Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by The Smutsketeer The Smutsketeer

What's next?

Halloween with Carmen

The two of you came back to your apartment, tipsy and very horny. You'd been almost unable to stop touching her and you'd been very much unable to stop looking at her firm tits and round ass. Likewise whenever she got the chance, Carmen had ground her ass against your groin, making it very hard not to have your way with her. You'd managed, though. Somehow. All the longing glances you'd gotten from other women that weren't your fiancée hadn't helped, either. It wasn't that odd with you packing a lot of heat in your admittedly too-tight pants, with you aroused on top of that. You knew you could've hooked up with anybody at the party, but you didn't want anybody else. All you wanted was your future wife. As soon as you got home, you pushed her up against the hallway wall and kissed her. She wasn't even surprised; Carmen began kissing back immediately, moving her hips against your crotch as you made out.

Please log in to view the image

"You are so fucking hot" Carmen said after breaking the kiss. "I got to have you."

"You'll get me" you promised. "Now show me those tits."

"You like them, huh?" your fiancée asked as she pulled her top down.

"I love them" you said. "Can I fuck them?"

"Get naked first and I'll consider it" she replied. You had rarely gotten naked for her as quickly as you did then. "There you go" Carmen said, smiling. She kissed you again while stroking you, her long, slender fingers toying with your shaft, your balls, and your tip. You moaned into her mouth as you were so very, very horny and sensitive. While she toyed with your sex, you groped her tits, feeling up her soft, beautiful, bouncy tits. Her nipples had been hard for a while, but there was a difference seeing her pokies and feeling them rubbing against your palms.

"So how about it? Will I get to fuck your wonderful tits?" you asked.

"Come on then" she said, getting down to her knees. She took your cock between her lips first, sucking on you a while to get you nice and lubed up, before grabbing a hold of your cock and grinning.

"What is it?" you asked.

"I'm getting a message from beyond" she said. She gave your cockhead a kiss then started moving your cock across her chest.

"F" you said. "U..C..K..M..E..H..A..R..D."

"Oh, how spooky" Carmen said, grinning, gathering a drop of pre from your tip and licking it up. "Maybe you should ask the board a question."

"Spirits, do you want me to fuck my fiancée up the ass?" you asked.

"Ooh" she giggled, "that's a great question." She angled your cock to her right eye, indicating a very clear answer.

"Well, there you have it" you said, your cock throbbing in her grasp. "The spirits want me to fuck your asshole."

"Great idea" Carmen said, licking her lips. "Any more questions?"

"A few" you said with a smirk on your lips. "Spirits, if we ever have another threesome, who should we ask?" You were curious what Carmen would say, so you paid close attention. "R...O...S..." you spelled out, grinning when you realised who she meant. "Really, spirits?"

"The spirits have spoken" Carmen said. "Oh, there's more coming through." She continued spelling out names, making you grin. There were a lot of girls your fiancée wouldn't mind getting with, apparently. She'd spelled out the name of Katie, a hairdresser in town that she was a regular client of, as well as the new dentist, Hannah, and Tiffany, one of the lawyers working for your mom's company that you'd met at company parties you'd taken Carmen to as your plus one.

"The spirits sure are eager for a lot of threesomes" you said.

"They sure are. I guess we'll have to make it a reality, huh?" Carmen told you.

"We might" you replied. "But they also wanted you to take it up the ass."

"Absolutely. But maybe you should ask them how to start" your lover suggested.

"Spirits" you said, "how should me and my beautiful wife-to-be get started tonight?" With a grin Carmen moved your cock again, making it point at the numbers this time. "6 and 9" you read out.

"Well, you heard them" Carmen said. She pushed you away, so you scooted over and let Carmen get undressed further. Soon she was fully naked, gloriously so, and pushed you on your back. No more words were needed, so she sat down on your face, giving you easy access to her pussy. It was already wet, so you dug right in, foregoing any foreplay and going to town on Carmen. Before long, she started grinding against you, rubbing her beautiful pink cunt on your face. You didn't mind one bit as her tangy pussy tasted fantastic. As you pushed your tongue inside and wriggled it around, the beauty moaned out loud before leaning forward and taking your cock in hand. "It's so fucking big..." she mumbled between sucks on your cockhead. "This thing should be illegal."

"Like you mind" you told your fiancée.

"I will gladly shelter this from the state" Carmen said with a giggle, kissing your tip. Every time she kissed your cock or sucked on it, she let out a soft moan. She got pleasure from sucking on you as much as getting pleasured herself, you knew that by now.

