Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 2 by FartAss24 FartAss24

Who's the victim?

Laurel and Sarah, Visiting their Gay-Best Friend

Sarah grinned at me as we climbed the peeling linoleum stairs toward Roger's apartment.

"Tuesdays are my favorite," she sighed, her perfectly tailored blazer brushing against my arm. She adjusted her engagement ring, its diamond catching the fluorescent light of the musty stairway as she gripped the rail tightly, walking with pace.

"Duh! Tuesday nights are sacred." I adjusted my leather jacket as we climbed the crumbling apartment stairs. "Like, call-of-your-engagement sacred." I joked, flashing Sarah my killer smile, the one that made bartenders spill drinks.

We were buzzing—a good buzz, like the kind from expensive champagne and knowing your life is basically perfect. My own ring — Ethan’s grandmother’s Art Deco behemoth — dug reassuringly into my finger.

Sarah shook her head laughing. "Sacred? Try non-negotiable."

Her laughter echoed brighter than the dim hallway deserved. We’d been climbing these stairs since grad school — Sarah squeezing my hand during thesis meltdowns, me stealing fries from her takeout boxes. Back then, her Korean-American parents worried she’d never focus on med school; my Spanish-Filipino abuela despaired I’d "become miserable" at my corporate consulting job. Joke’s on them. At 5’10" in stilettos, I tower over conference tables. Sarah, at 5’2", commands ERs in pastel scrubs. We survived hangovers and heartbreaks between these peeling walls. Now? Engaged to men who proposed within weeks of each other. Ethan builds eco-skyscrapers. Ben designs AI algorithms. Perfect, right?

Sarah paused mid-step, the harsh overhead light catching the impossible smoothness of her porcelain skin. "Non-negotiable," she repeated, softer now. Her almond-shaped eyes, always warm, held that familiar Tuesday-night gleam. She unbuttoned her silk blouse collar — a nervous habit since college — revealing the delicate hollow of her throat. Her curves beneath that tailored jacket were legendary: the waist nipped in, hips flaring like a vintage pinup, legs shortening the steep ascent.

I snorted, leaning against the sticky railing. My leather pants felt sleek against legs stretching forever upward. My complexion, darker than Sarah’s golden-fair, glowed faintly in the grime. High cheekbones, inherited from Manila and Madrid, caught shadows sharply. The staircase smelled faintly of mildew and ancient takeout, but beneath it? Sarah’s vanilla perfume and my own citrus scent tangled, clean against decay. Our matching Louboutins clicked rhythmically. Partners in crime since college.

Sarah glanced at her slender wristwatch, a tiny diamond-studded thing Ben bought her, and her smooth brow furrowed. "Shit! Almost seven! Twenty minutes late, Laurel! Roger’s gonna kill us."

Her voice pitched higher, urgent. She practically launched herself up the remaining steps, those incredible hips swaying urgently beneath her snug pencil skirt. Her blouse strained slightly across her generous chest with each hurried step. The hurried movement made her long dark hair bounce against her neck. She moved like a startled deer — graceful panic.

I lagged half a step behind, grinning openly. Her ass in that skirt? Forget sculpted marble; it was a masterpiece of soft, generous curves shifting graceful. Korean perfection wrapped in designer wool. The sheer, practiced confidence she radiated doing something as mundane as rushing upstairs was mesmerizing. My gaze lingered appreciatively. Totally platonic appreciation, obviously. Just best friend stuff.

We practically collided in front of Roger's familiar, battered door – faded green paint peeling near the knob, a faint scuff mark knee-high Sarah had made years ago. The faint odor of stale cigarettes and fried food seeped through the wood. Sarah fumbled her tiny clutch, fingers trembling slightly against its snakeskin texture. Her flawless face was flushed pink, making her look even more cherubic.

I raised a perfectly manicured hand and knocked. Three sharp, rapid raps. Almost frantic. Beneath the polished exterior, my knuckles were white. We shared a quick, breathless glance, wide-eyed smiles plastered on. The silence stretching behind the door felt thick, charged. We could hear the faint murmur of a television inside. Heavy footsteps shuffled closer. The metallic scratch of locks disengaging seemed unnaturally loud. Sarah unconsciously smoothed her already impeccable skirt, her other hand fiddling with the diamond solitaire on her finger.

The door swung inward, revealing Roger silhouetted against the yellowish haze of his cluttered living room. His faded Hawaiian shirt strained over his considerable belly, the floral pattern lost beneath sauce stains. Greasy wisps of gray hair clung defiantly to his gleaming scalp.

"You're late...twenty-three minutes" he rasped, his voice thick with displeasure. His small, watery eyes narrowed beneath heavy brows, fixing first on Sarah, then on me. A vein pulsed faintly at his temple. The stale air escaping his apartment carried the sour tang of unwashed laundry and microwaved dinners.

Sarah gasped, her hand flying to her mouth. "Roger! Oh god, we are so sorry!" Her voice trembled, high-pitched and ****. She surged forward instinctively, her Louboutins catching on the threadbare welcome mat. "It was Ben! He just wouldn't—he kept fussing about dinner reservations next week, and then Ethan called Laurel about—" Her explanation tumbled out in a frantic, breathless jumble, her flawless complexion flushing crimson. Her fingers twisted at her ring nervously.

Panic seized me. "It’s true!" I blurted, stepping closer. Roger’s frown deepened; it felt like a physical blow. "Ethan was being impossible, Roger! Asking why Tuesday nights were untouchable, saying he wanted to..." My own guilt churned, thick and hot.

Sarah nodded vigorously beside me. "We tried to leave sooner, we really did!" she whimpered, her voice cracking.

Roger didn't move from the doorway, his short, stocky frame blocking the entrance. His gaze tracked the frantic rise and fall of Sarah's chest beneath her silk blouse, then lingered on my leather-clad legs. The silence stretched, thick with our guilt and his unspoken disapproval. Sarah wrung her hands, her knuckles white. I could feel sweat pricking my hairline beneath my dark waves.

