Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 39 by Thalia80 Thalia80

What's next?

Events are getting faster

Sophie’s next day was free, so she was home all day. The boys were at the university, Dan until late at night, of course, but Jimmy only had classes in the morning. Sophie took advantage of being alone and invited Kristy over, as she had a lot to share with her. Her friend listened to the new events with her mouth agape.

"I can't believe it! And Dan just stood there without saying a word while Jimmy shot all his cum on your face!?" she marvelled. "There's no way back now, girl. He's going to watch you get fucked by that huge cock. I think it turns him on."

"Come on. Forget it. We talked about it, and he said it didn't bother him, but next time it shouldn't be like that. And I assured him that he didn't have to worry. What happened didn't cause me any emotional damage."

"Of course not. It turned you on. I can see it."

"Well... actually, yes. You know, it was interesting to feel Dan's cock in my mouth while tasting Jimmy's cum."

"I believe you. So? When are you going to fuck him?"

"Me? Don't be ridiculous. Never." Sophie's eyes widened.

"Haha. Just like you'll never give him a blow job, right?" Kristy asked sarcastically. "Listen. I think it's just a small step from here to the next level. He ate you out, you gave him a blow job, and you swallowed his cum in front of your boyfriend. Don't kid yourself. You're going to do it anyway," her friend argued.

Sophie couldn't decide if she really wanted to be faithful or if she just thought she would be faithful but secretly wanted what Kristy was saying.

"Listen. If you don't do it, I will. Someone has to try that huge dong." The girl declared boldly.

"No way. You'd better not get involved in this."

"Why not? That cock deserves it." At first, Kristy meant it as a joke, but Sophie's resistance encouraged her to push further. Slowly, she became more and more determined that Jimmy would lose his virginity anyway. "I think you'd remember it for the rest of your life. And I'm sure he wants it too. When is Dan coming home today?"

"I don't know. Late. Why...? No. I'm not going to have sex with him today," Sophie replied, understanding her friend's hint.

"Then I'll take on this noble task myself," she said with a broad smile. At first, she really just wanted to push Sophie into it, but the more they talked about it, the more she wanted to experience the monster herself. She remembered the moment when she touched him in the dressing room and felt heat in her groin.

"And what about your boyfriend?"

"You're really asking me that?" Kristy asked the legitimate question. "Anyway, everyone deserves a little fun. If he finds out, I'll let him fuck someone else. That's how men work." Sophie wasn't so sure about that, but then her friend interrupted her and headed for the bedrooms.

"Hey! Wait. What are you doing?" She called after her friend and realized that she really wanted to do it. She didn't know what her plans were, but knowing her friend, she had to stop her. However, she didn't succeed, because Kristy had already opened the nerd's door when she grabbed her arm. The sight froze them both in their tracks.

Jimmy was lying on his bed with his eyes closed, wearing a T-shirt and sweatpants, but he had taken out his hard-on and was jerking it off vigorously. He didn't even notice the two girls watching him masturbate from the doorway. In his mind's eye, he could see the two girls standing there, kneeling in front of him. Hearing the two friends talking, his imagination was involuntarily aroused, and he had to do something. His rod stood hard, towering over his body lying on the bed. It rose like a flagpole from the lying figure. The two voyeurs stared at it with their mouths open.

For a moment, Kristy was unsure if this was a good idea, and she was about to close the door when the nerd suddenly opened his eyes, as if he sensed someone was there. He shuddered at the sight but didn't even try to cover himself. Holding his thick cock in his hand, he stared silently at the girls staring at him. His manhood throbbed in his hand and almost burst with excitement. He knew that the two friends had come for this reason and didn't want to disappoint them by getting dressed. Finally, Sophie spoke first, breaking the awkward silence.

"We just... wanted to ask... if..."

"Actually, Sophie told me about your little game, and well... I was curious. It's just a pure coincidence that we walked in on you like this. I should mention that you could lock the door in situations like this." Her friend intervened.

"Actually, I didn't expect you to see me. Anyway, there's nothing here that you haven't seen before." Jimmy smiled. Sophie looked at her friend in confusion, then remembered the day they took her into the dressing room.

"Wait. So you... Kristy! I thought we discussed everything." She scolded her friend, but she didn't feel any real anger towards her.

"I'm sorry. I think you know best when temptation is just an arm's length away." Then she slowly walked toward the nerd, who watched the girl approaching him with wide eyes.

