Hand pick the teams yourself.

You've refrained from relying on magic so far this evening, but the thought of pairings come to mind and you decide to fix the game a bit to see the results. Beth and Lynn seems like a combination that could implode and ruin the rest of the party, but you're curious to see how the shy girl will react to the more outgoing cheerleader. That leaves Amina and Stacy to pair off while you decide to partner up with Candace. With these choices decided ahead of time, you magically direct the bottle to form the teams.

"This should be interesting," Stacy remarks, seeing Beth and Lynn together.

"... shouldn't you be getting dressed again?" Beth asks Lynn, who still remains nude.

"It's a dress up game, isn't it?" Lynn replies before suddenly becoming more demure and swishes her hips, "Why? Does this bother you?"

Beth frowns, apparently not liking being taunted, "No... I'm fine with it. And besides, you're right, I'm going to dress you up anyways..." The bespectacled brunette looks away in a huff.

"Yeah it's not like you haven't gotten a touch of my body yet, hmm?" Lynn continues to tease. Beth looks to go a shade redder in the cheeks and refuses to look in Lynn's direction.

"Alright everyone..." Candace says, regaining the group's attention. "Pick a dresser and a dressee. The dresser will get a card with the name of a character or profession and they have to dress their partner accordingly. We'll do one each and the team with the fastest guesses in 30 seconds wins! Now, since I already know all the cards, Riley will have to guess both times. Fair enough?"

Everyone seems to be in agreement and began with Stacy and Amina. The rest of the girls sit down on the couch and watch as Amina strips down to her underwear and awaits Stacy. Candace lets Stacy pick a card at random.

Stacy reviews the card and smiles, "This will be easy." She rummages through the trunk of outfits and nods to Candace, "Ready when you are!"

"Remember," Candace says, "No talking or you're disqualified. You have one minute! Ready... set... go!"

Candace starts her stopwatch and Stacy pulls out some clothes. She works quickly, throwing on a gray sweater, then sliding up a pleated skirt.

"Librarian?" Amina guesses. "School girl?"

Stacy signals to Amina that she is close with the second guess.

"School teacher?"

Stacy shakes her head and hands Amina a prop wand.

"A proctor? Disciplinarian?"

It becomes obvious to you that Amina is not very current on current movies. Stacy seems to be stuck on what other hints to give. She adds a pair of stockings to the ensemble and a scarf, but Amina isn't going to get something she isn't aware of. You could let this run through but it'll make their team lose for sure. You silently wish that Amina is aware of popular culture.

"Oh! Hermione Granger from Harry Potter!" Amina exclaims, suddenly recognizing the outfit.

"Finally!" Stacy exclaims and plops down on the couch.

"Well, that's forty seconds!" Candace announces. "Next up is Lynn and Beth!"

Beth takes a card from Candace and reads it. She pauses and swallows dryly before looking at Lynn and asking, "How badly do you want to win this?"

Lynn quirks her eyebrow, "What are you talking about? Of course I want to win this. You want to have to do a dare?"

Beth takes a deep breath and exhales. "Alright..." she slowly responds, "Let's give this a try..." she nods to Candace to signal that she's ready.

"Three! Two! One! Go!" Candace counts off before starting her timer.

Beth pulls out a string shouldered cocktail dress and puts it onto Lynn. The brunette then walks over to the table where the snacks and drinks are and picks up a bottle of juice. She hesitates for a moment.

"What are you doing?" Lynn asks warily. Beth remains silent but approaches Lynn with the bottle. A realization comes to Lynn and she backs off, "Don't you dare!" Stacy giggles and grabs Lynn by the arms, catching on to the act. "No! OMG! Beth, if you dump that on me, I swear you will live to regret it!" Lynn's eyes are wide with panic as she can't escape her friend's grip. Beth backs off, balked by the threat.

"Does that mean you forfeit?" Stacy asks Lynn, "I'll make sure to come up with a really good dare when me and Amina win!"

"How are you so sure she's going to dump it on you anyways?" Amina asks.

"Fine! Do whatever!" Lynn says, giving up the fight. Beth promptly turns the bottle over on Lynn's head, dumping the liquid all over her. "AAAGH!" Lynn cries out as she gets soaked in soda. Her hair is dripping beverage all over the carpet. Lynn pants as shock overtakes her. "What the hell?!" she cries out as she pulls at the dress that sticks to her skin.

"You still haven't guessed yet," you point out, shaking your head at the mess on the floor.

"Oh! Carrie! From the movie Carrie!" Lynn shouts out as the reference hits her.

"I wouldn't have dumped it on you if you'd have guessed sooner!" Beth laments.

"Well excuse me, I was trying to protect myself!" Lynn replies. She wipes off the excess soda and peels off the dress, wringing it onto the floor.

"Now stop that!" you cry out.

"Blame Beth, she dumped it on me!" Lynn retorts.

"At least do it in the bathroom," you say. Lynn shrugs and walks her naked, caffeine soaked butt to the washroom, "And feel free to shower off while you're there," you add.

"Should we wait for her to get back?" Stacy asks. Amina and Candace are already drying off the soda area.

"Well, we can continue until she's up again," Candace says, dropping a soaked towel into the bin. "We're next up, Riley, are you ready?" You nod and Candace passes the stopwatch to Stacy. "Lynn and Beth's time is thirty five seconds, so we'll have to do better if we want to take the lead."

You strip down to your underwear and take the center. Beth, Stacy and Amina line the couch while Candace picks a card at random. She takes a quick look and then nods to Stacy, passing her the answer card.

"Ready, set go!" Stacy calls out then starts the timer.

Candace quickly pulls out a long gown dress and you both struggled to get yourself into it. She then pulls out a crown and puts it on your head. You guess a queen or a princess, but it doesn't seem to be specific enough. You could always cheat and wish for the answer.