Then, slowly, the harsh lines of his face softened. A wheezing chuckle escaped his lips, transforming his scowl into something resembling warmth. "Ah, hell," he rasped, his voice losing its jagged edge. He reached out, his thick, stubby fingers surprisingly deft as they brushed a stray lock of hair my flushed cheek. "How can I stay mad at my two favorite girls?" The touch lingered, possessive. "Get your gorgeous asses in here."

Relief crashed over us like a wave. Sarah practically melted, leaning into him with a soft sigh, her earlier panic dissolving instantly. Her eyes shone with adoration. "Oh, Roger!" she breathed, her voice thick with gratitude.

Without hesitation, she surged forward, rising onto her toes with practiced grace. Her face tilted up eagerly as she slid her arms around his thick neck, fingers tangling briefly in the frayed collar of his shirt. I moved almost simultaneously, pressing against his other side. The smell intensified – unwashed skin beneath cheap aftershave. Roger's hands clamped down. One huge palm engulfed Sarah's waist, fingers digging possessively into the soft curve above her hip, pulling her hard against his stained shirtfront. The other hand landed heavily on my ass, squeezing the taut leather through my pants, fingers pressing deep.

As the door closed behind us, Sarah tilted her head back, her lips parting obediently. Roger leaned down – a tough angle – and kissed her, wetly, messily, his tongue thrusting past her teeth. It lasted seconds that felt endless. When he finally pulled his mouth from hers with a wet smack, saliva glistened on Sarah’s chin. Her eyes were glassy, unfocused, cheeks flushed deep crimson. She swayed slightly, enjoying the kiss.

He swiveled his head toward me. I met his eyes – dark, demanding pools. My taller frame instantly became a complication. At 5'10" even without heels, I dwarfed him. Struggling to meet his height, my neck strained painfully. My heels scraped against the linoleum as I fought to maintain balance, my body bending unnaturally. Yet, despite the awkward contortion, a wave of intense pleasure washed through me. His other hand snaked up my spine, fingers digging into the leather jacket. A low moan escaped me, vibrating against his perusing tongue. The discomfort faded beneath the sheer **** of his kiss, replaced by a dizzying, familiar warmth. My own hands clutched at his shoulders, pulling him closer, deepening the awkward, straining kiss. He tasted like cheap beer and stale peanuts, yet I couldn't get enough. He broke away abruptly, leaving me breathless. A thin thread of saliva connected his lower lip to mine before snapping.

Roger chuckled, a low rumble vibrating through his chest. With firm hands still holding us tightly, he shuffled us backward into the apartment.

"Inside, princesses," he ordered, his tone dripping with exaggerated patience, like addressing toddlers. The familiar, cluttered chaos of Roger’s living room enveloped us – overflowing ashtrays, pizza boxes stacked precariously, the blare of a muted re-run on his ancient television.

Sarah giggled beside me, a sound of pure relief, her earlier panic vanished completely. Her eyes met mine, sparkling with shared, giddy adoration. She looked radiant, lips slightly swollen from his kiss. Everything's okay her look screamed silently. We shared a conspiratorial smile, relieved our transgression was forgiven. He steered us firmly toward the worn, stained sofa dominating the small space.

We took a few eager steps, the promise of settling onto the familiar cushions beckoning. Suddenly, Roger stopped dead. His hands tightened on our waists, halting us instantly. He tilted his bald head, feigning surprise. "Hold up, girls," he rasped, his eyes narrowing playfully, shifting between Sarah and me. "Feels like somethin's missing... ain't it Tuesday?" His gaze lingered pointedly on Sarah's silk blouse, then dropped to my leather jacket. A knowing smirk played on his lips. "Forgot our special tradition already?" He clicked his tongue lightly, the sound echoing in the sudden stillness.

Sarah met my eyes first. A flicker of shared understanding passed between us, swiftly followed by a bubble of pure delight. Her smooth cheeks flushed pink again, but this time with excitement, not panic. She rolled her eyes dramatically towards the ceiling, a giggle escaping her swollen lips.

"Oh Roger," she breathed, her voice thick with affectionate amusement, "you're terrible!" It was our little game, this playful charade of forgetting the ritual. Instinctively, my own eyes rolled skyward in perfect sync with hers, a wide, giddy grin splitting my face. How could we have been so silly? Of course we knew what he meant.

Without needing words, Sarah turned towards me, her expression softening into pure trust. Her fingers, delicate yet insistent, found the cold metal zipper of my leather jacket. She tugged it down slowly, deliberately, the sound loud in the quiet apartment. I felt the cool air kiss my exposed collarbone, followed instantly by the warmth radiating from Sarah's closeness. Her focus was intense as she pushed the stiff leather off my shoulders.

My own hands, trembling slightly with anticipation and shared friendship, reached for the intricate pearl buttons of her silk blouse. The first button popped free, revealing the smooth, impossibly fair skin beneath. My fingertips brushed against the delicate lace edge of her bra. Sarah sighed softly, leaning into my touch, her eyes drifting closed for a blissful moment as I worked the next button. The scent of her vanilla perfume intensified, mingling with the stale air and the faint, musky warmth of Roger watching us intently.

Heels were kicked off with sharp, clattering sounds. First Sarah's Louboutins skittered toward the overflowing recycling bin. Then mine followed, landing with a dull thud near a discarded pizza box. We giggled, the sound high and bright, as we wriggled out of our restrictive pencil skirt and leather pants. Silk and leather pooled around our ankles like discarded petals. Sarah’s pencil skirt fell first, revealing gloriously plump thighs and the swell of her hips barely contained by sheer lace panties. My leather pants peeled away slowly, clinging for a moment before surrendering, exposing legs that seemed to stretch endlessly upward. Standing there in just our lingerie – Sarah’s pale pink demi-cup bra barely restraining her full curves, my own black satin set a stark contrast against my warmer skin – felt exhilaratingly normal.