Sophie's blood ran cold at her friend's boldness, and she just watched the events unfold from the doorway. She couldn't believe Kristy was so reckless. She sat down on the bed next to the motionless guy and, without asking any questions, reached out her hand and wrapped her fingers around his rod. She began to stroke his cock with slow movements and watched triumphantly as Jimmy threw his head back and enjoyed it. He closed his eyes again and enjoyed being pleasured by someone else's hand instead of his own. Kristy motioned to her friend, who quickly closed the door so that Dan, who might be coming home, wouldn't see anything, and she walked uncertainly toward the bed. 'I'm not normal,' she thought to herself, but she followed her besties’ example and sat down on the other side of Jimmy on the bed, and with her hand outstretched, she also began to work on the huge monster. Jimmy looked up for a moment and groaned loudly as he saw both girls jerking his cock in unison. Every vein was rock hard, and he thought he was going to explode right there and then. He had to close his eyes again and concentrate so as not to cum early. The girls watched mesmerized as his foreskin moved up and down over his swollen, shiny glans; Jimmy's cock was already quite wet.

"I think I need some help here, Sophie. This is huge," Kristy said, and added her other hand to assist. So now three small palms were gripping and stroking his massive member, but Sophie also joined in with her other hand, which she used to massage Jimmy's large balls. The touch of four hands gave the nerd incredible pleasure, and he thought he was dreaming. Then a completely new sensation startled him. When he opened his eyes, he saw Kristy bobbing her head up and down on his cock with practiced movements. The pressure of the hands did not ease, but now the girl's mouth joined in as well. She thoroughly explored every inch of the glans with her tongue and played with the salty precum. When she lifted her head, a shiny string was still hanging from her lips, and she smiled at Sophie.

"Mmmm. You have to taste this. I know you've already felt it, but it's so different from my boyfriend's. It makes me so wet. Sophie! How have you not fucked this huge cock yet? I don't know how you can resist him." Seeing her friend's hesitation, she began to push her head down with her hand so that she could also take Jimmy's manhood into her mouth.

Please log in to view the image

Sophie didn't resist for long and let her friend take control. It didn't take much time before the two girls were taking turns sucking his huge cock, working on it nonstop. Jimmy didn't know how far the girls wanted to go, but he felt that if this continued, he would soon cum. He thought it was time to give it a try.

"Okay, girls. I think it's time to return the favor." To his surprise, Kristy immediately smiled and, leaving Sophie alone with the monster, began to undress. The other two watched with wide eyes as the blonde removed every piece of clothing.

"What's up, guys? You've both seen it all before. Nothing new here." With that, she climbed back onto the bed and knelt directly over Jimmy. Sophie couldn't believe her eyes, and Jimmy was amazed. A few inches from his head was a wet pussy, and all he had to do was stick out his tongue. "Now show me what you can do, big boy!" And with that, Kristy sat on the nerd's face, pushing her private parts right into his face. Jimmy didn't know what to do, so he just started working, just like he had licked Sophie earlier. He could feel that Kristy was extremely excited, and he enjoyed the slightly different taste of her new pussy filling his mouth. He gave it his all and almost devoured the dirty blonde girl's crotch.

Sophie stared at her friend with her mouth open and for a moment forgot about the cock throbbing in her hands. However, its twitching snapped her back to reality, and she threw herself back into sucking with great pleasure. 'What the hell are we doing?' she asked herself as Jimmy's musky-smelling cock filled her mouth and she licked the salty precum off it with relish. With a loud smack, she let go and decided it was time to get rid of her clothes too. Jimmy didn't even notice that there was one less girl pleasuring him, so absorbed was he in licking pussy.

After Sophie slowly stripped completely naked, she watched the other two for a while. Their bodies moved in perfect harmony, and she felt a little jealous of Kristy. She stared at her round boobs, which Jimmy was already fondling vigorously. 'I wish I had tits like that.' But she didn't sit around for long. She climbed back onto the bed just as her bestie opened her eyes and beckoned her over, pointing commandingly at Jimmy's erect penis. Sophie's eyes widened; she wasn't sure she could do it. Not because she wouldn't enjoy it, but because of Dan. 'I've sat on him like this before. This isn't sex. This isn't cheating. I'm just getting closer and sitting on his lap.' She slowly started to move, and her friend smiled as she saw the struggle in Sophie's eyes. She knew she wanted it, but her loyalty to Dan was so strong that it held her back.

'It's okay, baby girl. You'll feel it inside you by the end of the night anyway,' Kristy said to herself. 'You just need a little push.' Meanwhile, Sophie sat on the nerd's lap and sighed loudly as his hot cock touched her slit. She was already dripping wet, so she started slipping on it in a matter of seconds, and now all three of their bodies were moving in rhythm.

Please log in to view the image

At that moment, Kristy lifted herself up slightly, leaving a wet stain on Jimmy's face, but she didn't go far; she just turned around and faced Sophie. She leaned forward a little and kissed her girlfriend on the mouth, which surprised Sophie. However, she didn't resist but kissed her back, and now their tongues were dancing. Both of them were increasingly carried away by passion and were no longer thinking rationally, just letting their desires guide them. Meanwhile, their hands were exploring each other's bodies more and more. Sophie happily grabbed Kristy's large breasts, feeling their softness. Her friend played with her already hard nipples, but with her other hand she rubbed her besties' clit, while the girl didn't stop sliding on the huge cock. Sophie was lost in the sensation. Kristy looked down at Jimmy's erect, swollen cock as it stretched Sophie's pussy lips with its thickness and sighed loudly. She looked at her girlfriend and silently formed the words, 'You have to fuck him!'

