Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by HipsDontLie HipsDontLie

How will you catch on?

Fuck to exhaustion

Later, Carrie would have to explain to you how things ended up this way. But it wasn't the right time for that. Cassidy was panting and drooling, her tits freed from her bra bouncing everytime her sister entered her pussy with a vigorous thrust, her beautiful piercing blue eyes blurred by the pleasure she was experiencing for the very first time. Your dick was already erect and you had already removed your jacket and shirt and had already walked the distance between the door and the girls when you thought about asking "Mind if I join the fun?"

Your girlfriend laughed "Because you think that's optional?" She grabbed her little sister by her brunette mane and **** her to raise her head to your crotch's level. "Now, Cass, be a good slut and suck this delicious cock."

The younger girl blinked and looked at you as if she was waking up from a dream. "Are you sure?" she asked with apprehension. "He's your boyfriend, you're really okay with that?"

"For fuck sake, you two really do the pair." Carrie sighed. "I didn't just allow you to suck his dick, I ordered you to do so!" She ponctuated her admonition with a slap on her sister's ass, to which she reacted with an excited squeal. Cassidy's hesitatance was now gone, an hungry smile on her face she quickly unbuckled your pants and extracted your dick from it.

"Oh my god, I never imagined it to be so soft yet so hard!" she exclaimed before licking it. "Hmmm... And it tastes so good!"

Carrie chuckled, still ramming her pussy. "So you're my sister, after all." she remarked before taking adventage of her hold on her hair to **** her to take your dick in her mouth. The little brunette instantly started pumping heagerly.

"Oh fuck! It's like she was born for that!" you moan. And she trully did a really good job, especially for a first time. It was like she instinctively knew how to place her throat and how to use her tongue and lips.

Your girlfriend smiled and intensified both her penetration in her sibling's vagina and the rythm of the blowjob. "I guess it runs in our blood."

Cassidy didn't last long before tensing her body and letting out a long moan muffled on your shaft, as her sister had just driven her to orgasm -for the heighth time this afternoon, you would learn later. The sheer hotness of the scene made your cock twitch and spurt in her mouth. Carrie let you spit a few drops in her sister's mouth before pulling her by the hair so you could spray her cute, innocent face with your cum. The younger girl was panting heavily abandoned in her elder sibling's arms, white sticky strands crossing her nose and cheeks, her angelic blue eyes full of devilish lust despite the weariness. It was a vision of perversion of the innocence and this realisation turned you on even more. Your depraved girlfriend was cupping her little sister's tits and licking your sperm from her face, but you were too horny to let them have a break. You suddenly grabbed the very recently deflowered brunette by her waist and lifted her, ignoring her surprised yelp to lay her down on the dining table. You then seized her fishnetted thighs to have her lift her legs in a V and entered her wet pussy. You were amazed by how tight and well lubrificated she was, so much so that despite your dick being squeezed way more than you were used to, it was also the first time you penetrated a girl so deeply and with such ease on your very first thrust.

She arched her back yelling "Oh fuck yes! It's so good!" and you started hammering her frantically.

Not one to stay by the side and watch, Carrie climbed the piece of furniture and sat on her sister's face, facing you. "Now, Cass, show me you remembered how I made you moan." She instantly started moaning when Cassidy's tongue began to dance on her clit and labias, while her cadet's hands started caressing massaging her hips and rump.

All three of you were lost in pleasure and passion. You leaned forward to kiss your sexy devious girlfriend impetuously and wispered "I love you." while ravaging her baby sister's tight pussy.

"You better do." she simply replied with a grin and a wink.

Soon after, all three of you came in unison, and you filled the younger woman's unprotected womb with your seeds.


The rest of the evening is blurry in your mind. You remember turning Cassidy face down, her legs hanging from the tabletop, and deflower her asshole. She's even tighter there, and looks like she enjoys it even more than in her cunt. Carrie lies down besides you in the exact same position as her sister, so Cassidy and you can finger both of her holes at the same time. When you discharge your juice in the cadet's anus, you pull out to immediately do the same to the elder. Then you have memories of all three of you fucking in the bathtub. It's sloppy and uncomfortable, but you're all too drunk on wine and sex to care. You lick your own semen out of somebody's vagina at some point. You're tied to a chair watching the girls enjoying each other and you're forbidden from moving. It may have been your idea. But they take pity on you or can't do without your dick so you end up being used as a dildo on a chair. You try to fuck on the stair. It's a terrible idea, you can't remember why but you has no difficulty believing it once you sobered up. At some point Cassidy open the door, wearing only her stockings and garterbelt and covered in your sperm, and she spends a lot of time explaining to the delivery man who brought you pizzas that no, it's not a porn setting, while he tries to answer that he just want to be paid and that no, he didn't mean with sex. You end up giving him money, probably too much considering you asked yourself the next day where your fifty bucks had gone, and you're not sure wether or not Carrie gave him a blowjob. Maybe it was the second delivery man. Anyway, you only stopped fucking when none of you could keep their eyes open.


"Hey!"You woke up with difficulties to the sound of Carrie's voice. To your amazement, you're in your bed with your girlfriend by your side and her sister resting on top of you. "Hmmm... What time is it."

"It doesn't matter. I just wanted to tell you something." she answers with a sultry smile.

"What is it?" you ask, wondering what kind of perverse plan she can be up to now.

"I love you too."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)