Sarah struck a playful pose, one hand on her hip, the other dramatically flung out. "Ta-da!" she chirped. Her expression was pure, innocent mischief. I mirrored her instantly, pivoting gracefully on my bare feet, arms wide, presenting myself like a runway model finishing her walk. "Better?" I jokingly asked, my voice full of laughter that echoed Sarah’s. We were offering ourselves up as a joke, our shared comfort with Roger transforming this undressing into something silly.

Our playful eyes met Roger’s – and then simultaneously dipped lower. There it was. Impossible to miss beneath the straining, grease-stained fabric of his cheap khakis: the unmistakable, rigid outline of his erection, pressing insistently against the zipper. My breath hitched audibly, a tiny gasp escaping my parted lips. A slow, knowing smirk bloomed across Sarah's flushed face. She glanced sideways at me, her eyes sparkling with shared amusement and pure delight. I knew my own grin widened instantly, mirroring hers. See? her look seemed to say. He’s happy. Everything’s fine. The sight wasn't shocking or awkward; it was confirmation. The last lingering shred of tension evaporated. Roger was happy.

Of course he was. He was our Roger. Our gay best friend whose appreciation was purely aesthetic… obviously. It was flattering, really.

I smiled at his familiar gaze, thinking back to how we met Roger. Sarah and I, fresh-faced and terrified twenty-somethings crammed into the apartment next door, convinced our lumpy, balding neighbor was a serial peeper. We’d whisper, clutching cheap wine glasses, whenever his heavy tread echoed in the hall. “Did you see the way he looked at my laundry basket?” Sarah would hiss, eyes wide. I’d nod frantically, remembering look he gave me, gaze lingering on my legs in my sundress as I left for a date with Ethan. Pure creep. We’d drawn imaginary lines in the hallway carpet he better not cross.

Then… the Great Internet Outage. Sarah studing for exams. **** pacing. Our modem blinked accusing red eyes. And wouldn't you know it? His internet conveniently went kaput too. A suspiciously timed coincidence. His knock – hesitant, heavy – made us jump. Sarah peered through the peephole, her face pale. “It’s him, Mr. Creep” she breathed, the syllables thick with dread. He offered, in that gravelly rasp, to "take a peek" at our router. Desperation overcame caution. We cracked the door, reluctantly letting him in . He shuffled in, radiating awkward middle-aged menace. We hovered, tense, watching his thick, clumsy fingers unplug wires, fiddle with ports on our modem while muttering tech jargon that sounded vaguely plausible yet utterly nonsensical. He plugged his own ancient laptop in. Said he needed to run a "diagnostic." Clicked things. The modem blinked back to life. Green light. Salvation! He’d grunted something about a "shared signal boost," winked (a grotesque, leering twitch), and shuffled out. We were grateful in the moment, relief somewhat washing away the lingering creep-factor.

The thaw began slowly. Awkward hallway encounters transformed. Instead of darting glances and hurried whispers, we’d offer tentative smiles. "Morning, Roger!" I chirped one Tuesday, surprising even myself. He’d grunted back, a sound resembling "Mornin'," clutching his overflowing laundry basket. Progress! We eventually chalked his awkwardness up to shyness. Harmlessness. Maybe he wasn't secretly filming us through vents? The shared experience of cheap apartments and leaky faucets forged a strange camaraderie. Our fear morphed into pity, then burgeoning friendship.

One laundry day, I was wrestling an uncooperative fitted sheet into the dryer, clad in snug yoga pants and a worn tee. The door swung open, and Roger stood there, no laundry basket in sight. For a suspended moment, he didn’t move. His gaze traveled down—slowly, deliberately—from my face, over my chest, tracing the curve of my waist and hips hugged by the black fabric, all the way to my bare ankles. Then came that rough voice: "Lookin' real nice today, Laurel."

My cheeks flushed hot—not with discomfort, but a sudden, startling warmth. This wasn't the creepy leer we'd feared. This felt… genuine. Appreciative. "Thanks, Roger," I’d chirped back, smoothing my shirt, strangely flattered. Sarah found me later, grinning like an idiot. "He complimented my outfit!" I’d whispered. She’d squealed. "See? Just appreciates aesthetics!" Our protective walls crumbled completely. He was just a lonely guy with good taste.

A few weeks later, the invitation felt like natural progression. "We should cook for him," Sarah suggested one evening, swirling her pinot noir. "Pay him back for the internet." We planned meticulously. Straightened the apartment until it shone. Sarah wore a stunning red silk sheath dress; I chose tailored cigarette pants and a plunging camisole. We cooked Pad Thai and Korean BBQ – extravagant for our budgets at the time. He arrived in a slightly-too-small button-down shirt. Conversation flowed surprisingly easily over cheap wine. We laughed, genuinely enjoying his dry wit. It felt good. Safe.

Then, halfway through dessert I leaned across the small table. The wine made me bold, blurting out the question burning inside me: "Roger? Are you...married? Or seeing someone?" Sarah froze mid-bite, eyes darting nervously to mine.

Roger paused, setting down his fork. He looked directly at me, his expression unreadable for a heartbeat. Then, a low chuckle came from his chest. "Married? Nah," waving a dismissive hand. "Errr...girls ain't my scene." His eyes crinkled at the corners, almost as if he was gauging to see if we believed him. "Never have been. I..ugh...swing the other way."

Relief, sharp and giddy, flooded through me. Sarah exploded into giggles beside me, a high, clear sound like shattering glass. "Oh my god!" she gasped, covering her mouth. "Laurel, we were total idiots!" Tears of laughter streamed down her cheeks. "We thought... we thought you were such a creepy pervert! Watching us!" The confession tumbled out, fueled by wine and sudden, overwhelming release.

