, feeling pain as it begins to stretch your hymen. Peter quickly loses patience and thrusts upward, breaking through and going to the hilt with one powerful stroke.

"AAAHHA HA HA HAAOOOWWW!" You shout loudly around your father's dick, just as he begins to fuck your mouth.

"Ow? OW?! Wait, ow? Oh God!" Your father leans around your backside and stares at the small trickle of blood running down Pete's balls to your sheets in horror. "You're a virgin? You WERE a virgin?! Oh no! Sarah!.... Did you just let your brother take your virginity?!"

He yells at you like the whole situation that just transpired was somehow your fault, making the pain all the worse as Pete slowly begins thrusting into you. You're almost happy he did it so quickly, ripping it off like a bandaid, but the small amount of spit you added as lube runs out quickly, and being suddenly yelled at by your father has you less horny than ever. You wince and yelp with every bounce as your brother humps into you without a care in the world.

Your father looks conflicted as he considers trying to put his cock back into your mouth while you cry out in pain. He looks like he's having a hard time getting into again after finding out he just gave your virginity away to your brother, personally. Especially since he probably would have wanted to take it himself if he had known it was on the table. He suddenly gets an angry look on his face when he thinks about your inexperience.

"Pete, stop for a second." Your father begins, making your brother stop his incessant painful thrust and holding your face up by the chin, making you look him in the eye before he continues. "You know there's going to be a lot of people wanting to give you a donation today, right?"

You nod sheepishly in his hand.

"So you know you're gonna have to get used to this kinda stuff, okay? There's gonna be a lot of not-so-nice guys wanting to do all sorts of painful things to you from now on, so if you aren't used to it now, it's gonna be way worse later, ya know?"

You nod again.

"So you need to get used to this kinda thing with someone who loves you so you don't get hurt. You'll need to learn how to do anal and deepthroat by the end of the day, I would think. Which would you like me to teach you now?" He releases your chin and puts his hands on his hips, his big cock pointed at you ominously, excited again at the chance to do something more fun with you.

You gulp loudly as you decide.