Go help her, alone.

"Wait here for a moment," you tell Kyle, "I'll be right back."

"The call of nature?" he asks.

"Something like that," you tell him.

As you approach the forest and get closer and closer you begin to make out details of the girl. It is Scarlett! You jog your way over. Her arms are latched around a small tree, bound by handcuffs.

"How'd this happen?" you ask her.

"I don't want to talk about it..." she replies, glowing red, "I was tricked. I've been stuck here for about ten minutes and I don't know when he'll be back."

"When who will be back?" you ask.

"This guy, he had a magician's outfit and a man-bun. Listen, I thought it was a magic trick. It wasn't a magic trick though. It was just a trick. Now I am stuck."

"Hasn't anybody ever told you not to go into the woods with creepy men?" you ask.

"I wasn't alone. There were these girls, too, and these old ladies just on that path over there, but then I was blindfolded for the trick and when he took the blindfold off everybody was gone. Don't think I'm stupid or anything."

You give her a smile and inspect the cuffs. They're police grade. You certainly can't break them.

"I have a bobby pin in my back pocket," she says, "The left one. Grab it and help me get out."