"Total idiots!" I echoed, dissolving into helpless laughter, my face buried in my hands. The absurdity of it all crashed over us. "We're so sorry, Roger!" I managed between gasps. "We judged you so wrong!" We were leaning into each other, shaking with mirth, giggling apologies mixing with relieved sighs. The fear vanished, replaced by a warm, dizzying camaraderie. Our "creepy" neighbor wasn't threatening at all. He was gay. Harmless. Safe.

Roger just watched us, that knowing smirk playing on his lips again, nodding slowly as if savoring our drunken confession. "Thought I was a pervert, huh?" he murmured, leaning back comfortably. "And here you are, cooking me dinner lookin' like a couple'a supermodels." He took a slow sip of wine, his gaze lingering appreciatively on Sarah's exposed shoulder, then drifting to the low neckline of my camisole.

Roger just grinned that slow, indulgent grin, patting my knee reassuringly. "Water under the bridge, princesses," he rumbled, his voice thick with amusement. "Just glad you finally see me straight." We all burst out laughing again – the sheer delicious irony of that statement! From that night, it became effortless.

He stopped being "Roger-next-door" and became "Our Roger." He started dropping by constantly. "Need a third opinion!" he'd bark, pushing past us into our tiny apartment, his gaze immediately sweeping over Sarah's outfit. "Laurel! That blouse looks hot on you! Blue's your colour, babe." He'd rummage through my closet with surprising decisiveness, pulling out a sapphire silk top I'd forgotten I owned. "This! With the black skirt. Perfection." His hands were firm, practical, as he adjusted the collar, fingers brushing my collarbone possessively. Sarah would twirl happily, delighted by his blunt appraisal. "Roger thinks this dress makes my ass look amazing!" she'd announce proudly. We welcomed it.

The hugs started naturally. Arrival hugs became lingering embraces where his thick arms enveloped us entirely, his face buried briefly in our hair. Departures earned affectionate pats – firm, lingering smacks right on the curve of our asses that echoed slightly in the hallway. "See ya, gorgeous," he'd rasp, giving Sarah's generous backside a final, proprietary squeeze while his other hand lingered possessively on my leather-clad hip. We'd giggle, exchanging amused, fond glances. So Roger! Such a harmless, flamboyant queen.

Standing half-naked before him now, our discarded clothes piled like offerings at his feet, that familiar comfort wrapped around us tighter than any silk robe. Sarah’s playful pose relaxed into easy grace, her flawless skin luminous under the dingy overhead bulb. My own taller frame felt perfectly at ease, even clad only in satin and lace. Roger’s gaze travelled slowly over Sarah’s curves, lingered appreciatively on the long lines of my legs, then settled warmly on our faces.

"Sit," he commanded softly, patting the sagging sofa cushion on either side of him. The worn floral fabric exhaled dust motes dancing in the stale air as we obeyed instantly, the springs groaning beneath our combined weight. Sarah slid gracefully to his right, the soft swell of her hip pressing flush against his bulk. I folded my long legs carefully to his left, our bare thighs brushing his stained trousers. His arms encircled our waists instantly. One broad palm settled heavily against Sarah’s silk-clad chest, fingers splayed possessively just beneath the swell of her breasts. His other arm hooked around me, his heavy hand resting low on my hipbone, thumb tracing idle circles against my bare skin where the satin band met flesh. I sighed contentedly, leaning my head briefly against his shoulder, my hair brushing his jawline.

"Now," Roger started, his voice thick with pretend sympathy. He squeezed Sarah's breast experimentally through the silk, kneading the soft flesh beneath. Sarah shifted slightly, a soft, **** gasp escaping her lips, her eyelids fluttering. His gaze, sharp and assessing, flickered between our faces. "Talk to me. What’s got those boys of your's all twisted up?" His fingers dug possessively into my hipbone, pulling me closer against his side.

"Ben was asking questions again," Sarah blurted out suddenly, twisting the diamond solitaire on her finger nervously. Her brow furrowed, genuine worry momentarily clouding her adoring gaze. "He wants to know why Tuesday dinners are non-negotiable. Why I can’t ever reschedule. He sounded... suspicious." She glanced at me, seeking solidarity.

I nodded fervently, pressing closer against Roger's bulk. "Ethan too!" My voice sounded higher than usual, tinged with defensive frustration. "He keeps saying Roger's 'weird' and 'inappropriate.' He doesn't understand our friendship at all!" Roger's fingers tightened around my hipbone, grounding me instantly. His thumb traced slow circles against my bare skin.

"Typical men. Can't comprehend a pure, platonic friendship..." His other hand slid from my hip down my thigh, the rough pads of his fingers gripping the sensitive flesh just above my knee, squeezing me. Roger’s voice dropped, his grip tightening subtly on both of us, "and their tiny minds twist it into something dirty. Pathetic."

Sarah gasped softly, her eyes widening with sudden clarity. "Yes! Exactly!" Relief flooded her features, smoothing the worry lines instantly. "Ben can't seem to grasp why we enjoy spending time with you. As if it's remotely abnormal that we'd want to hang out with our older, middle-aged, gay, ex-neighbor." She leaned her head against Roger's shoulder, her dark hair spilling over his shirt. "Laurel? Remember Ethan accusing Roger of having ulterior motives?" She rolled her eyes dramatically.

A genuine giggle bubbled up from me. "Ulterior motives?" I shifted my long legs slightly under Roger's lingering grip. "As if Roger would ever look at us that way!" It felt absurd. Roger's hands, one firmly cupping Sarah's breast, the other gripping my inner thigh, weren't lewd demands – they were affirmations of our unshakeable, platonic bond. His obvious erection pressing against my leg? Just harmless appreciation. The sheer absurdity of Ethan and Ben's jealousy felt suddenly hilarious.

"Ulterior motives?" he echoed theatrically. His gaze, however, held a sharp intensity as he locked onto Sarah's flushed face. "Sarah, look at me."

