He lets her choose

"You really want to know?" I asked her softly. "Because I need to warn you, the answer will change your life forever."

"I...believe you," Anna said, her back shivering. "But if you leave now, I will never be able to get the curiosity out of my head."

I hesitated, as a possible solution came to my head and debated whether or not to offer it.

"I have a much bigger crush on her than ever before, after today," I realized. "If I am going to let her into my life, then I need her to decide on her own that she wants to be with me or I am not going to be able to forgive myself."

I sighed and nullified my earlier wish that got her to trust me completely when I surprised her on the shower. Her naked body tensed slightly on the spot and I opened my mouth before I lost my nerve.

"There is an alternative," I said slowly. "I could erase all of your memories about me and use my powers to heal your virginity so that you don't feel confused or guilty...if you prefer."

Anna gaped, looking shocked at the option I just gave her.

"Is that...is that what you want?" She asked, her emotional tone hard to read and I wasn't going to use my cheat codes to figure it out. "For me to forget you?"

I bit my bottom lip, recalling I didn't want to influence her decision too much. But in the end, truth works both ways in order to establish trust. So, I looked into her lovely hazel eyes and I am sure my feelings of longing must have been visible.

"No," Was all I said.

Anna remained quiet for a long time, clearly trying to decide which opposite paths of the crossroad to follow. I just stayed silent and watched her face, angelic in more ways than one. Then, she took a deep breath and walked closer, her breasts shaking as she did. Tentatively, she placed her hand on my chest and looked up.

"I don't know what could change so much if you tell me the truth and I don't know why I feel that walking away from you would be a colossal mistake but...I don't want to forget you," The former angel whispered.

And with that, she gave me a slow, deep kiss. I let her in and held her close, my hard cock pressed against her folds. We lost track of how long we were caught on that embrace and I wasn't going to use my powers to verify it. Some things are better left as mysteries.

Eventually, the redhead broke away and caressed my cheek, nervous but determined. "I am ready," She said.

I smiled warmly at her and sighed. Then, I gently kissed her forehead and wished for the memories to flood back in.