Flare Bolt its eye.

Niki and the beast stare one another down as you ponder your next move. Her own piercing glare is just as intimidating as the giant's. As they continue this, you notice something odd. The cyclops' brow twitches, and he stops attacking. Niki gazes up in terror as the unthinkable occurs--the hefty, swinging cock starts to rise. It's like a monster in itself as it grows to twice its size, and extends upwards, casting a shadow down upon the warrior. Amara and Eva flush red as they stare, and you can't help watch in awe. Though, you shake it off, and take this opportunity to make your move.

While Niki stands stunned at the massive cock looming over her, you have the perfect spell for this. As you move, you raise your sword up and point the tip forwards--gaze looking down the steel as you try to level it out with the creature's eye. You focus your mana and the weapon once again begins to illuminate. It's now or never, so you shout the words required, and unleash the fury of your spell.

"Flare Bolt!" A fiery bullet of energy careens through the air, and it collides perfectly into his eye. He removes a hand from his weapon to cover the pain, and Niki spots the opportunity for a counterattack.

She swings her mace, and slams it against the side of his kneecap with all of her might. Her pure strength causes the leg to buckle, and he crashes down onto his hands and knees--club rolling to the ground. Meanwhile, Eva unleashes a second Magic Bolt, which impacts with his upper arm. You reach him at that point, and pivot your body in a pirouette to slice open his leg. The barrage of attacks leaves the cyclops helpless. With one final move, Niki leaps up, shifts around his protruding member, and slams her mace down against his throat. The monster coughs out one more time before he falls limp. The party pants heavily, and rests to regain their breath.

"Uh. Cyclopses are like evil, right? There wouldn't be a quest to kill something innocent. I hope," you say after looking over the creature's corpse.

Eva nods. "Oh yes. They're a spawn of evil. Terrifying monsters that eat people, and when they aren't guarding treasure, they're rampaging through villagers and murdering innocent people for no reason other than to satisfy their own dark cravings."

That was a relieving answer, though that sounds horrifying. Also, is he seriously still full-mast?

"I got the eye," Niki says as she pops a white sphere nearly the size of a basketball out from the head. She turns it around, and the pupil stares back at you.

"Can you put that in a bag or something?" you ask.