Before Sarah could respond, his thick, stained fingers hooked roughly under the delicate lace strap of her pale pink bra. With a sudden, sharp tug downwards, the flimsy fabric tore away with a soft rip. Her full breasts sprang free, pale and flawless, nipples hardening instantly in the cool air. Roger lowered his head, his tongue rasping wetly against her soft flesh, his lips closing greedily around one stiffening peak. He sucked hard, his eyes sliding closed momentarily. Sarah arched her back instinctively, a low moan escaping her parted lips. Her fingers tangled weakly in his thinning gray hair, holding him closer, her eyes fluttering shut with pure, unfiltered contentment.

Simultaneously, his other hand slid unerringly from my thigh, skimming upwards beneath the hem of my black satin panties. Rough fingertips found me already slick and swollen. He didn't hesitate as his thick index finger thrust inside me, curling deliberately, while his thumb found my clit and began circling it with practiced, relentless pressure. Sparks of intense pleasure shot through my core. My hips bucked involuntarily against his hand, a choked whimper tearing from my throat as my head fell back against the sofa cushion. The sensations – Roger's hot mouth on Sarah's breast, his fingers working deep within me – weren't invasive. They were comforting. More proof of our tight-knit friendship.

He pulled his mouth from Sarah's nipple with a wet pop, leaving it glistening and swollen. He raised his head slightly, his own lips slick. "Tell me, sexies." His fingers inside me didn't pause. "Does this feel like an ulterior motive?" His eyes swept from Sarah's blissful expression to my own clouded gaze. "Does our honest friendship feel... improper?" He punctuated the word improper by twisting his thumb sharply against my clit, sending a jolt of bliss through me that made me cry out.

Sarah sighed deeply, a sound of pure exasperation mingled with affection. She shifted slightly against him, her exposed breasts brushing his stained shirt. "You don't need to convince us. They're just being stubborn guys, Roger." Her fingers gently stroked his bald head as he resumed sucking her other breast, his movements hungry. "Ben gets this little jealous crease right here," she tapped her own smooth forehead lightly, "whenever I mention Tuesdays. He doesn't understand." She arched her back further, pushing her soft flesh deeper into his mouth. "Thinks it's weird I want to spend time with you... a sweet, kind, older gay man." She giggled breathlessly. "It's stupid jealousy, that's all. He'll get over it."

"Jealous?" he asked, genuine confusion furrowing his brow. "Why? They've got two gorgeous, loyal women waiting at home." His thumb pressed harder against my clit, making me whimper. My hips rocked selfishly against his hand. "Two devoted fiancées. What's to be jealous of?"

I swallowed hard, struggling to form words through the thick haze of joy. "Because..." My voice came out ragged as his finger thrust deeper. I met Sarah's trusting gaze. She nodded encouragingly, her lips swollen from his kisses. "...because we made them promise," I managed, shifting my hips to meet Roger's pistoning.

"No sex. Not 'til marriage." Sarah chimed in.

"Yeah... the wedding night. We want it pure, special." I rolled my eyes fondly. "May be a little frustrated, I guess. Pent-up energy."

She shrugged, her breasts jiggling slightly. "They love us but makes them a little cranky... suspicious."

I leaned into Roger’s solid warmth, the pressure of his finger inside me anchoring me. "We decided about a month after becoming friends with you. We weren't exactly... sheltered." I remembered fleeting encounters with handsome, successful men – fleeting, intense, ultimately shallow. "A few guys here and there. Quality guys," I added quickly, defensively.

"But... empty." Sarah nodded vigorously against Roger's shoulder. "Exactly! Tom before Ben... handsome lawyer. Smart. Fit. Sex was... fine. But?" She wrinkled her nose. "Meh. Like eating plain toast." We both giggled.

Greg before Ethan? A surgeon. Gorgeous hands. I pursed my lips. "Competent? Sure. Passion? Zero."

Sarah sighed dramatically. "Exactly! Like lukewarm tap water." She giggled, leaning deeper into Roger’s thick arm encircling her waist. His fingers resumed kneading her bare breast. "We'd already met Ben and Ethan when we started hanging with you. Perfect gentlemen. Respectful." Her expression softened dreamily. "They cherished us. Worshiped us. So... we decided." She glanced at me, seeking confirmation.

"We decided," I echoed firmly, shifting my hips against Roger’s relentless fingers. Pleasure pulsed hot and urgent. "To save ourselves. To keep it sacred. For them." The words felt righteous, logical. "We told them our vows included waiting. They agreed." Pride warmed my chest. "Honorable men."

He leaned forward, his belly pressing against Sarah’s bare thigh. "So since meeting me, neither of you..." He trailed off, letting the implication hang thickly. His gaze flicked to Sarah’s flushed face, then locked onto mine. "Not even... a slip?" His thumb traced Sarah’s inner thigh, creeping higher. "No... compromises?"

Sarah gasped indignantly. "Roger!" Her almond eyes widened with wounded sincerity. "Never!" She twisted her engagement ring fiercely. "I love Ben. I’d never betray him. Not even a kiss!" Her flawless skin flushed brighter, righteous anger mixing with loyalty.

I shook my head vigorously, my dark waves brushing Roger’s stained shirt. "Same! Ethan’s my everything!" The thought felt preposterous. Cheating? Unthinkable. My commitment was absolute. "We wouldn’t dream of it," I declared, meeting Sarah’s fervent gaze. She nodded fiercely, clutching Roger’s arm. Complete agreement. Total trust.

Roger chuckled softly. "Good girls." Satisfaction rumbled in his chest. He patted Sarah’s knee gently. Then, his eyes shifted fully to me.

"Laurel." His voice cut through the air. "Mind ditching the panties?" His thick finger jabbed toward my black satin underwear.

Without hesitation, I hooked my thumbs under the delicate waistband. The cool air kissed my slick folds as I slid them down my long legs, kicking them aside onto the stained carpet.

He grinned. "Thanks. Now on your back."