Sophie swallowed hard, and her eyes widened as she thought about what it would be like if Jimmy penetrated her right now. Nevertheless, she shook her head. She didn't want to give herself completely to the nerd; Dan was still in her thoughts.

"Okay. Then I'll do it," she said, lifting herself off Jimmy's face, who was drowning in licking her pussy. Sophie was completely shocked and could only obey as Kristy instructed her to move aside. Kristy quickly stripped Jimmy of his clothes, and now all three of them were naked on the bed. Sophie sat down next to Jimmy on the bed and watched as her friend took her place.

'I shouldn't let her. That cock is mine. It belongs to me. I'm the one who brought him all the way to this point.' Sophie was no longer thinking about Dan but about how she should be in Kristy's place. She felt a strong urge to take back her place and be the first to be penetrated by Jimmy's thick cock. However, she couldn't move, she couldn't do it, and she watched with trembling excitement as Jimmy pressed his swollen cock against the blonde's oozing wet opening. Her pussy juices literally flew down onto the nerds' flagpole. Holding back her breath, Sophie watched as the shiny glans stretched the pussy lips at first, then the throbbing shaft pushed deeper and deeper into the girl. The pussy lips stretched to their limits and wrapped around the nerd's hard rod. At that moment, Kristy moaned loudly, and Sophie looked at her in horror. But she calmed down when she saw that her friend was moaning not from pain but from pleasure. She was amazed that the guy's cock had barely penetrated the girl and was already having such an effect on her. 'I wonder what it feels like. But Dan...'

Please log in to view the image

Jimmy couldn't believe he was slowly penetrating the first pussy of his life, inch by inch. He loved how her hot hole wrapped around his manhood. He almost exploded inside her honeypot as her hot, wet pussy slid further and further onto his hard-on, giving him intense pleasure. When he caught his breath a little, he glanced at Sophie, who was lying next to them.

"Do you like the view, Sophie?" Jimmy's question snapped the girl out of her thoughts, and she looked at the nerd, whose face was still glistening with Kristy's juices, and a broad smile spread across his mouth. She was sure that he had been waiting for this since he moved here, maybe even longer, and now it had become a reality for him. The girl smiled back and leaned closer to him. Without thinking, she kissed him and closed her eyes to taste her girlfriend's juices on the nerd's lips. They began to kiss passionately, and Jimmy touched her more boldly, his hands exploring every inch of her body. He grabbed her ass, started fingering her, and squeezed her breasts more and more intensely. Kristy controlled the penetration, feeling the nerd go deeper and deeper into her pussy. When she looked down, she was shocked to see that he was about halfway in, but she already felt completely full.

"Oh! Fuuuck. Your cock is so huge. It's much bigger than my boyfriend's. You're stretching me so much. It feels so good." This disturbed the other two people, and they stopped kissing. They glanced at the blonde and both smiled. "Sophie, you have to try this too."

"What!? But I... wait!" Her protests were in vain, however, as Kristy reluctantly let go of Jimmy's cock, which slowly slipped out of her pussy. She felt incredibly empty, but she didn't mind. She thought Sophie should experience this too. She pushed her girlfriend onto all fours and motioned for Jimmy to kneel behind her. "Wait. This might not be a good idea... I don't think it will fit."

"I think it will. I saw how professionally you took that dildo," Jimmy mocked, taking a little confidence. Kristy glanced at him and winked. They both knew Sophie needed a little encouragement. This has the effect, as she waited silently and tremblingly for the others to take control. She was still not sure she could do it, but at that moment she felt his glans moistened by Kristy's pussy juices and Jimmy's precum at her opening, and all other thoughts vanished.

Please log in to view the image

True to her best friend, Kristy grabbed Jimmy's thick shaft and smiled as she helped him into Sophie's hole. Jimmy’s and Sophie's hearts were pounding in their throats. For both of them, fulfilment had finally arrived. The months of tension and flirting dissolved in this movement and moment, and they both moaned with relief at the moment they had both dreamed of for so long.

It's true that Sophie didn't take Jimmy's virginity literally, but it didn't really matter. Kristy's help was needed to give her friend the courage to take this step. Sophie didn't blame her friend for this, and what really mattered to Jimmy was that Sophie was finally his. He will never forget the feeling of her pussy wrapping around his cock for the first time, and the real emotional connection was between them. Very few people can say that they lost their virginity with two girls at the same time. The nerd's chest swelled with pride. Now he penetrated the girl more deeply and watched in amazement as his thick cock disappeared inch by inch into her.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)