Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by tcorbett691 tcorbett691

What happens that morning?

He has a LOT of fun with me

After our parents were gone, John came into my room (without knocking!). I was still dressed in the shorts and t-shirt I had slept in. "Hey..." I had resigned myself to my fate.

"Heh, you look like you're about to be in front of a firing squad. I want you to put on some makeup and some sexy lingerie. Then, come to my room." With that, he left. Knowing I had ****, I put on some red lingerie that Kevin had given me. Then, I went to John's room. "Very nice! Now, get on the bed and pose so I can take a pic." I got in his bed and tried to look happy. He pulled out a camera and snapped the pic. "Okay, take it off."

"Seriously? You made me put on lingerie just to take a picture?"

"Well yeah. Don't you usually take off your clothes to have sex?" I sighed and took off the lingerie as quickly as I could. "Now, until mom and dad come home, you're going to do exactly what I say. Do I make myself clear?"

"Yeah..."

"Say 'Yes, sir.'"

"...Yes, sir."

"Lay down and spread your legs." I did as I was told and watched with a little bit of fear as he dropped his shorts showing me his already hard cock.

"Aren't you going to fuck my ass?" I asked as he got in bed between my legs. I already knew the answer.

"Oh I will, but I want this hole first since you wouldn't let me fuck it yesterday." He lined up the head of his cock with my traitorously wet pussy and slid his cock in. "Ooooh, this feels different than your ass! It's so warm and wet! It's practically sucking me in!" His cock was just as thick as Kevin's but longer. As his cock went deeper in my pussy than anything else had, it felt good at first and I wrapped my legs around him out of habit. But then he hit the back. "Huh? I can't go in any deeper."

"Wait, that's not all of it?!"

"No, I've got about an inch left. How come I was able to get the whole thing in your ass but not your pussy?"

"How would I know? Let's just get this over with." I turned my head so I didn't have to see him.

"No, look me in the eye. I want you to know who's fucking you!" With that, he started to pound my cunt fast and hard. Unfortunately, it meant he was banging against the back of my pussy really hard!

"Ow! Ow! Ow! Wait! Stop!" Surprisingly, he actually stopped.

"What is it?"

"You're hurting me! I've never had anyone hit the back before and you're doing it really rough! This isn't going to work." Besides the fact that it really was hurting, I knew he had another inch left and I was worried that the whole "**** my cock into your womb" thing might be possible. "Let me ride you." We rolled over so that I was on top. "And no thrusting up. Let me do all the work."

Normally, I wouldn't mind getting fucked roughly. I've had many toe curling orgasms with my arms and legs wrapped around Kevin as he tried to fuck me through his bed. And I've had many where I bounced wildly on his cock. Sex with Kevin was usually wild and rough. But Kevin's cock didn't go deep enough to hit the back of my pussy. Maybe I could get used to that eventually but right now it just registered as pain.

So with John, I had to do a balancing act of sorts. I started slow at first, moving up and down but careful to not go far enough down for him to hit the back, again. Eventually, I got the hang of it and started moving faster. His hands went straight to my tits, of course, but having my tits grabbed is a major turn on for me.

"That's it, Jenna! Ride my cock!"

"You like that, John? You like how my tight, Asian pussy squeezes your big, black cock?" As I bounced on his cock faster and faster, I couldn't help but get into it. I tried to focus on the fact that the guy who's cock I was riding wasn't Kevin but instead I focused on how good John's big cock felt inside of me! My moans got louder and louder as I rode his cock wildly. Soon, I could feel my orgasm approaching. "Oh god! Oh fuck! I'm cumming! I'm CUMMING!" I arched my back and yelled as I came on his cock. I also felt the familiar feeling of a pulsating cock shooting its hot load inside of me. Kevin always cums inside of me so I didn't think anything of it at first.

When I finally came down from my orgasm, I collapsed on top of John and lay there panting as I felt his cock still twitching inside of me. But since his cock hadn't gone down yet, it bumped the back of my pussy and that unfamiliar sensation brought me back. "Oh shit, did you cum inside me?!"

"I did and it felt amazing!"

"What the fuck?! I never said you could cum inside!"

"You're on the pill, aren't you? And besides, do you think I could have pulled out if I wanted to? Now, suck me hard, again. I want your ass next."

"Asshole." I move between his legs and start sucking his cock which was covered in a mixture of our cum. As annoyed as I was, tasting that and feeling him get hard in my mouth really turned me own. I wanted his big, black cock in my ass. That's what I had expected and honestly looked forward to. Hell, even if he hadn't blackmailed me, I probably would have let him have my ass again before the summer was up.

"That's enough. Get on your hands and knees. I want to do you doggy."

"Just be sure to lube me up first." I get in doggystyle position and look back at him. Instead of grabbing his bottle of baby oil, he dips his finger in my cum-filled pussy before fingering my asshole with it. He was lubing my ass with his cum! I didn't know what to think of that but his finger in my ass felt so good that I moaned.

"Heh, you really are an anal slut, aren't you?"

I look away so he can't see me blush. "Just hurry up and stick your dick-- Ah!" He entered my ass without warning and slowly slid the whole thing in before he started thrusting in and out. "Oh! Ah! Fuck! Fuck my ass!" There was no pretending that I wasn't loving this. My poor little pussy couldn't handle the length of his cock but my asshole welcomed it! He was soon thrusting hard and fast and I could hear the sound of him banging against my ass cheeks. My tits were swinging wildly until he moved his hands up and grabbed them.

I've never been good at being quiet during sex. Fucking in Kevin's dorm, everyone knew when I came. Which was at least once a day. I spent more time in his dorm than mine. It got to the point that Kevin stopped trying to keep out his roommate Steve because we were fucking so much. I felt bad for him being denied his room so I let him watch. I did shut him down hard when he tried to join in, though.

But yeah, every night Steve would be in his bed pretending to not jack off while he watched us fuck. And as loud as I got when I was close to cumming, he couldn't sleep anyway.

Me getting roughly fucked in my ass by John's long, black cock had me being even louder. He was right. I was an anal slut! Maybe it was because he couldn't fuck me vaginally the way we both wanted but this was so much better that I soon found myself cumming, again! I practically screamed as an orgasm rocked my whole body. He held me against him with his cock as deep in me as it could go. But then I realized that he wasn't filling my ass with cum yet. I had just cum that quickly.

What do I do to make him cum?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)