I too smiled warmly. Positioning myself felt natural. I stretched out fully on the worn sofa cushions, my spine pressing into the coarse fabric. My bare legs fell open. Confidence radiated through me. This was... Roger. Safe. Familiar. My harmless, gay best friend. Sarah watched me settle, her expression soft, approving, utterly trusting. She leaned closer to Roger, as he shifted his considerable weight between us, his stained khakis straining tautly.

He grunted softly as he freed himself. Short but thick. Veined. Already glistening at the tip. He gripped the base firmly, angling it towards my exposed entrance. The blunt head nudged against my slick opening, pressing insistently. I inhaled sharply. Roger’s other hand remained possessively cupping Sarah’s bare breast, fingers idly rolling her nipple.

"God, Laurel," Sarah stated, her voice full of conviction. "If Ben and Ethan could just... see us? Right now?" She gestured vaguely with her free hand towards Roger’s straining erection poised at my entrance. "They’d realize instantly how ridiculous they’re being. How totally offbase their suspicions are."

Roger nodded at her assessment, his hips shifting slightly forward. The pressure against my entrance intensified, stretching me wonderfully. My breath hitched.

"Exactly!" I continued, staring at the thick shaft teasing at my folds. "They’d realize Roger’s only ever been... supportive." I giggled suddenly, a light, airy sound.

"Honestly? If anyone should worry?" Sarah leaned towards Roger, her breast pressing into his hand. "It should be us! Keeping you away from their charming company!" She winked theatrically at Roger. "We might need to protect Ben and Ethan from you, handsome! A charming gay man like Roger? They'd be putty in your hands!" Her flawless face beamed with affectionate amusement.

As Sarah rambled, his thick cockhead breached me easily, slick as I was. There was that familiar, stretching fullness, a pressure quickly blooming into deep warmth flooding my core. It felt… nice. Comfortable. Like pulling on my favorite soft sweater after a long day. Not earth-shattering, just pleasant. Routine. As natural as breathing. I sighed contentedly, sinking deeper into the scratchy cushions. He slid deeper, a slow, heavy glide that pushed against my inner walls, igniting low sparks that rippled gently outward. Nothing frantic, nothing ****. Just… Roger. Solid, dependable Roger. My hips lifted lazily to meet his, encouraging him deeper still. "Mmm," I hummed, gazing up at the water-stained ceiling tiles. "Feels good, Rog."

Roger grunted, bottoming out inside me with a final, solid thrust that pressed my pubic bone firmly against his thick base. He stayed buried deep, his hips settling heavily against mine. A familiar ache started low in my belly, spread thin and lazy by his leisurely pace. He began rocking slowly, a steady, unhurried pace like a lazy river current. Each drag inward stirred that pleasant warmth. His thumb found my clit again, lazily circling. Pleasure built steadily, predictably, like water slowly coming to a simmer. It was comforting. Familiar. We’d done this countless Tuesdays.

"So," I sighed easily, my voice barely hitching as he pulled back almost entirely before pushing deep again. His thick shaft dragged deliciously against sensitive spots. "Like I was saying… Ethan…" My brow furrowed slightly, focusing past the pleasant distraction between my legs. Roger’s slow thrusts felt grounding, helping me think. "...might also be a little stressed about the wedding. He kept pushing about the registry yesterday. Wanted to add golf clubs." I rolled my eyes skyward in exasperation. Roger's thumb pressed harder on my clit, sending a sharper jolt that made me spasm briefly. "Oh! Nice, your dick feels amazing," I murmured automatically, relaxing back.

"Golf clubs? Seriously?" Sarah chimed in, leaning over Roger to get a better view of my face. "Ben tried to suggest ski chalet towels!" Her fingers tightened briefly on Roger’s arm. "As if!" Roger huffed agreement, his hips snapping forward sharply once, hitting deep enough to **** a breathy grunt from me. "Yesss… feels really nice like that," I managed, smiling up at him reassuringly. I let my eyes drift closed, focusing on the thick, short cock pushing into me. Just Tuesday night comfort. Nothing to see here. Pure friendship. Ben and Ethan were just… being silly guys.

The thought crystallized suddenly, blooming bright and obvious like a lightbulb flicking on. My eyes snapped open. "Oh!" I gasped, shifting my hips slightly to accommodate Roger’s next thick thrust. "That’s it!" Roger paused mid-rock, his thick shaft buried deep, his brow furrowing slightly. Sarah tilted her head, curious. "What’s it?" she asked softly.

"Maybe..." I started, the idea gaining momentum, feeling perfectly logical, utterly reasonable. "...maybe Ethan and Ben just need to meet Roger!" I beamed triumphantly at Sarah, then up at Roger’s face hovering above me. "Properly! Not that awkward hallway nod years ago! A real hangout! Beer? Pizza? Then they’ll see!" My voice pitched higher with excitement. "They’ll understand! They’ll realize how wonderful Roger is! How… normal our friendship is! How dumb their jealousy is!"

Sarah’s expression shifted instantly from confusion to radiant understanding as her face lit up. "Oh my god, Laurel! YES! That’s brilliant!" she breathed, clapping her hands together softly. "You would adore Ben, Roger!"

Deliberately, Roger withdrew his shaft from my slick entrance with a wet, sucking sound. The sudden emptiness felt jarringly cold. He leaned back, settling his considerable fat frame deeper into the sofa cushions.

"Hmmmm. Might be time," Roger said. His gaze locked onto Sarah’s. "High time… to have a little chat with those boyfriends of yours."

"Boyfriends?" I corrected gently, a soft, affectionate smile playing on my lips. I held up my left hand, placing it on his flabby shoulder as he resumed pumping into me. "Fiancés, Rog. They’re our fiancés now. Remember?"

A bark of laughter erupted from Roger’s chest, startlingly loud in the small room as he pulled out of me for good and sat back on the couch. It held an edge that made Sarah flinch almost imperceptibly. Her adoring smile faltered for a fraction of a second before snapping back into place, brighter than ever.