"It won't fit in your mouth, though" you told her. "Well, not if you want to breathe, anyway."

"Good point" the beautiful brunette said. She sat up straight, allowing you to eat her pussy for a while longer before dismounting your face. With a smile she turned around, sitting down again, sandwiching your cock between her thighs. Leaning in, your fiancée kissed you deeply, moving her hips slowly. "Give it to me good, huh?" she asked.

"Yes ma'am" you said, reaching down to grope her perky ass. "Do you mind if we make out for a while first?"

"Is this about the making out or grabbing my ass?" she asked.

"Can't we do both, like I already am?" you wanted to know.

"Sure" Carmen said with a smile, kissing you again. For a long time the two of you just made out, grinding against each other while you kept fondling Carmen's sweet ass. A few times you teased at her asshole, making her gasp in pleasure. Over the months you'd been together she'd really started loving anal, to the point where there were times she went out with vibrating anal beads you could turn on with the push of a button on your phone using an app.

"You like that, huh?" you said.

"For sure" she said, her smile turning into a grin. "I mean, the spirits did tell you to fuck my ass."

"Who am I to argue?" you asked, kissing her again. "So come and get it."

"Yes, daddy" Carmen replied, kissing you before moving so that her pussy was just grazing your cock. She sank down on it every so briefly before pulling away again, leaving you disappointed.

"Don't leave me hanging, baby" you told her.

"Don't worry" she replied, "I just needed to get you a little more slippery. Here.." She took your cock in hand and shifted a little so that your cock was pushed against her sphincter. "Happy now?"

"Almost" you said, putting your hands on her hips and pulling her down slowly so that your cock started filling up her ass. Letting out a long moan, your fiancée took you up her shitpipe, her back arching.

"Yeah.." she moaned, "you feel so good in my ass!"

"You love it?" you asked, hoping to draw her into more dirty talk.

"Fuck yes! I've loved it ever since we tried it for the first time. Oh, John" she said, gripping her tits before looking down at you. "I love how fucking obscene it is to have a cock bigger than my fucking arm up my ass! "

"Ah, fuck" you said, your cock throbbing as Carmen started to ride it. You absolutely loved hearing the beautiful young woman talk dirty, because she looked so wholesome and innocent. You'd loved finding out she was incredibly slutty, to the point where she'd become addicted to your cum.

"What's that? Does my future husband love it when I ride him while saying filthy things?" she asked.

"For sure" you said, nodding. "Your ass is still so fucking tight."

"Any hole is going to be tight for your massive dick, baby" Carmen said, leaning in to kiss you again while starting to roll her hips. "Like Rose's, or Katie's, or Hannah's, for instance." She grinned as she saw your reaction, but mostly felt it. Hearing her talk about the people she wanted to rope into a threesome made your cock throb. "Yeah, I thought as much." She leaned in and kissed you again, grinning afterwards to stroke your cheek with a single finger. "I can tell you like it. Who do you want to fuck the most, baby?"

You considered this for a moment. "They are all good choices" you told her, moaning softly when your beautiful fiancée started talking about the girls.

"I know. Rose is so beautiful but may be a little too prudish. Still, if we could get her into our bed I bet she'd be such a little whore" Carmen said, moving a little faster. "Katie's a sexy little thing, too. Sometimes when she has to lean in to take something off the counter and her tits are pushed up against my head. I always get so wet when I feel her soft tits, baby."

"So that's why you always want to fuck after you get home from an appointment with her?" you asked, sudden understanding dawning.

"Oh yeah" your lover said, grinning broadly. "She's bustier than Alison, so I hope you pick her. I want to motorboat her big, soft tits."

"There's still Hannah" you pointed out. "I want to fuck her tight little ass, too. But mostly her throat."

"Oh, you're so nasty, baby" Carmen said.

"It's only fair" you said with a grin. "She puts things in my mouth whenever I see her. I just want to return the favour." This made Carmen laugh happily.

"I'm sure she'll thank you for it, too. As soon as she catches a glimpse of your tongue depressor, she'll be all over you, I'm sure of it" she said.

"Like you were?" you asked, smiling as you pulled her closer, kissing her one more time.

"For sure. Now how about you flip me over and fuck my ass missionary style while you decide who we're going to seduce, huh?" she suggested. You did just that and began to thrust into her, making out with your fiancée in the mean time.

"Ah..yeah, give it to me, baby! Fuck my ass! But you have to tell me who you want with us the next time we have a threesome! Please, tell me while you fuck me!" Carmen exclaimed.

Who do you pick?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)