Jen

Terry beats Jen.

"Well, guess I lose," Jen said with a smile. "Come get your prize, Terry!" Even though she had lost, she was really looking forward to getting her ass fucked.

"Um, Jen, I don't think I can..." Terry said sadly.

"What do you mean? I know you've wanted to fuck me for like ever. Now's your chance!"

"I just came twice. As much as I'd like to, I don't think I can get it up again any time soon."

"This is a problem," Maria said. "Half of the boys were eliminated too quickly. Terry and Josh can only do so much without us having to wait a long time for them to recover. So how about if one of them can't do the deed, they can pass it to one of the eliminated guys?"

"That works, I guess..." Jen said. She had been really looking forward to Terry fucking her ass. Geo would be a poor substitute.

"I'll do it." Everyone turned to to the door leading to the kitchen and saw Juan standing there.

"Juan? I thought you left!" Tonya said in shock.

Juan walked past Tonya without even looking at her. "So, you need someone to fuck your ass, slut?"

"Why yes, I do!" Juan wasn't as big as Terry but he was close. And as an added bonus, this would be one more win against Tonya. She stood up. "Have a seat, stud. You're getting some special treatment!" Juan sat in Jen's seat and Jen started stroking his cock getting him hard quickly. Then, the covered Juan's cock with lube. Finally, she turned her back on Juan, spread her ass, and slowly impaled her ass on his cock. She sat there with his cock balls deep in her ass and leaned back against him. "Your cock is so deep in my ass!" Juan wasn't the biggest cock she'd had in her ass but was around the size she was most used to. She could ride him as rough as she wanted and that's exactly what she intended to do.

As for Juan, Jen's tight ass was threatening to overwhelm him. Only Tonya knew, and Josh now suspected, that he was a virgin. So, when Jen started to bounce wildly on his cock, it took all of his concentration to not cum prematurely.

Jen was really enjoying herself. Juan hadn't grabbed her tits like she expected, so they bounced freely as she rode his hard. Normally, she would have bent over and let Juan do the work but she wanted to put on a show. She wanted Terry to see what he was missing. And she wanted Tonya to she her fucking her man! Both of those things, plus the hard cock up her ass, really turned her on.

Luckily for Juan, Jen could cum easily from rough anal sex. So when the dam broke and he came hard in her ass, she was already close enough to cumming that it only took a few strokes of her clit to make her cum loudly.

She slumped against Juan, his softening cock still in her ass along with a large amount of cum. "That was fun," she said. "We should do it again sometime!"

"Definitely!"

Tonya wanted to be angry but each of her holes had been used and creamed by three different guys this night, none of them Juan. So she felt sad and uncertain instead.