Roger slapped his thick thigh. "Fiancés!" he wheezed, shaking his head slowly. "Right, right." He patted Sarah’s knee again, then jabbed a thick, stubby finger towards his own lap. His erection stood rigid. "Alright, princess. Up."

Sarah didn’t hesitate. A beatific smile spread across her flushed face. "Of course, Rog!" she chirped, scrambling eagerly to her feet. She quickly pulled her underwear off and placed them to the side, climbing onto his thick thighs. Her movements were graceful, practiced. She pivoted smoothly on his lap, her bare back pressing against his straining belly.

She presented her rounded, perfect ass inches from his cock. "Just like this?" she asked sweetly, glancing over her shoulder, her eyes wide and trusting.

Roger grunted, grabbing her hips firmly. He spat thickly onto his palm, then slicked it roughly over his glistening tip. He aimed the blunt head directly against Sarah’s tight, puckered opening. "Exactly like that, doll."

Sarah sighed, relaxing back against his stained shirtfront. She wiggled her hips slightly, seeking better purchase on his thick thighs. Her soft flesh yielded against the insistent pressure. Roger leaned forward, his hot breath washing over her ear. "No concerns?" His thick finger traced the straining rim teasingly. "About... this?" He nudged the thick crown harder against her clenching entrance. "Your sweet little asshole getting plowed by your fat, bald, pervy, 'gay' neighbor? Sure you trust me?" His tone was thick with mock self-deprecation.

Sarah gasped softly, not from discomfort, but from shock. She craned her neck, straining to meet his eyes over her shoulder. Her expression wasn't offended; it was deeply hurt. "Roger! Stop it!" Her voice trembled with genuine upset. "Don't you ever talk about yourself like that!" Her fingers dug gently into the meat of his thighs. "You're not pervy! You're our best friend! Our gay best friend!" Her eyes shone with fierce loyalty. "Why... why wouldn't I want this?" She pushed her hips back firmly, swallowing the tip with a soft gasp as it breached her. "It's Tuesday," she added simply, her voice muffled slightly as she turned her face into his shoulder. "This is... what we do."

Her unflinching trust, her complete dismissal of his ugly and pervy description as absurd, fueled Roger’s movements. With a guttural groan, he gripped her hips tighter and shoved forward powerfully. Sarah cried out sharply – a sound that quickly dissolved into a low, satisfied humming as he seated himself fully inside her tight channel. Her body craned beautifully against his, accepting the deep intrusion. Her flawless skin glistened with a fine sheen of sweat. "See?" she breathed raggedly. "Perfectly normal... for us."

I watched Sarah intently, a soft smile playing on my lips. Sarah’s head lolled back against Roger’s shoulder, her eyes fluttering shut. Her breathing hitched, turning shallow and rapid. A blissful haze descended over her features, smoothing away any lingering thought. Her mouth went slack, forming a soft ‘O’. Tiny, breathless sighs escaped her lips with each rhythmic thrust from Roger beneath her. She wasn't talking anymore; she wasn't thinking. She was utterly absorbed, lost in the simple, overwhelming sensation of Roger moving inside her. I had seen this so many times. That familiar Tuesday-night bonding where words dissolved into pure feeling. I shifted comfortably on the sofa, pulling my naked knees up under my chin. I loved watching them like this. It was soothing, this shared ritual. Nothing strange about it. Just Sarah communing with our best friend.

Her humming intensified, vibrating through her chest. Her hands scrabbled weakly against his meaty thighs, fingers flexing aimlessly. Drool began to trickle from the corner of her open mouth, tracing a glistening path down her chin onto Roger’s stained shirt. Her eyes remained blissfully unfocused, staring past me at the peeling wallpaper. I reached out and gently brushed a strand of damp hair from her sweaty forehead like a good friend. Sarah didn't react, lost somewhere far beyond the cluttered apartment.

Roger's thick fingers dug possessively into the soft swell of Sarah’s bare breast, pinching her nipple almost cruelly. Sarah moaned, a low, throaty sound devoid of comprehension, her body responding automatically.

"Fuckin' perfect tits, Sarah," he growled, his hot breath washing over her ear. "Ben ever appreciate 'em like this? Huh?" His hand squeezed harder, making her gasp sharply. "No, 'course not. Too busy worrying about his precious 'pure' bride to be." He spat the word derisively. "Dumb bastard."

He leaned forward, his lips brushing Sarah's temple. "Don't you worry your pretty little heads, dolls. Roger’s gonna fix this." A sly grin spread across his face. "Gonna have a nice, long chat with Ben and Ethan." His hand slid lower, fingers tracing the stretched rim where his shaft pistoned relentlessly into Sarah’s ass. "Make 'em understand how... unfounded their concerns are." He punctuated the last word with a particularly vicious thrust that made Sarah’s cry **** off into a wet gurgle.

I was to relieved. Roger would handle it. Ben and Ethan would finally relax.

Roger slammed into Sarah’s clenching depths one final time, burying himself impossibly deep. A guttural roar ripped from his throat – "Fuckin' take it!" – as his hips locked flush against her perfect curves. Beneath him, Sarah’s body stiffened. Her breasts jutted outward obscenely. Her mouth gaped wide, soundless for a heartbeat, before a ragged, animalistic screech tore from her lungs, echoing off the walls. Pure, visceral release ripped from her core. Her thighs trembled violently against his, fingers clawing uselessly at his hairy thighs. Her head snapped back hard against his shoulder, eyes rolling wildly up into her skull, whites showing. Drool splattered freely onto her chin and his shirt. Her entire body convulsed, shuddering uncontrollably as Roger emptied himself deep inside her ass in thick, pulsing jets.

Slowly, the violent tension seeped out of her. Her frantic breathing evened into shallow, whistling gasps. Her eyelids fluttered weakly before drifting shut. Her head lolled limply against Roger’s shoulder. She slumped bonelessly against him, utterly spent. Roger grunted, easing his softening shaft ou with a plop. A thick rivulet of glistening white immediately began oozing from her hole, tracing a slow, obscene path down her inner thigh, dripping onto the sofa cushion below.

