Get your trunks back.

You get up out of the water. From the other side of the pool, Carly makes an embarrassed gasp and looks away. Ignoring that, you chase after the swim trunk thief. Abigail yelps and makes a run for it. Being an excellent swimmer doesn’t necessarily make her an excellent runner though. The athletic swimmer proves this when, making a sharp turn, she slips and falls. You lunge in to catch her!

The two of you tumble in a somersault, then roll around some more until you find yourself on top of her, face to face. You stare at each other for an awkward pause before realizing that your male member is pinned firmly against her abdomen. Blushing red, you promptly pull yourself off to the side. Abigail’s eyes immediately go down to what has just been touching her. Your cheeks burn harder and you cover up with your hands.

The trunks thief tosses your property back to you with a smirk, then gets back to her feet and dives into the water. You pull your shorts back on and look out for her. She’s already on the other side of the pool, chatting it up with Carly. They look at you and then giggle amongst themselves. With a sigh, you resign yourself to enjoying some time in the pool.

The cool water is soothing against the muggy night air. You swim a few laps around the pool, then relax by the edge. The girls have kept to themselves for the time being, although you do catch them glimpsing at you every so often. Lynn is enjoying a float on an innertube. You swim up and quietly ask her, “Is it just me, or are those two up to something.”

Lynn partway opens her eyes, then turns her head toward the girls in question. She looks, then goes back to her napping position. She utters back, “They’re definitely conspiring.”

This news doesn’t put you at ease, but Lynn offers nothing more so you go back to swimming around. Soon, the girls swim up to you looking excited with Carly showing signs of nervousness.

“Hey, Riley!” Abigail greets.

You clutch your shorts defensively.

“Don’t worry, I’m not going to steal your shorts,” Abi laughs. “In fact, I thought I’d make up to you for that prank…” You raise your eyebrow, questioningly. Abigail takes that as a sign to continue. She says, “Well, since we all got a good look at you, I thought you might like to get a good look at one of us back…” Your eyes widen, revealing the flaw in your poker face. Abigail grins wide, then adds, “Only you have to play a game first.”

“Hmm…” you grimace, “I’m not too keen on games…” Especially if it’s like the ones Lynn likes to play. You keep that to yourself though since Lynn is within earshot.

“Oh, this will be a fun one!” Abigail says, looking to Carly and smiling. Carly looks away but gives off an impish grin as well. “All you have to do is wait here!”

“Alright…” you say, waiting for the redhead to explain further. The girls look at each other and giggle, then scamper off the deck and onto the lawn. “What are you doing?” you call out.

“Just wait and see!” Abigail calls out from the darkness.The deck is raised high enough above the lawn that you can be hidden from view if you were on the ground. Compound that with the dim lighting; you can’t make out anyone beyond the deck railings.

A moment later, you see two lady’s speedos tossed onto the deck, one from the left side, the other from the right side.

“Now pick!” Abigail calls out.

You might be able to deduce the wearers of the swimsuits if you could match their scents, or find any stray hairs in the fabric, but the fact that Abigail said that from the right side of the deck makes the choices pretty obvious. Now it’s time to decide which girl you want to see naked more.