Sarah’s eyes blinked open lazily. They were perfectly clear, focused, holding that familiar Tuesday-night contentment. A serene, slightly drowsy smile touched her swollen lips. "Mmm?" she breathed, her voice husky but calm. She shifted slightly on Roger’s lap, stretching her arms overhead with a languid grace that made her breasts sway enticingly. She glanced down casually at the viscous white fluid leaking freely down her thigh, pooling on the cushion. A flicker of mild annoyance crossed her flawless brow. "Oh, yuck," she sighed, wrinkling her nose delicately. She plucked a discarded napkin from the cluttered coffee table, wiped her thigh briskly, then dabbed lightly at her trembling entrance without a trace of self-consciousness. She tossed the soiled napkin onto the floor amid the pizza boxes.

"Drippier than usual today, Rog," she teased lightly.

"Alright, princesses," he sighed, feigning ****. "Clock's tickin'. Pushing ten." He nudged Sarah gently. "Better get your gorgeous carcasses movin'. Wouldn't want Ben and Ethan," he paused, letting their names hang heavy with sarcasm, "workin' themselves into a lather waitin' up for ya."

The pleasant haze of the past few hours evaporated instantly. Sarah pushed herself upright, wincing slightly as she climbed off Roger's lap, the movement sending another trickle down her inner thigh. She grabbed another greasy napkin, wiping carefully

"Ugh," I groaned, grabbing my clothes. I stared at my discarded boots near the pizza box. "Why do they have to be like this? Every Tuesday!" The frustration was thick in my voice, edged with genuine hurt. "It's not like we're doing anything wrong!"

Sarah nodded vigorously, wiping her thigh again. "Exactly! Ben kept prodding about Roger's hobbies yesterday." She rolled her eyes dramatically as she stepped into her lace panties. "As if Roger needs hobbies! He has us!" She giggled, her fingers trembling slightly as she fastened her bra clasp.

Roger leaned back, grinning smugly as he watched us scramble to get dressed. His stubby fingers drummed on his bare, hairy thigh. "Relax, girls. Deep breaths. Nothing a little chat with them can't fix. I bet we'll become fast friends too. Hell, you both admitted when you first saw me you thought I was some creepy old perv!" He threw his head back and laughed outright.

Sarah paused while pulling her pencil skirt over her hips. "Oh god!" she giggled, cheeks flushing at the memory. "I guess we also were such judgmental idiots!"

I giggled, struggling with my leather pants' zipper. "You screamed when he offered to help with your moving boxes!"

"Because he appeared out of nowhere!" Sarah protested, slipping into her blouse. Her deft fingers raced up the pearl buttons. "One minute, empty hallway. Next?" She shuddered playfully. "This short, fat, sweaty guy breathing heavy beside me! I was afraid he was going to steal something"

"More like steal us!" I chimed in, finally wrestling my leather jacket back on. "I can't believe Mrs. Dominguez in 5F warned us about the 'predator' down the hall." I chuckled, adjusting my engagement ring. "Little did she know!"

Sarah snapped her Louboutins back on. "Oh my god!" Her eyes widened with sudden, playful curiosity. "Is she still trying to get you kicked out, Rog? Filing complaints?" She straightened her blouse, smoothing imaginary wrinkles. "She used to glare lasers at you!"

I leaned against the doorframe, chuckling. "That fiery Colombian bombshell?" I pictured her instantly: impossibly wide hips swaying like a metronome beneath skin-tight leopard print, a cascade of dark curls framing a face perpetually etched in outrage. Volcano breasts threatening to escape plunging necklines, curves that defied physics and zoning laws. Pure New York attitude packed into five foot two of sheer, smoldering Latin fury. "She tried organizing a tenants' committee just to ban you from the laundry room, Rog!" I added, grinning. "Remember? Petitioned everyone."

Roger grunted, a sound thick with satisfaction. He hoisted himself off the sofa. "Maria?" A smirk spread across his face, far too wide, showing yellowed teeth. "Nah." He waved a dismissive hand. "Smoothed things over with her and her husband. Real... understanding lady. Her and that daughter of hers."

Sarah paused, one hand on the doorknob. "Daughter?" Her brow furrowed slightly, a flicker of vague curiosity.

"Yeah, remember Yvonne? Sweet kid." He grabbed a beer from the overflowing fridge, popped the top with a practiced flick. "Nineteen now, in college." The words hung in the air, weighted. He took a long swig, foam clinging to his lip. "Realized I wasn't the problem. See things different now." He gestured vaguely toward the hallway with the bottle. "They have me over on Thursdays for dinner."

Sarah blinked, processing. Her expression cleared instantly, replaced by a wide, relieved smile. "Oh, Roger! That's wonderful!" She beamed, genuine warmth radiating from her flawless face. People just need time to get to know you!"

My own smile mirrored hers effortlessly. Of course. Roger always fixed things. How silly Maria seemed now! All that wasted fury. The image shifted seamlessly in my mind: Maria’s scowl melting into a friendly wave, Yvonne’s shy teenage smile. Thursdays felt... right. Another piece falling perfectly into place. "Glad things are calmer," My mind shifted to Ethan, picturing him laughing and hanging out with Roger, feeling a pleasant glow.

Roger drained his beer, crushing the can with one meaty fist. "Alright, scoot," he ordered gruffly, herding us toward the exit. His palm landed heavily on my ass for a final, possessive squeeze. "Your jealous boytoys are waiting."

We stepped out, giggling softly. "Bye, Rog!" Sarah chirped, blowing him a kiss.

"See you next Tuesday!" I added brightly.

We turned toward the stairs, humming softly. Halfway down the first flight, the sharp clack of high heels approached from below.

Rounding the landing, Maria Dominguez appeared, carrying a bulging grocery bag plastered with a Colombian bakery logo. Behind her, Yvonne hauled another, struggling slightly.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)